- Best Mafia CatcherSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: singersigner First: Oversoul Second: fferyllt
Nominated: Cephir First: pieguyn Second: Sakura Hana
Nominated: Titus First: Drixx Second:
- Nominated: singersigner First: Oversoul Second: fferyllt
- Most Cunning ManipulatorSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: TSO First: Aeronaut Second: Pine
Nominated: Titus First: Mastin2 Second: MathBlade
Nominated: sthar8 First: Metal Sonic Second: Nexus
Nominated: zMuffinMan First: FakeGod Second: notscience
Nominated: pirate mollie First: ika Second: Antihero
Nominated: RadiantCowbells First: Aneninen Second: Jake from State Farm
Nominated: Drixx First: Titus Second: Varsoon
Nominated: Postie First: wgeurts Second: RadiantCowbells
- Nominated: TSO First: Aeronaut Second: Pine
- Rising Star
Spoiler: Description- Nominated: Plotinus First: VysePresident Second: EVERYONE
Nominated: PantherPunt First: Performer Second: Some guy
Nominated: lalaladucks First: Metal Sonic Second: House
Nominated: Stabulous First: Nachomamma8 Second: Marquis
Nominated: Postie First: wgeurts Second: RadiantCowbells
- Nominated: Plotinus First: VysePresident Second: EVERYONE
- Best ReplacementSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Plotinus First: VysePresident Second: Voidedmafia
- Nominated: Plotinus First: VysePresident Second: Voidedmafia
- Best Contribution to Mafia DiscussionSpoiler: Description
- Funniest or Most Enjoyable PlayerSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Antihero First: hiplop Second: Untrod Tripod
Nominated: Shiro First: Firebringer Second:
- Nominated: Antihero First: hiplop Second: Untrod Tripod
- Best Performance Pro-Town TeamSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Town of Mini 1626: Duck Tales Mafia First: Mastin2 Second: None
Nominated: Town of Drawn on Arrival First: quadz08 Second: Marquis
Nominated: Town of Mini 1626: Duck Tales Mafia First: Mastin2 Second: ArcAngel9
Nominated: Town of Micro 488 First: Metal Sonic Second: None
Nominated: Town of Blitz 2 The Stars My Destination First: mastin2 Second: BBmolla
Nominated: Town of Suikoden U-Pick First: Titus Second: mastin2
Nominated: Town of MAFIACEPTION First: Glork Second: Plotinus
- Nominated: Town of Mini 1626: Duck Tales Mafia First: Mastin2 Second: None
- Best Performance Scum GroupSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Scum Team of Open 577: Hope Plus One First: Bookitty Second: Psyche
Nominated: Scum Team of Open 583: JK9++ First: Mastin2 Second: eyesott
Nominated: Scum Team of Reck's Retrospective Rehash First: xRECKONERx Second: singersinger
Nominated: Scum Team of FF7 Mafia First: ika Second: Antihero
- Nominated: Scum Team of Open 577: Hope Plus One First: Bookitty Second: Psyche
- Best Performance Third PartySpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Deasvail for his perfomance in Mini 1646: Quil's Smalltown First: xRECKONERx Second: Bookitty
Nominated: Marquis for his perfomance in NY 183 First: Antihero Second: The Bulge
Nominated: scotmany12 for his perfomance in Prozac's Basic Theme First: Porochaz Second: Davsto
Nominated: shos for his perfomance in Everything is a Lie First: Jake from State Farm Second: wgeurts
- Nominated: Deasvail for his perfomance in Mini 1646: Quil's Smalltown First: xRECKONERx Second: Bookitty
- Most Memorable EventSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Untrod Tripod & xRECKONERx First: xRECKONERx Second: TSO
Nominated: Belisarius for his Hammer First: pirate mollie Second: Witness Protection
Nominated: notscience for replacing into a scumslot and driving a D1 lynch on Town PR within 48 hours in New York 182 First: The Bugle Second: None
Nominated: BBmolla for that flip First: saulres Second: None
Nominated: Untrod Tripod for posting a bunch of song lyrics First: SleepyKrew Second: Oversoul
Nominated: Voidedmafia for continuing to play after end game First: Ms Marangal Second: sthar8
Nominated: This moment in Inorganic Chemistry First: mastin2 Second: Metal Sonic
