i think i must have read his post and read it as "...called all 3 scum..." my bad guys =(
that being said, i still think it is more likely there are 2 anti-town groups rather than a 4 scum team because if there are only 2 left on the team, i don't think you'd want to kill a teammate for the sake of possibly clearing the remaining scumbuddy. so in my mind, either there were two mafia on opposite teams, or we have a remaining SK.
if it was a mafia group (let's call them mafia group A), they could have killed cipher/lemming because they thought he was in mafia B, a SK, or town. if mafia A thought C/L was in mafia B (or town), i could see mafia group A being vocal about it.
if it was an SK that killed C/L, it's still possible that the SK wanted to kill cipher/lemming because the SK thought he was town.
also:
i wrote:i also think that the SK was either clever enough to hold a kill night one, absent enough to not get a choice in, or else the SK was roleblocked by cipher/lemming.
this makes it seem very possible that the SK thought lemming was town but lemming suspected the SK, thus the SKs night choice N2 (and possibly lemming's choice N1).
what i meant to say was:
i wrote:i also think that the SK was either clever enough to hold a kill night one, absent enough to not get a choice in, or else the SK was roleblocked by
alabaska j N1
.
this makes it seem very possible that the SK thought lemming was town but lemming suspected the SK, thus the SKs night choice N2
i guess this also holds true if it's a second mafia.
i'm thinking we need to go back to D2 and see who alabaska mentioned roleblocking.