Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[killa seven]

imo Bm is still acting like he was the first time, trolling the thread the same.

[farside22]

why do you think there is 126 pages right now.

[Celebloki]

/prod received

I have been very busy with summer classes, Will catch up soon and make a post.

[Battle Mage]

The above is true, having just done a full reread. It was brutal.

Whome? seems less likely to be scum due to some of the night actions, as BM said, but I don't know if he and I are thinking about the same thing.

well, what are you thinking about?

Right now he's just looking protown, but doing a bad job of scumhunting/defending himself.

What do i have to defend myself against? How do you figure that im doing a bad job of scumhunting? That is surely dependent on whether Armlx is scum or not?

BM

[Battle Mage]

Anyways, BM has been using some not so great logic against armlx, like accusing him without any reasoning. For example, in post 3127, he accuses armlx of buddying up with Korlash when to me, it seems like armlx is just reminding Korlash that he isn't as bad as he thinks he is, nothing more. If I knew more about Korlash and if he is a good mafia player, I would have said the same thing.
That doesn't mean he's necessarily scum, it's just making the day go even longer.

Armlx, also. You also try to halfheartedly throw out suspicion on BM without trying to sound very passionate about it...it looks like you're not trying to get BM interested in you.

Armlx has yet to respond to this. It's a pretty valid point. On numerous occassions he has declared me assuredly protown, yet still seems to want me dead...

BM

[armlx]

Anyways, BM has been using some not so great logic against armlx, like accusing him without any reasoning. For example, in post 3127, he accuses armlx of buddying up with Korlash when to me, it seems like armlx is just reminding Korlash that he isn't as bad as he thinks he is, nothing more. If I knew more about Korlash and if he is a good mafia player, I would have said the same thing.
That doesn't mean he's necessarily scum, it's just making the day go even longer.

Armlx, also. You also try to halfheartedly throw out suspicion on BM without trying to sound very passionate about it...it looks like you're not trying to get BM interested in you.

Armlx has yet to respond to this. It's a pretty valid point. On numerous occassions he has declared me assuredly protown, yet still seems to want me dead...

BM

1) Was that quote even directed at me?

2) The last time I declared you pro-town was before you died. I don't think you are assured town, just that you aren't worth a lynch. There is a distinction.

[Battle Mage]

Guys, guys. I'll happily lynch you both when I'm done lynching scum.

This post is so full of win it hurts.

Need i direct you back 2 pages to this post? ^^

You clearly suggest that you know i am protown. Not quite pre-BM2.

If you were trying to keep your story straight, you probably need to try harder...

BM

[armlx]

You clearly suggest that you know i am protown. Not quite pre-BM2. Rolling Eyes

Hardly. It simply echoed my opinion you weren't worth lynching at the time as per default lynch policy.

[Battle Mage]

You clearly suggest that you know i am protown. Not quite pre-BM2. Rolling Eyes

Hardly. It simply echoed my opinion you weren't worth lynching at the time as per default lynch policy.

if thats what you meant, maybe you should have said it. I'm not buying it.

BM

[armlx]

if thats what you meant, maybe you should have said it. I'm not buying it.

Yawn. Thats what you've said about everything I've said all day.

[Battle Mage]

if thats what you meant, maybe you should have said it. I'm not buying it.

Yawn. Thats what you've said about everything I've said all day.

Maybe that should tell you something about your consistency.

BM

[armlx]

Maybe that should tell you something about your consistency. Rolling Eyes

Because changing opinions when people post is illegal? Because clarifying your intent automatically means you are making up something to fit the scenario?

[andersonw]

Anyways, BM has been using some not so great logic against armlx, like accusing him without any reasoning. For example, in post 3127, he accuses armlx of buddying up with Korlash when to me, it seems like armlx is just reminding Korlash that he isn't as bad as he thinks he is, nothing more. If I knew more about Korlash and if he is a good mafia player, I would have said the same thing.
That doesn't mean he's necessarily scum, it's just making the day go even longer.

Armlx, also. You also try to halfheartedly throw out suspicion on BM without trying to sound very passionate about it...it looks like you're not trying to get BM interested in you.

You're saying that by putting suspicion on BM, I'm trying not to get him interested in me? I don't get how that makes sense.

Also, by your logic, whenever player 1 attacks player 2, and player 2 already accused player 3, you're saying that player 1 is automatically buddied up with player 3? Please explain your reasoning more.

Mod:

Tomorrow, I will be going to summer camp for 2 weeks, so I will need a temporary replacement.

[Andycyca]

Mod:

I request replacement. I have way too much work.

[JordanA24]

Vote Count Updated, replacing Andycyca.

Instead of replacing andersonw, I shall instead (for the purpose of Vote Counts) pretend

he

his vote doesn't exist for those two weeks (he can still be lynched however).

[Matt_S]

The main idea to get from this page is that BM and armlx are trying to murder each other, and most of the people are just watching. I see no reason to lynch BM at this point, and armlx is one of the people who I think is protown. So let's get on with the Celebloki lynch. But look, I've decided to do a post analysis on Peers!

