Kay. I left job early. So. Ill try to summarize. Here are my general thoughts so far.
FAMOUS QUESTIONS
Some people have accused me of dodging questions. I havent. I think all the information needed to explain why I acted like that or that is in this thread. Since Falcone still thinks that I havent answered his question Ill answer him.
Your problem Falcone, is that you think I didnt suspect Timeater at the moment I unvoted him. I did suspect him but I unvoted becuase I wanted to prevent a possible quicklynch. After my unvote, conversation settled down and I KEPT thinking Time/Ergo was possible scum for the reasons previously given. His wagon was full of information. Almost EVERYBODY reacted to it. At that PRECISE moment, If Ergo was lynched and he would have came up scum, then the people jumping in his wagon early (Muerrto, Voodoo) had less possibilities of being his scumpartners, and people defending him (Nhat, Batto, Vivian) should be moderately suspected. If Ergo would have came up town then the people jumping with me for weak reasons are more probable scums (Tony and Grimmy).
You're talking about information gained in a short period of time (between my unvote and my revote). Yes, there was information between these two events but the INFORMATION I was talking about was generated since the moment Muerrto placed his vote on him.
MY CLAIM AND MY WIN CONDITION
Here it is.
populartajo wrote:I could be your watcher, guys and I could win when all the threats to the town are eliminated.
Take that, scumbags and lambs.
As Falcone has pointed out there are three possibilities regarding my claim.
a)I could be the real watcher and I have a town win condition
b)I could be scum and I somehow have a town win condition in my PM.
c)I should stop playing mafia and spend all my money in lottery tickets becuase I am extremely lucky : I guessed town's win condition.
I already pointed out that reason "c" is going against common sense. Reason "b" feels a little better argumented but it is ridiculous for skitzer to add all possible win conditions in the scum PM. So, my friend Falcone, unless you come up with another possibility, choice "a" is the only one we should consider.
IM YOUR FREAKING WATCHER!
MY SCUMHUNTING TECHNIQUES!!!111
To all the people that dont understand why I suspect Muerrto, look at this:
After my PBPA, I worte this wrote:Falcone, what do you think of Ergo's case and lurking? Do you think is a bad case?
Wheres Muerrto and Ergo?
Mod: Prod them.
Muerrto's inmediate response was:
Muerrto wrote:First off, just to let you know, I wasn't prodded. Second,
Unvote positive, poisitive vote : Popular
You called for my prod when I posted friday, then saturday, and I even cross posted with you? It had been less than 24 hours since my last post.
And attempting to link me with Ergo/Time? Nice. No wonder you had a problem with me agreeing with you about Ergo.
First of all, I must admit I made a mistake when rereading and didnt notice that Muerrto had posted recently so that he didnt need a prod. To be honest, I was expecting a little of decent support since I thought he had experience and could attack the weak reasonings against my case. This explain the "Muerrto, thoughts?" that I added at the end. However, the thing that worried me the most is that he was supporting my theory of Time's flaking until that post, therefore he found me townie. Then,how did I go to decent reasoner to obvious scum just becuase I made a mistake about his frecuency of posting in this game? Oh yes, was it because the majority of players were against me? THE REASONS WHY HE VOTED ME ARENT SCUMTELLS.
I will add more reasoning to my case when I answer his the weekend. I have to go. Thats all for now.
In the meanwhile, could you do me a favor and answer him who has scumhunted more?
Mod: Any news in the replacements?
Sadly, no. I'm having a hard time finding replacements in either of my games.
Call me Tajo.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12894
Coming summer 2010: Tajo's Starcraft Mafia.
Tajo's MagictheGathering Mafia