Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[armlx]

There's no point lynching BM, this discussion's been had.

There may have been a point before he claimed hider AND the godfather had died AND he had a cult only cop show him as cult while he claimed miller before the cult would have presumably kicked in.

As for the BM = likely to be recruited, WIFOM.

As far as skitzer goes, thx for the help here.

So people I want dead list:
skitzer
TSN
Peers
dahill1
TS

Peers and TS are fairly default though, other 3 are the real suspects.

[Battle Mage]

Skitzer, stop being stupid.

QFT

[Xtoxm]

Shoot, I forgot to answer your question, BM.

I don't need much to find you cult-y, it's basically all summed in your odd claim, Rosso Carne's role and investigations, and the stuff I mentioned earlier about poisoning.

so, there isnt much of a case then. In fact, you dont find my PLAY scummy atall? You just suspect me because of WIFOM type things, that are beyond my control, like my role, Rosso's stupidity, and the behaviour of the CR.

BM

Your odd claim is the main basis of my doubt for you, but I can see the feasability of a such role being present. Having you confirmed would be nice.

Well only Farside can do that.

BM

Yeh I know.

It's her decision, ultimately.

But there are other people i'd want to focus on first.

Seeing as you are confirmed non-mafia and all.

[Battle Mage]

There's no point lynching BM, this discussion's been had.

There may have been a point before he claimed hider AND the godfather had died AND he had a cult only cop show him as cult while he claimed miller before the cult would have presumably kicked in.

As for the BM = likely to be recruited, WIFOM.

As far as skitzer goes, thx for the help here.

So people I want dead list:
skitzer
TSN
Peers
dahill1
TS

Peers and TS are fairly default though, other 3 are the real suspects.

You gonna vote for Skitzer then? We need to be like the town we began as. An agile, graceful lynch mob, who could run someone up to -2 in 24 hours, and then be on the next suspicious player in 10.

[Xtoxm]

ckd: everyone has been wrong. But sometimes, you are right. Maybe it is a smarter idea to "test" him tonight.

that isnt up to you and me..that is up to farside.

this is true. Dont worry, i'll be sure that she is briefed before we go to night.


Also, lets keep posting rapidly. My post count is SOARING.

BM

I am so going to catch you. Totally.

eh? now im lost.
lol

I was refering to the post count part

[Battle Mage]

Shoot, I forgot to answer your question, BM.

I don't need much to find you cult-y, it's basically all summed in your odd claim, Rosso Carne's role and investigations, and the stuff I mentioned earlier about poisoning.

so, there isnt much of a case then. In fact, you dont find my PLAY scummy atall? You just suspect me because of WIFOM type things, that are beyond my control, like my role, Rosso's stupidity, and the behaviour of the CR.

BM

Your odd claim is the main basis of my doubt for you, but I can see the feasability of a such role being present. Having you confirmed would be nice.

Well only Farside can do that.

BM

Yeh I know.

It's her decision, ultimately.

But there are other people i'd want to focus on first.

Seeing as you are confirmed non-mafia and all.

Oh, she will confirm me tonight, dont you worry.

BM

[Battle Mage]

ckd: everyone has been wrong. But sometimes, you are right. Maybe it is a smarter idea to "test" him tonight.

that isnt up to you and me..that is up to farside.

this is true. Dont worry, i'll be sure that she is briefed before we go to night.


Also, lets keep posting rapidly. My post count is SOARING.

BM

I am so going to catch you. Totally.

eh? now im lost.
lol

I was refering to the post count part

I bet i'll overtake MoS, before you get into the top 5.
Actually i dont think i have the highest post per day rate anymore. I was about 0.2 ppd away when i last checked. Hopefully this should move me back into poll position.

BM

[Xtoxm]

ckd: everyone has been wrong. But sometimes, you are right. Maybe it is a smarter idea to "test" him tonight.

that isnt up to you and me..that is up to farside.

this is true. Dont worry, i'll be sure that she is briefed before we go to night.


Also, lets keep posting rapidly. My post count is SOARING.

BM

I am so going to catch you. Totally.

eh? now im lost.
lol

I was refering to the post count part

I bet i'll overtake MoS, before you get into the top 5.
Actually i dont think i have the highest post per day rate anymore. I was about 0.2 ppd away when i last checked. Hopefully this should move me back into poll position.

BM

You prolly will...But my ppd is higher than yours! Mwah!

[armlx]

E-penis fights are funny, but lets get back to lynching one of TSN/dahill/skitzer.

[Battle Mage]

damnit. You're right! And its harder for me to increase mine, having been here nearly a year longer.

Young upstarts...

[armlx]

Hehehe, you said harder.

