Editor's note: This was supposed to be posted at 11:30 (GMT-05) For some reason I didnt hit submit and let my computer turned on until I came back to click submit.
Fuck!!!!!!!! I had a nice post ready to be submitted (post by post analysis after my infamous post) and I hitted F5. ARRRRRRRRRRRRRR
Just read Muerrto's post. Ill answer it later but I think we just catched either scum or a very dumb/lazy player.
Will try to summarize, this time analyizing each player.
In special order:
Vivian :
overall nice response to the happenings so far. Isnt afraid of calling craplogic and uses the best reasoning in the crowd. Pretty much town.
Batoousai :
I like his posting. Callin me an overanalyzer isntead of possible scum is protwon response. Second in best reasoning of the crowd. Slightly protown.
Nhat:
Although he was the first attacking me I can understand the point of his attacks. Doesnt agree with my logic but uses good reasoning and so far has reacted protown to the happenings. Slightly protown.
TonyMontana and Voodo :
are these people in the game?!! Voodo is slightly protown for semidefending Timeater. Tonymontana not so much for obvious lurking after voting the most suspected player. More input is needed from these guys.
Grimmy
: Scummy behavior at the beginning of the game. However I really liked his comeback post. Semisuspecting his attackers and accepting a mistake in the tone he did is slightly protown response. However for the actions previously commented, he's pretty much neutral.
Shadowgirl:
Still dont know if this girl is scum or isnt just paying attention. Joins the group of thinking Timeter asking a replacement is null tell. Joins the attackers of my case. Low posting. Neutral.
Falcone
I liked his posting until he started to push my case to uenxpected levels. Kept pushing the Grimmy's case until he started to attack me. Slightly scummy. Hope he's just some tunnelvisioned Slightly protown.
Timeater/Ergo
Timeater did what I call a D1 scummy action. I already explained why. Im not 100% sure he's scum but I definitely know his lynch is full of information. Ergo's active lurking doesnt tranqulize me. Still hasnt posted what I think a replacement should post.
Now comes the interesting part.
FuzzyLightning
One thing I noticed about this player is low average of posting and the way he went to think Tmeater could be scum, therefore agreeing with my logic......
FL wrote:As I said earlier, Timeeater's play was just weird, and I have seen it before from someone else, but his play this time has led me to wonder if maybe he really is scum just trying to get out because he couldn't hack it. Will wait to see what Erg0 has to say now.
.......to think this.
FL wrote:I am slightly torn between Grimmy and tajo. Seeing the case against tajo makes it hard to look past him because his play has been slightly odd, as noted by nhat. I think, following his reaction to Grimmy's post maybe there is some buddying up going on there, and I think 1 of them is probably scum. My guess is tajo, so positive vote: tajo
Notice he has only 5 posts in the game. Where did he get the conclusion that there might be a scum between Grimmy and me? In Falcone's Dojo? This doesnt make sense becuase a)if there's buddying then both have to be scum not just one and b)it was so fucking early to tell who is scum and who isnt with that degree of certainty....... Mildly scummy until he comes back and answers for this.
Muerrto
Pretty much scum.Has gone to agree with me all the game (supporting a decent wagon) to positive vote me. WTF!! I mildly suspected him before because that is usually a scum technique. Agree with a townie in a decent case, push it and then when things go wrong, blame me for it. Also I never lnked you with Ergo. And I still ahve the feeling you're active lurking. Overdefensive much?
How can I go to decent reasoner to obvious scum?!
Call me Tajo.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12894
Coming summer 2010: Tajo's Starcraft Mafia.
Tajo's MagictheGathering Mafia