Newbie 588 - Game Over!
-
-
The World No.1 Noob
-
-
Vel-Rahn Koon Virginia's Trump
- Virginia's Trump
- Virginia's Trump
- Posts: 6189
- Joined: March 1, 2007
- Location: Catawba College
Mafia, this vote doesn't count since you didn't unvote first, although it doesn't matter at this point. Sorry I missed the hammer vote yesterday when I looked at the thread. - VelMafiamurkrow wrote:Huh...erm,vote: no lynch.I have no leads and no idea otherwise, so I can't really lynch anyone.
Final Day 1 Vote Count
Cat_Killer - 2 (Abstract Actuary, Mafiamurkrow)
Mafiamurkrow - 5 (rolandofthewhite, goborage, Grum, camisade, The World No.1 Noob)
Not Voting - 2 (Cat_Killer, Dave)
5 to LynchThe Newbie Queue ALWAYS needs ICs and Mods!
Are you willing to help out? Check the Queue title to see what roles we need filled!-
-
Vel-Rahn Koon Virginia's Trump
- Virginia's Trump
- Virginia's Trump
- Posts: 6189
- Joined: March 1, 2007
- Location: Catawba College
"You call that a defense? That's the biggest load of nonsense I've ever heard!", exclaimed Abstract Actuary. The mumbles of consent from the rest of the Council members told Mafiamurkrow that he was indeed in trouble.
"But I'm...", begins Mafia. However, his statement goes unfinished as the chair is kicked out from under him by The World No.1 Noob. A bit hasty? Perhaps. Let's see what's in his pockets first.
Council ID card, bus pass, tickets to the opera...nope, nothing here that indicates scum. Oh well, I guess there's always tomorrow!
Mafiamurkrow,Townie, Lynched Day 1
Night has begun. Those of you with night actions must submit your choices by Saturday, April 12th.The Newbie Queue ALWAYS needs ICs and Mods!
Are you willing to help out? Check the Queue title to see what roles we need filled!-
-
Vel-Rahn Koon Virginia's Trump
- Virginia's Trump
- Virginia's Trump
- Posts: 6189
- Joined: March 1, 2007
- Location: Catawba College
Strange things are happening in your sleepy little town. You all arrive at the Town Council hall, and notice that no one is missing! Strange indeed...
Day 2 has begun. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.The Newbie Queue ALWAYS needs ICs and Mods!
Are you willing to help out? Check the Queue title to see what roles we need filled!-
-
Dave Townie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 69
- Joined: March 20, 2008
-
-
goborage Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 519
- Joined: March 20, 2008
- Location: Moe's Tavern Occupation: Bartender, Part-time Scumhunter
These two are the most suspicious in my eyes:
camisade - sends mafiamurkrow to -1, "I agree. Or just lynch her because I've gotten sick of her BS." Seems to be pushing for a quick-lynch.
The World No.1 Noob - hammers mafiamurkrow without allowing a role-claim. Claims townie even though he isn't the one under suspicion - over-defensive.
About the no nightkill: Are mafia obliged to kill someone nightly or should we assume that a doctor miraculously saved a townie?Well if you're so sure what it ain't, how about tellin' us what it am!-
-
camisade Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 176
- Joined: July 5, 2007
We didn't get anything relevant out of her ever, even when she was at L-1. All she posted was BS. Why sign up if you're not going to play the game?goborage wrote:These two are the most suspicious in my eyes:
camisade - sends mafiamurkrow to -1, "I agree. Or just lynch her because I've gotten sick of her BS." Seems to be pushing for a quick-lynch.
The World No.1 Noob - hammers mafiamurkrow without allowing a role-claim. Claims townie even though he isn't the one under suspicion - over-defensive.
About the no nightkill: Are mafia obliged to kill someone nightly or should we assume that a doctor miraculously saved a townie?
