33. Asks if Surye's FoS on GS is doubting his claim.
34. Says he's waiting for Cele's catch-up.
35. Agrees w/ Cele's case on Lowell. However, he says he disagrees w/ Cele's list of protown players, which is as follows:
TSPN
FL
GS(hes doomed to be NKed imo)
and I get some Pro-town vibes off of TSQ.
Looking at this list, it's tough to argue that TSPN and GS are not town at this stage in the game. That leaves TSQ and FL. FL is obvious, because FL was the major opponent of Johoono. TSQ is a little shakier - I'm curious why you all think he was on Cele's protown list, and whether or not you think he was one of those that Jo disagreed with, and if so, why?
36. An EBWOP.
37. Says he'll catch up - unvotes.
Note: This analysis covers everything up to page 28. From this point forward Jo's primary focus is arguing with FL about why he shouldn't be lynched. It would take up a lot of space to cover all that, and since it's only three pages back I figure you can review that piece of it yourselves. However, there is one more crucial review post that I feel needs to be covered, that being post 699. I will go over it much as I did his other general analysis post, but this time, I will cite whether his opinion is consistent, or has flipped.
Cele (Middling; consistent) - Says he's stalling, following others, and that he has a hard time getting a good read on him - the options Jo provides are scum or inexperienced town.
FL (scum; raised from middling) - Cites suspicions from day 1 and the wagon FL started on him, talks about lurker policy.
GS (Town; lowered from middling) - No one CC'd the doc claim.
Iceman (Middling; Consistent) - "Still on line between newbie scum and newbie town."
TSQ (Scum; consistent) - For getting Zeek wagon rolling on D2, calls him shifty, says he tried to save myself and FL through his town list.
Surye (Middling, lowered from town) - Says he thought marmalade was protown, but that Surye hasn't said enough to judge.
Sir T - (Middling; raised from scum) - Ditto latter half of above.
Lowell - (Middling; consistent) - Agrees with the anti-not-doc claiming idea. Also agrees with my case on Lowell.
TDC - (Middling; raised from scum) - Says he's hard to read and "stays just above the lurking surface.
Note: The previous four seem like breeze-overs in comparison to his others, which are brief but more substantial.
TSPN - (Town; lowered from middling) - Proven town by GS doc prot on N1.
He then comments that he thinks FL and TSQ are a scumteam, and votes FL.
Overall points to consider:
1. Perhaps the biggest question raised by Jo's posts is: what's his connection to the lurkers? He is constantly flip-flopping on his position on them, one minute voting them into posting and defending them the next. Especially noteworthy are Surye, TDC, and Sir T.
2. Also, before my PBPA I was suspicious of mafiaSSK/TSQ, but due to the fact that Jo is confirmed scum, in looking at his interactions with TSQ, it's tough to believe Jo would hammer him that hard if he were his partner.
3. Additionally, it would be hard to believe that FL is scum judging by Day 2.
My list of potential scum at this stage in the game:
- Surye
- Cele
- Sir T
- TDC
- Lowell
That is in order from scummiest to least scummy.
Therefore,
vote: Surye