Well, I'd like to
Jon doesn't sit in my first place anymore - though he still looks suspect for me. I'd say for me now my 'rank' stays:
1 - Tony
2 - Jon
3 - Tume
Tume talks a lot and his explanations gave me a new look on him - his explanations make sense to me, and he's trying hard to prove his case against others now, too, instead of just being defensive. That doesn't mean I'm about to forget his previous actions (the whole arguing if Pope did or did not roleclaim as a mean of defense of his role really made me think for a moment he might be scum), but it lessened my suspicions on him.
Jon still sticks out to me, but I'm going to have to go with Tony. He says he already explained himself but actually provided no further information, he gives a fourth vote with no comments, and his short posts still bugg me. He doesn't defend himself with the (repeated all the times someone asks) claim that "the innocent don't need to defend themselves" and that... It might be another point of view, sure, but if you don't show how exactly you're innocent, how am I supposed to believe in you? Anything you say can be used as information about you. Ok, you might find more important to scumhunt, but when you defend yourself, we can see more of your behavior, and that helps town, too. For me, it looks like you think that defend is an act of the mafia, and attack, an act of the town. But don't forget the mafia is attacking, too, and the innocent have to protect themselves against a mislynch.
"I see no problem with short posts if you post frequently" - I don't get that, either. I thought it was about quality, and not quantity.
When you only make short posts, attack and don't defend yourself, I think you're mafia with no knowledge on how to cover your lies and attacks townies to put blame on them. That's what you look to me. On the other hands, your actions made me think. While I've been suspecting Tume for being extremely defensive (and, supposedly, having something to hide - but now he's showing a more balanced game), I'm suspecting you for the exact opposite reason. You said Michel came out as an agressive player, but you seem much more agressive, at least to me. While a defensive game alerts me, and agressive one just screams mafia - town has no reason to be as rushed as you were (still using the example of the fourth vote: you didn't even let Tume, a new player who had only been in the game for a page or so, explain himself before putting him into an extremely dangerous position. If he's actually mafia, it's great, but if he's town and dies, it's just what the mafia wants).