Slaine Hayes (2): TDC, BridgesAndBaloons
BridgesAndBaloons (2): TheSweatPantsNinja, Alabaska J
TDC (1): Slaine Hayes
jonathantan86 (1): CallMeLiam
TheSweatpantsNinja (1): jonathantan86
Not voting: No one
With 7 alive it is 4 to lynch.
Okay. So I'm scum because... why? You failed to mention anything scummy about me. I really don't feel like this is a pro-town vote.Alabaska J wrote:vote: BaB
Really feels like scum to me hiding behind a strategy that would help the town. Note: not using too townie, as things he has said make me feel this way.
that makes it a tie between yes and no. I'm now changing my answer to yes to explain since I worked really hard. So I'm going to write out all the reasons now.Also, I would like you to explain the maths that make it possible for us to automatically win and whatnot. I don't doubt you, I'm just bad at this kind of stuff usually.
That was why I was at first reluctant to share all the information, but I realized that it's pretty obvious (at least for me) without even doing the math that scum need to counter-claim.CallMeLiam wrote: I'm not too happy that you explained what the the best play for the mafia is re: the maths of the counterclaim but I suppose it wouldn't have been too hard for scum to work out with all the other info in front of them.
Well you explained why you did it, you then behaved consistently with your motivation by unvoting after a reaction appeared and it didn't start a cushy bandwagon so I didn't think it needed too much comment.BridgesAndBaloons wrote:What about my vote for you? Nothing to say about that?
This is true for nearly every game of mafia and not at all specific to this setup.BridgesAndBaloons wrote: Something useful I learned from this is that we shouldnotride a wagon until someone claims. To benefit town the most, there should probably only be one claim the first day. See above logic (quote it to see it better) to understand better.
Haha, I
Well you explained why you did it, you then behaved consistently with your motivation by unvoting after a reaction appeared and it didn't start a cushy bandwagon so I didn't think it needed too much comment.
Code: Select all
Lynch Townie(3/5) Scum(2/5)
NK T(2/4) P(2/4) T(3/5) P(2/5) (T=townie, P=power role)
(6/20) (6/20) (6/25) (4/25)
0.30 0.30 0.24 0.16
86.7% 50% 100% 70%
No. The numbers explain that thanks to me bringing up something important the town has a guranteed 50% or higher of winning (assuming both power roles aren't killed by Day 2).So the numbers say that it's quite possible that BaB is scum using this strategy
Said it wasn't for too townie, blatant misrepresentation is a great D1 scumtell.CallMeLiam wrote:unvote, vote: Alabaska JVotes for players that are 'too townie' I do not like.
Yes, you said it wasn't "too townie". What was it then though?Alabaska J wrote: Really feels like scum to me hiding behind a strategy that would help the town. Note: not using too townie, as things he has said make me feel this way.