[qupte="MMCL in post114"]Also - the calls for me to reveal that I am a cop. What do you want me to say? At this stage I won't say I am and I won't say I am not. Just that I believe I have the town's best interests at heart and that I think it is highly likely that Tally is scum. [/quote]ralphmerridew in post 253 wrote:MMCL, you didn't answer my question. Which of these is the case:
a) Your information marks Talitha as definitely being scum, but your information could be wrong (i.e., you are a cop, but you could be insane).
b) It is possible that Talitha is innocent but your information is correct (i.e., you are a tracker who followed Talitha to tss).
Also, is your information binary (you get one of two results, guilty / innocent) or not?
This is the main post that's making me suspicious of MMCL.MMCL in post 257 wrote:B cannot be correct ralph... I am not saying if A is...
If he's a standard cop, why hasn't he just said so? What does he gain by being mysterious?
If he's a less specific information role (like tracker or gunsmith), I can understand his refusal to give a specific role; it would tell the scum what sort of lie to tell. But why refuse to give any sort of response?
When I was Miss Infrared (tracker) in Clue Mafia, I followed the SK night 1. Day 1, I tried to subtly push for his lynch; when that failed, I directly claimed that I'd investigated DP, that my result had given me good reason to believe him guilty, and pushed for him to role-claim. As it happened, he claimed townie; after that, I would have been willing to state my information directly contradicted his claim, and that the town could lynch me or vig-kill me if his claim proved true. (Unfortunately, I flubbed the play at that point, and didn't post as well as I could have.)
OTOH, MMCL won't even say, "Yes, I have an investigative role." That strikes me as a way to keep open a day 2 defense of "I'm not a cop; I just I was voting based on her behavior."
That sets my scum-o-meter off completely, so until MMCL can commit to