No nightkill: I've read a game before where a lone Mafia claimed doctor and chose to forgo night killing and bluffed by saying that he protected someone. So I'm guessing Mafia is allowed to do that, but maybe it varies from mod to mod. I'm not sure-
-
goborage Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 519
- Joined: March 20, 2008
- Location: Moe's Tavern Occupation: Bartender, Part-time Scumhunter
I think this post is suspicious. It's in the guise of someone trying to prevent a quick-lynch. But what AA is doing is summing up all the "scummy" actions that Mafiamurkrow has made and making a case to lynch.Abstract Actuary wrote:Based on these two posts it looks like Mafia Murkrow is at L-1.
Mod wrote:Official Vote Count
Cat_Killer - 2 (Abstract Actuary, Mafiamurkrow)
camisade - 1 (Dave)
Mafiamurkrow - 3 (rolandofthewhite, goborage, Grum)
Not Voting - 3 (camisade, Cat_Killer, The World No.1 Noob)
5 to Lynch
And at least one person who thinks he's suspicious enough to add the hammer.camisade wrote:
Ugh. Do you not have anything to say besides that?Mafiamurkrow wrote:AW BLEH. -has mysteriously disappeared for a while due to busynessism- I'm sorry for poofing. D=
vote: Mafiamurkrow
And all Mafiamurkrow has to say is . . .Cat_Killer wrote:Mafiamurkrow seems scummy to me. See:
That's... not a reason. Failing to adequitely explain his motives.Mafiamurkrow wrote:
Okay, here's my reason.camisade wrote:
Why did you do this? You should probably post reasons when you vote, because if you don't it seems suspicious.Mafiamurkrow wrote:Unvote.
And...
Vote: Cat-Killer.
First, I voted no lynch because I didn't really suspect anybody. But then...I thought it over and voted CK. Sorry, Cat-Killer.
goborage wrote: And why did you vote Cat-Killer?
Again, continuously avoiding the question. Add that to the terminal lurking and I think it's scummy.Mafiamurkrow wrote:Does it really matter? Besides, whoever I vote might get other people to vote for them too. And really, no need to know EVERYTHING...
I'm holding off my vote becuase that would put him on L-1, however, unless something changes my mind, I WILL be voting for him.
FOS: Mafiamurkrow
Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." Anyway, I think it's time to get a role claim from Mafiamurkrow.Mafiamurkrow wrote:Huh...erm,vote: no lynch.I have no leads and no idea otherwise, so I can't really lynch anyone.
AA distances himself from the lynching by not actually voting for her. After all, throwing a hammer would make one look suspicious. However AA indirectly causes the lynch by convincing #1 Newb.
My question is why are you so gung-ho on making Mafiamurkrow look suspicious if you're voting for Cat-killer? Is Cat-killer not the most suspicious person on your list? Why didn't you make a summary of Cat's scummy actions?-
-
The World No.1 Noob Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 201
- Joined: March 18, 2008
-
-
The World No.1 Noob Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 201
- Joined: March 18, 2008
How would that work? wouldn't the real doctor claim that he's doctor too? and so the town would lynch one of them and if that person isn't mafia then the next round mafia would get lynched.No nightkill: I've read a game before where a lone Mafia claimed doctor and chose to forgo night killing and bluffed by saying that he protected someone. So I'm guessing Mafia is allowed to do that, but maybe it varies from mod to mod. I'm not suremarksiqiwang
王嗣其-
-
rolandofthewhite F. the White!
- F. the White!
- F. the White!
- Posts: 1721
- Joined: August 28, 2004
- Location: hither and thither
There isn't necessarily a doctor in the game, No.1. I think the C9 setup allows that their could be a cop, a doctor, both, or neither.Correct. See the Roles post (3rd post on page 1) - Vel
My main objects of suspicion are camisade and Grum. I guess throw Dave in just because I don't have enough on him one way or the other. I'll reread tonight and try to get a better idea of who's who.Quiero hacer contigo lo que la primavera hace con los cerezos.-
-
Grum Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 200
- Joined: March 19, 2008
lol i'm going to assume your suspicious of me cuz i was suspicious of you... thats fair but why(do i talk to much?) and what about camisade and dave... well it seems dave is a little quiet... thats not really a reason to cause any suspicion though but to be safe keep an eye out for lurking. camisade seems a little upset about noobs and-- wait i am a noob... uhh camisade i didn't say anything lol...
