Mystery Mafia 2- Game Over! But who won!?

[Dasquian]

Sigh. Bored of this game now.

[mnowax]

( the funny part is i m all outta knives) shush don'ttell anyone... )

[Patrick]

Sigh. Bored of this game now.

Who's scum?

[Dasquian]

I have no idea, mnowax won't agree to stop threatening everyone with murder long enough for us to play.

[ashmite84]

Sorry, just found this game. Will read and post.

[lord_hur]

its ok folks. i didn't bold the last one. this one i did. no kill will go thorugh.

Does your role speciafically says you can retract kills ? Because otherwise, I have trouble with the concept of resurrection...

( the funny part is i m all outta knives) shush don'ttell anyone... )

Now you're saying that the number of knives is limited ? Because if they are :

- Why the *hell* did you waste them on arbitrary killing ? You could have worked as a way to give town multiple lynches per day, as Patrick said... I won't really blame you, as 1/2 is hell of a good rating, but still, that's really irrational ;

- I can throw my best argument about your being town right into the bin (though some of it is left : it would still be extremely powerful for scum) ;

- Did you have 2 or 3 knives ? In short, was populartajo actually shot at or not ?

[lord_hur]

Can we have your word that you won't make any more kills without some prior discussion?

[Battle Mage]

Prodding Vel-Rahn Koon

[Dasquian]

OK, so that's proof that mnowax can legally retract his kills. mnowax, can we please have your agreement to some level of cooperation?

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

I'm here, sorry folks. Was busy all weekend watching a History channel special on WWII and the atomic bomb. Pretty cool stuff. I'll have another read through (besides the speed read I just did - WTF mnowax!?!?!) in the next few days. Have a newbie game going to night soon, so have to focus on that first.

[lord_hur]

OK, so that's proof that mnowax can legally retract his kills. mnowax, can we please have your agreement to some level of cooperation?

Wow. I was thinking this was unlikely, as the power would have unpredictable effects depending on the time BM checks the thread.

Seems I was wrong though.

It also means Alabaska J was killed by mistake, as mnowax apparently wanted to retract the kill and would have done so if he hadn't forgotten to bold it.

Does that mean he's been playing with us and was planning to retract it from the start ? Hmm I don't think so, as there are 13 hours between the kill order and the retractation - huge risk of BM coming and hammering him.

mnowax is still pro-town for me.

[lord_hur]

Claim : Miller.

Take that BM.

Claim : Jester.

The mod told me to.

@populartajo : are you saying your role post forces you to make random claims unless you get modkilled ? With what frequency, each page you post in ? every 2 real days ?

[mnowax]

it could happen.

[ashmite84]

'Kay, I'm good.

( the funny part is i m all outta knives) shush don'ttell anyone... )

Why would you admit to this? If you are town please stop being so erratic.

Sigh. Bored of this game now.

Who's scum?

Uh-huh.

[Nightson]

unvote

for now

[Battle Mage]

Vote Count

Mnowax 1 (Dasquian)

Not Voting: Populartajo, Patrick, DrippingGoofBall, Mnowax, Nightson, Ashmite84, Lord Hur, Greasy Spot, Vel-Rahn Koon

6 votes are currently required to lynch. You have less than 11 days until deadline.

[DrippingGoofball]

mnowax killed the game.

No one wants to say anything.

Maybe we can lynch populartajo? Only if this pleases mnowax of course. If it doesn't, I retract my statement, beg for my life and apologize.

[Dasquian]

I am interested in playing this game as soon as we get assurances from mnowax that he's not going to play homicidal overlord and at least attempt to cooperate.

[mnowax]

(HEY! i cant kill anyone !)

[Dasquian]

OK, but at some point in the future you may get a chance to kill again - don't respond to that, there's no need to overplay your hand if you won't, and no need to make yourself an obvious threat if you will. So,

on the basis that you will

(which may not be the case):

1) Will you agree not to kill anyone without opening it up for discussion?
2) Will you agree to take criticism and debate without resorting to threats?

Thanks.

Since we're here: why did you choose to kill the people you chose to kill? Detailed reasoning would be appreciated.

[mnowax]

ok i will. the first one was to show my power, the second one was an accident but i am now glad that it went thorugh anyway.

1:yeah sure
2: depends on how close you guys are to lynching me, but i can take the debate. if i get close( L-2 or closer), i can not say what i may do to get myself not lynched.

OK?

[Dasquian]

Not really, but at least we can proceed. Who do you think the scum are?

[mnowax]

you for one

DGB for t wo

[Dasquian]

OK... want to provide any reasonings there?

(I'm not scum, fwiw)

[mnowax]

you protested to much to me having sucha huge power for a dayvig, and you gave up instantly, as if you were scum.

DGB just sumbitted to me without any explanation buthe wats to survive. If you are town you win even if you dont survive. scum want to stay alive.