Nominated: A simultaneous triple hammer First: Ankamius Second: Cheery Dog
Nominated: This post by Reasonably Rational First: Varsoon Second: Kligoncelt
Nominated: This vig shot by Salamence First: Davsto Second: Voidedmafia
Nominated: Shiro for this post First: Davsto Second: pieguyn
Nominated: notscience for this post First: Shady Second: hiplop
Nominated: THIS FUCKING VOTECOUNT First: BulletNLynchproof Second: None
Nominated: Davsto for this post First: xRECKONERx Second: Nexus
- Nominated: Untrod Tripod & xRECKONERx First: xRECKONERx Second: TSO
- Game of the Year- Awarded to the Moderator of the game.Spoiler: Description
- Nominated: Capcom Crossover Chaos First: pieguyn Second: Metal Sonic
Nominated: (Hilariously Unbalanced Mafia 2 First: Titus Second: Mastin2
Nominated: SMITE Mafia First: MetalSonic Second: Drixx
Nominated: Inorganic Chemistry Mafia First: mastin2 Second: None
Nominated: Steven Universe Mafia First: Metal Sonic Second: Drixx
Nominated: FF7 Mafia First: hiplop Second: pirate mollie
Nominated: Legend of the Hidden Temple II First: Firebringer Second: Titus
Nominated: Slavic Music Mafia First: Radiant Cowbells Second: Postie
- Nominated: Capcom Crossover Chaos First: pieguyn Second: Metal Sonic
- Best SetupSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Mastin2 for (Hilariously) Unbalanced Mafia 2 First: Titus Second: Voidedmafia
Nominated: hitogoroshi for Signs and Void First: Cheetory Second: Metal Sonic
Nominated: Marquis for Mini 1688: BEES!!! First: Not_Mafia Second: Fro99er
- Nominated: Mastin2 for (Hilariously) Unbalanced Mafia 2 First: Titus Second: Voidedmafia
- Best Flavor TextSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Sir Elton Hercules John for Mini 1628: Rick Santorum Saves Xmas First: Wisdom Second: TSO
Nominated: Serene2 for UnCouTh mAfia First: saulres Second: Bookitty
Nominated: Aeronaut for Delicious Mafia First: Bookitty Second: Zebulin
Nominated: Marquis for Mini 1657 First: DarkLightA Second: Metal Sonic
Nominated: Jingle for Micro 458 First: Skullduggery Second: Voidedmafia
Nominated: Magua for Mod Error Mafia First: saulres Second: shos
Nominated: Ether for Mini 1689 First: N Second: Plotinus
Nominated: Varsoon for Steven Universe Mafia First: mastin2 Second: Cerebus v666
- Nominated: Sir Elton Hercules John for Mini 1628: Rick Santorum Saves Xmas First: Wisdom Second: TSO
- Best MutationSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Ika for Mini 1638: Mafia Lottery First: eyesott Second: Silverwolf
Nominated: xRECKONERx for Reck's Retrospective Rehash First: ChannelDelibird Second: singersinger
Nominated: Self-Sensor for Mini 1630: Edgar Allan Poe uPick First: Nachomamma8 Second: Bookitty
Nominated: Mastin2 for (Hilariously) Unbalanced Mafia 2 First: Titus Second: theelkspeaks
Nominated: Varsoon for the Alliance Mechanic in Steven Universe Mafia First: Metal Sonic Second: Titus
Nominated: wgeurts for the Everything is a Lie First: shos Second: Psyche
- Nominated: Ika for Mini 1638: Mafia Lottery First: eyesott Second: Silverwolf
- Excellent Moderation
This is now a Body of Work awardSpoiler: Description
- Behind the ScenesSpoiler: Description
- Outstanding MishMash GameSpoiler: Description
- The Community Contributor AwardSpoiler: Description
- Nominated: Bicephalous Bob for chatmafia First: SleepyKrew Second: Cheetory6
Nominated: wgeurts for updating the wiki First: PokerFace Second: Psyche
- Nominated: Bicephalous Bob for chatmafia First: SleepyKrew Second: Cheetory6
- In order to be considered by the scummy judging committee, a nomination must be seconded.
- Self-nominations are allowed. However, they are generally frowned upon, particularly where the sole winner will be the nominator. It is expected that Most Enjoyable Game will be a self-nomination
- Nominations with LINKS and descriptions of why you wish to nominate a player or group of players are greatly appreciated.
- Please boldwho you are nominating and for what award.
- Please note these are the preliminary categories for the 2013 season. There may be changes.