#1 noob I'd say its a doctor in this game and they won't talk out now because thats just a targeting system for the mafia to kill him/her it just screams kill me doesn't it?
so my conclusion is #1 noob is exactly as him name states he is... the #1 noob here... no offense.At all times I are confusing... Is my hobby..-
-
goborage Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 519
- Joined: March 20, 2008
- Location: Moe's Tavern Occupation: Bartender, Part-time Scumhunter
I think there's some confusion with No. 1's post. He's replying to Camisade's example, not our game. The game Camisade is talking about probably didn't have defined roles which allowed for the false-claim mafia.
It's doubtful that they would but just to be sure:
Mod: can the mafia choose not to NK?Yes, of course they may - Vel
@roland: Can you explain why camisade, Grum, and Dave are at the top of your list?-
-
rolandofthewhite F. the White!
- F. the White!
- F. the White!
- Posts: 1721
- Joined: August 28, 2004
- Location: hither and thither
This is still pre-re-reading, so my opinions on all of this may change once I go back through.gorborage wrote:@roland: Can you explain why camisade, Grum, and Dave are at the top of your list?
camisade - He pointed out that Mafiamurkow wasn't helping catch Mafia, and used that as his reasoning for lynching. But we aren't trying to lynch players who aren't good at catching Mafia (because all the Mafia have to do is participate and pay attention and they'd probably seem good at what they're doing). Rather, we should be focusing on catchingMafia. Then again, I can see where the frustration comes from.
Dave - He seems to be popping in when he's needed and then disappearing. Also, a really exuberant reaction (e.g. "Awesome") to something that is beneficial to the town (such as a Mafia lynch or no kill at night) is sometimes an example of Mafia trying to act like townspeople, especially among new people who don't know any better. Then again, he wasn't on the Mafiamurkrow wagon (or any wagon), which makes me wonder if he's trying to fade into the background.
Grum - Not suspicious of him because he was suspicious of me. There's just a certain something I can't quite put my finger on. Hopefully when I re-read I can figure it out.Quiero hacer contigo lo que la primavera hace con los cerezos.-
-
Abstract Actuary Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 442
- Joined: October 11, 2007
- Location: Chicago
This is a horrible misrepresentation of my post and it seems you missed the point just like Noob and Murkrow did.goborage wrote:
I think this post is suspicious. It's in the guise of someone trying to prevent a quick-lynch. But what AA is doing is summing up all the "scummy" actions that Mafiamurkrow has made and making a case to lynch.Abstract Actuary wrote:Based on these two posts it looks like Mafia Murkrow is at L-1.
Mod wrote:Official Vote Count
Cat_Killer - 2 (Abstract Actuary, Mafiamurkrow)
camisade - 1 (Dave)
Mafiamurkrow - 3 (rolandofthewhite, goborage, Grum)
Not Voting - 3 (camisade, Cat_Killer, The World No.1 Noob)
5 to Lynch
And at least one person who thinks he's suspicious enough to add the hammer.camisade wrote:
Ugh. Do you not have anything to say besides that?Mafiamurkrow wrote:AW BLEH. -has mysteriously disappeared for a while due to busynessism- I'm sorry for poofing. D=
vote: Mafiamurkrow
And all Mafiamurkrow has to say is . . .Cat_Killer wrote:Mafiamurkrow seems scummy to me. See:
That's... not a reason. Failing to adequitely explain his motives.Mafiamurkrow wrote:
Okay, here's my reason.camisade wrote:
Why did you do this? You should probably post reasons when you vote, because if you don't it seems suspicious.Mafiamurkrow wrote:Unvote.
And...
Vote: Cat-Killer.
First, I voted no lynch because I didn't really suspect anybody. But then...I thought it over and voted CK. Sorry, Cat-Killer.
goborage wrote: And why did you vote Cat-Killer?
