Let's analyze more Gimli posts.
Is DE bleeding town? No. We will get to that. Or maybe he is but I doubt it. Haven't read all that crap.
340 is a nothing readlist.
344: First again a rather harsh view towards SRs posting. It's entirely natural to see a logical contradiction and if unresolved assume a less than towny motive for it. Especially when Gimli was the one pressing Black on her meta comment in the first place and couldn't let it go. So it could be connected to the intricate process of forming or faking reads. 2nd half of this post is basically gaslighting. Soul reads founded on nothing are scummy. And it isn't according to DE founded on nothing, It's Meta somehow, but really, its nothing and that's the point of calling attention to it.
351: From Gimli's perspective the Klick read makes sense. Will read Aureal and edit this but I forgot she was a player at one point.
379: Noting that Black never answered this akaik, but this is WIFOM. I believe we have been told that DE can be this confident as scum too. As for scum strategy, what if all the scum blatantly and absurdly townread each other over nothing? Never could happen right? that kind of thing could easily fuck with people's minds. I've experienced it (we as scum did did lose though). The point is that we cannot know it and speculation is WIFOMy. Also you had just said Klick is town because DE is hard to elim now so... the strategy seems to be working if that was it!
some posts about but mechanics; sure. It is understandable to be worried about a shit result if slide actually made it to the top 3 (despite what we actually got), and people's reasons for it were bonkers, but its possible they didn't understand rule 8 well at the time. On that note will say that post tally the fact that Car got 5 and sheep 8 might be an indication of scum influence. Will have to count votes.
579: Agree with SR read, and the reasons why. Had the same feeling wrt their early game mech talk and after reviewing the other two posts they can thinly be called town observations. On me my content is diametrically opposed to your own reads wondering how much that factored in instead of being overly critical. Entering some kind of null-scum into lets flip em read is jarring to me.
Aureal and Ali/MariaR I have to read more carefully. Agree with Hu Tao. Will edit
606: Turn around on Prism is pleasantly surprising. and good.
The next paragraph is something that is fundamentally wrong. I wonder if you actually believe it, I'm starting to believe that you do. There have been games I've played where stuff like that happens. "I'm town, are you town?" "Yeah I'm town lets rock!". Even for some reason it is true in this game, it is not indicative of being something that more often happens between town than between town and scum or scum and scum than probability would dictate. There isn't anything special going on between you and Kiri. And DE has already said that the reason he locked you as town was due to Meta. Now is what DE said too much for a scum player to go on a limb with? Maybe. I don't think I'd ever do that. But would a chaos prone guy without inhibitions do it as scum? completely possible.
Need to read CC and edit.