[Battle Mage]

E-penis fights are funny, but lets get back to lynching one of TSN/dahill/skitzer.

Vote for Skitzer NOW. Bloomin idiot. lol

[armlx]

I thought I had that in my last relevant post. Guess it disappeared when I was reordering it to make sense.

Unvote, Vote Skitzer

[Battle Mage]

I thought I had that in my last relevant post. Guess it disappeared when I was reordering it to make sense.

Unvote, Vote Skitzer

A likely story!

[armlx]

So people I want dead list:
skitzer
TSN
Peers
dahill1
TS

Peers and TS are fairly default though, other 3 are the real suspects.

Vote Skitzer

There's no point lynching BM, this discussion's been had.

There may have been a point before he claimed hider AND the godfather had died AND he had a cult only cop show him as cult while he claimed miller before the cult would have presumably kicked in.

As for the BM = likely to be recruited, WIFOM.

As far as skitzer goes, thx for the help here.

Was the original ordering, or something similar. Think the format I chose is better?

[Matt_S]

I disapprove of the skitzer wagon. I approve of the Peers wagon.

[Xtoxm]

I disapprove of the skitzer wagon. I approve of the Peers wagon.

I've gathered you approve of Peers

Why do you not like skitzer wagon?

[Matt_S]

I disapprove of the skitzer wagon. I approve of the Peers wagon.

I've gathered you approve of Peers

Why do you not like skitzer wagon?

Because skitzer's not Peers. And other things as well which I'll keep a secret.

[dahill1]

other things as well which I'll keep a secret.

yay for softclaims
also, can someone explain to me why people keep wanting to lynch BM when we have established that we aren't going to right now?

[Pie_is_good]

Me neither. Shall we bandwagon him?

I'll give Surye and Pie a ring. They can help us put a bit of pressure on him, so he doesnt hide away and lurk.

Yeah. No.

I kind of despise LurkerLynching with a fiery passion.

As for the BM = likely to be recruited, WIFOM.

You might totally be right here, but I'm not seeing it. How would the cult's night-zero recruit be impacted by WIFOM-type things

before

the town knew the cult existed?

--------

-If you still think BM might be scum, you have not been reading the game. And by that I mean, you most likely do not follow the miller logic, and also you suck at analysis and/or have not read his posts over the last few days. And by that I mean, you're a moron.

-It is a waste of a perfectly good vigkill to test him tonight (It would be a waste of a vigkill to test him even if he wasn't flamingly protown). A vigkill is, on average, about as accurate as a lynch. Remember that, children.

-I mentioned this awhile ago and nobody really commented: Hurry up and massclaim, people.

-There is no case against TS, for those of you who have a meta on TS.

-

Vote: CKDScum

. I am voting for CKDScum because he is scum, and as a result his posts have been scummy. CKDScum, you may attempt (and inevitably fail) to show innocence by answering these questions:

1) Excluding me (Pie) and you (CKDScum), which player is most likely protown but also hurting the town the most?
2) What's the scummiest post you've made all game, and why?
3) If you were currently mafia, what would your strategy be?

Please, nobody answer these questions until CKDScum does.

[armlx]

I don't endorse mass claims in flavorless 30 player games.

As for cult WIFOM pie, I guess the logic I was trying to use applies more to scum kills, but its a similar thing to try and out guess a cult recruiter without something to connect anyone to him.

[armlx]

Hey, BM, remember you asking which game I saw cult poisoning in? I couldn't find it because I modded (well, failed at) it. Points Mafia Mega. N1, thoth dies of poisoning to the cult.

[mnowax]

hi hows everyone doing? i am supposedly replacing into this game, i just dont know who. will be starting the rereading soon. this one is trying to beat kingmaker II in posts, huh?

[armlx]

Not aiming to, will. Between BM, xtoxm, Surye, and I (if my playing with these people elsewhere is any indication), it will maybe even reach Lost Boys.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Yes, but there is still that dreadful possibility that you are cult, and as long as that possibility remains...well, your the main suspect for that.

Poison did not show up until last night. Poison, which is likely a delayed method of death, would fit well with the delayed cult. Therefore, it is a very good possibilty that the cult member is still cult, and as BM being an experienced player, it is likely that the cult recruiter may have chosen him.

Yes, we have had this discussion. But not discussing it anymore doesn't make the cult member go away. It's not that simple.

Christ. Even CKD said this was stupid, but I'm going to pile onto that.

Unvote, vote skitzer.

Would mafia so blatantly try to pile onto the cult, is what concerns me, but its worth a good bandwagon. Also, I just checked to see who skitzer replaced, only to discover he's been in the game this whole time, and I hadn't noticed. I'm not sure whose fault that is.