Again, continuously avoiding the question. Add that to the terminal lurking and I think it's scummy.Mafiamurkrow wrote:Does it really matter? Besides, whoever I vote might get other people to vote for them too. And really, no need to know EVERYTHING...
I'm holding off my vote becuase that would put him on L-1, however, unless something changes my mind, I WILL be voting for him.
FOS: Mafiamurkrow
Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." Anyway, I think it's time to get a role claim from Mafiamurkrow.Mafiamurkrow wrote:Huh...erm,vote: no lynch.I have no leads and no idea otherwise, so I can't really lynch anyone.
AA distances himself from the lynching by not actually voting for her. After all, throwing a hammer would make one look suspicious. However AA indirectly causes the lynch by convincing #1 Newb.
My question is why are you so gung-ho on making Mafiamurkrow look suspicious if you're voting for Cat-killer? Is Cat-killer not the most suspicious person on your list? Why didn't you make a summary of Cat's scummy actions?
I didn't sum up any case against Mafiamurkrow. I quoted the vote count, then the vote that put her at L-1, then a subsequent FoS (potential hammer), then a post by Mafiamurkrow in the middle that shows she didn't understand the situation. The purpose was to alert everyone of the situation. Since the L-1 vote had happened, no one even seemed to notice. No one mentioned it and that is a dangerous situation to be in. So I wanted to make everyone aware of the situation - especially Mafiamurkrow and any potential hammers. The reason I did it is clearly stated in the post. Essentially, slow down, here's the situation and no one hammer before we get a role claim from Mafiamurkrow; Mafiamurkrow, claim you role.
At that point I didn't have any suspicions on anyone that were good enough to lynch. Cat_Killer had acted the scummiest to me based on her page one play - which I've already stated. It seemed newb scum, but just as easily could have been newb town. Mafiamurkrow had acted strangely, but nothing to make me think she was scum.-
-
goborage Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 519
- Joined: March 20, 2008
- Location: Moe's Tavern Occupation: Bartender, Part-time Scumhunter
I think a simple "Mafiamurkrow is at -1, make a rolecall please" would have sufficed. Instead you quote a giant wall of text of people accusing Mafiamurkrow. Besides that, your defense works up to this point: "Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." This is finger-pointing, an attempt to make Mafiamurkrow look scummy.
You then go on to say "Mafiamurkrow had acted strangely, but nothing to make me think she was scum." This quote applies again: "Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." This quote proves that you thought what Mafiamurkrow was doing was scummy.
FOS: Abstract ActuaryWell if you're so sure what it ain't, how about tellin' us what it am!-
-
Grum Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 200
- Joined: March 19, 2008
I don't know that just seems like hes being a valuable player to me. while it does set up murkrow to be on defensive, it is seemingly an effective way to get people to talk... if he throws accusations out there at random (not naming anyone rolandofthewhite...). my current thought is that abstract is really the most valuable player at the moment, calm and collect.
also i have to say your comment is rather funny...
followed in the same post by:This is finger-pointing, an attempt to make Mafiamurkrow look scummy.
fingers everywhere!!FOS: Abstract ActuaryAt all times I are confusing... Is my hobby..-
-
Abstract Actuary Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 442
- Joined: October 11, 2007
- Location: Chicago
I said it "could be." I didn't say it was scummy. It's not inherently scummy to make that statement, but scum could benefit from it. There is a difference.goborage wrote:I think a simple "Mafiamurkrow is at -1, make a rolecall please" would have sufficed. Instead you quote a giant wall of text of people accusing Mafiamurkrow. Besides that, your defense works up to this point: "Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." This is finger-pointing, an attempt to make Mafiamurkrow look scummy.
You then go on to say "Mafiamurkrow had acted strangely, but nothing to make me think she was scum." This quote applies again: "Seems like it could be scum saying "I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail." This quote proves that you thought what Mafiamurkrow was doing was scummy.