Post 0: Not relevant to this game.
Post 1: Votes BM1, will explain later.
Post 2: Suggests using mostly empty votes, because not enough has happened.
Post 3: "Death Threats. Nice."
Post 4: Gives a vague reason for his BM1 vote involving "early miller silliness" and "past games".
Post 5: He's not lurking, just posting infrequently.
Post 6: Rather than contribute to the game at hand, he makes a comment about the theory of vigging N0
Post 7: Despite 3 kills, Peers doesn't think the vig killed N0
Post 8: Noncommittal stance on thenextepisode.
Post 9: Questions Imat's jester reference. I only mention posts like this because they are posts he make which don't further the game.
Post 10: Townies get mad, scum crack. He doesn't talk too much about the game everybody's playing.
Post 11: He unvotes because his vote doesn't belong there. Also of interest is the comment that he's "Not sure who the scum is", as if everyone who's voting must be certain. Backing down from providing content.
Post 12: Gosh, 4 replacements already. Nothing wrong with his posting frequency though, oh no.
Post 13: This post is, I think, about a deadline. The reason a deadline is needed is because there's not enough content, a.k.a. too many posts like this.
Post 14: Zomg people read sigs? Let's see how long he can go before posting game relevant stuff.
Post 15: "I got scummy strikes?"
Post 16: Another thing I had to look up to find the context. BM1 says Lloyd ma have scum on his wagon since he's getting a lot of heat for something I can't remember, so good ol' Peers says that maybe he's being bussed.
Post 17:He votes killa seven1. "Yeah, I'll join the wagon. Let's see if we can get a worth-while claim out of this. " Isn't this a little odd?
Post 18: Accuses armlx of trying to stop a killa seven wagon because armlx wants discussion.
Post 19: Wants someone to hammer killa seven1 instead of using the rest of the time for discussion.
Post 20: Blah blah blah. The main point to take from this post is that claiming now means he won't be able to do a magnificent fake claim later on.
Post 21: Whines about people believing someone else's townie claim. I believe it was Xtoxm's claim.
Post 22: I'll ignore his confusion about cult cops. I won't ignore his immediate conclusion that BM1 must die.
Post 23: Votes Rosso basically just to test BM's claim.
Post 24: The ambiguous "he"s in this post is what's confusing. Peers suddenly doubts that some person is town despite no mention of scumminess in past posts.
Post 25: Wants to know why we're having discussion. Also talks about why he's voting for Rosso, which is completely different from his "we're testing BM1" reason.
Post 26: I'll point this post out because he mentions reasons that he never used before.
Post 27: So impatient.
Post 28: It's funny that he's now opposed to directing the vig, when earlier he hypothesized that we were discussing so that we could find scumbuddies for the vig to lynch. He never expressed any dislike of directing the vig before.
Post 29: Yes, he seems to be considering millers coming up guilty to all investigations.
Post 30: "Yeah, god forbid you make him change his vote. It might give the rest of us something to judge him by besides his attitude. " He says this while TheSweatpantsNinja and I are arguing, when I'm presently voting Peers, and threaten to switch to TheSweatpantsNinja. This is why TheSweatpantsNinja will be my target if Celebloki/Peers is scum.
Post 31: He's now getting into philosophy. But what this basically sounds like is him denying that the Rosso lynch made sense.
Post 32: Something crazy about cult wanting scum to stay alive. I'm too lazy to go back and see what this is referencing, but he's avoiding any accusations.
Post 33:

This is not productive posting.

Oddly enough, neither was that.

And coming from me, that means something.

Enough said.
Post 34: Empty vote on TheSweatpantsNinja.
Post 35: All of the sudden, one of BM1, CKD, and TS is scum. Oh, and "I offer some input. Just not as much as everyone else. "
Post 36:

You still didn't explain your vote.

Oh, I'm sorry, did I forget to give you something you could twist into using against me? My mistake. I forgot you needed people to give you rope to hang them with, and couldn't get any of your own.

The only times he's been emotional were this post and the one earlier. They sound like OMGUS.

And that's the show.

[Surye]

Catching up here

[farside22]

How many peoples eyes have crossed reading anything BM fight with some player at this point.

[armlx]

How many peoples eyes have crossed reading anything BM fight with some player at this point. Laughing

Agree, thats probably half the thread by now.

Waiting on replacements and people to say stuff. This game is getting bogged down by a lack of activity by some members, and a lot of momentum is actually needed to lynch/wagon someone effectively right now.

[Bogre]

BM: The qoute wasn't directed at Armlx.

The other qoute wasn't directed at you.

Heh.

My eyes -ARE- crossed.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I'm just waiting for the whome wagon to develop.

I'm not interested in pursuing armlx. Or BM. I might be interested in celebloki/peers, but he wouldn't be my first choice.

[Matt_S]

The lack of comments on my case saddens me.

[Korlash]

*pats matt* I thought it was a very nice case. It was well written and had good punctuation! =D

[armlx]

The lack of comments on my case saddens me. Crying or Very sad

I endorse it. Peers/Bloki/whoever is one of the people I am very willing to lynch at this point as per the list.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

That's sort of how I feel. I'd be willing to lynch him, I see the merit, but he isn't my first choice.