FOS: Abstract Actuary
I could have made my post simpler, but it appeared to me that everyone had missed what had occurred (MM to L-1) and I wanted to make it clear what happened.-
-
goborage Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 519
- Joined: March 20, 2008
- Location: Moe's Tavern Occupation: Bartender, Part-time Scumhunter
I'm still not convinced and I don't the words "could be" absolve you from anything. This quote: "Seems like it could be scum saying 'I'm not going to name any names as to avoid leaving any more trail'" is too pro-lynch in my eyes.I said it "could be." I didn't say it was scummy. It's not inherently scummy to make that statement, but scum could benefit from it. There is a difference.
vote: Abstract Actuary
Anyways has anyone given any thought to the setup? I'm going to assume we have a doctor as I can't see why mafia would choose not to NK.
* 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 1 Sane Cop, 1 Sane Doctor, 5 Townies
* 1 Mafia Goon, 1 Mafia Roleblocker, 7 Townies
* 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Cop, 6 Townies
* 2 Mafia Goons, 1 Sane Doctor, 6 Townies
So I'm guessing either 1 or 4.Well if you're so sure what it ain't, how about tellin' us what it am!-
-
Grum Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 200
- Joined: March 19, 2008
-
-
The World No.1 Noob Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 201
- Joined: March 18, 2008
but the aim of the game isn't to not get killed, its to lynch the mafia and you'll win if the town lynches the mafia whether you're dead or alive, so if you've contradicted the mafia on being the doctor and you get killed whether by mafia or by lynch the and you're revealed as doctor then everyone will know who ever claimed to be doctor was lying and obviously the mafia. And plus if you make a contradictory with a mafia on who's doctor then it won't be likely for you to get killed by mafia because either you or the mafia will be lynched, if you get lynched first then its the doctor for 1 mafia (is this worth it? I'm not sure I am noob like you said lol but I do like to believe I have logical reasoning), but if the mafia gets lynched first then you can save yourself at night.#1 noob I'd say its a doctor in this game and they won't talk out now because thats just a targeting system for the mafia to kill him/her it just screams kill me doesn't it?
o and btw whats a mafia roleblocker?marksiqiwang
王嗣其-
-
The World No.1 Noob Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 201
- Joined: March 18, 2008
-
-
Cat_Killer Townie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 22
- Joined: March 19, 2008
- Location: Glasgow, Scotland
-
-
Dave Townie
- Townie
- Townie
- Posts: 69
- Joined: March 20, 2008
This is one of the first mafia games I have played, and would quite like to win, so I suppose I got a little excitedrolandofthewhite wrote: Dave - He seems to be popping in when he's needed and then disappearing. Also, a really exuberant reaction (e.g. "Awesome") to something that is beneficial to the town (such as a Mafia lynch or no kill at night) is sometimes an example of Mafia trying to act like townspeople, especially among new people who don't know any better. Then again, he wasn't on the Mafiamurkrow wagon (or any wagon), which makes me wonder if he's trying to fade into the background.
A mafia roleblocker is someone that can send a name to the mod each night, and the person that they choose gets blocked and cannot perform there night action. Wiki Definition-
-
goborage Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 519
- Joined: March 20, 2008
- Location: Moe's Tavern Occupation: Bartender, Part-time Scumhunter
I don't understand what you are saying. Can you explain this please?#1noob wrote: but the aim of the game isn't to not get killed, its to lynch the mafia and you'll win if the town lynches the mafia whether you're dead or alive, so if you've contradicted the mafia on being the doctor and you get killed whether by mafia or by lynch the and you're revealed as doctor then everyone will know who ever claimed to be doctor was lying and obviously the mafia. And plus if you make a contradictory with a mafia on who's doctor then it won't be likely for you to get killed by mafia because either you or the mafia will be lynched, if you get lynched first then its the doctor for 1 mafia (is this worth it? I'm not sure I am noob like you said lol but I do like to believe I have logical reasoning), but if the mafia gets lynched first then you can save yourself at night.
Sane cops and docs will carry out their tasks 100% unless a roleblocker stops them. Insane cops and docs have a chance of screwing up their task.#1noob wrote: o and btw again why is it sane doc and sane cop? are there insane doc and insave cops?Well if you're so sure what it ain't, how about tellin' us what it am!
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
-