Mini Normal 2326 | Everything has exploded !

[Dannflor]

and being overly reasonable*

[Vivax]

I can yeet gob for never trying to make sense.
But that‘s about my only reason, I think the derp is more often town but I can‘t know it for sure.

And Ninja it‘s not that Luca is the only one forcing himself through unpleasantries but rather that he acted as if Oats was his only concern there (maybe cause he‘s so obstinate which takes away all energy from scum.)

[Hu Tao]

VOTE: DarthPunk

I wouldn't hate oats or gob either. But think I prefer this

[DarthPunk]

Town: OOO, Hu Tao, Ninja

i think this is a pretty solid top town tier and as such I want to say vivax is also town

for other reasons too but i think this is a cute reason

Can you expand on the other reasons cause i am having trouble reading his slot with his wild scum teams.

Part of it *is* his wild scum teams? I feel like Vivax is operating in his own world and isn't really tuned in to what everyone thinks the most likely teams are. I think he would have to be as scum. I think he'd more conscious about making sure his scum teams made sense.

D1, I don't really understand why he'd start out white knighting Roden and then start to reevaluate him towards end of day (before he claimed). I think it would've been way more straightforward to just stick with the white knighting since it's not like Vivax's support was needed for Roden to get pushed to claim

See one of the things I really value when determining alignments is "can I understand this persons perspective on the game, and can I see they are thinking about the game in a way that makes sense for town."

This is why HT looks bad to me for example. Cause I need her posts to make sense to me, so when she agrees with a post that a Town!HT doesn't agree with, I wonder why she is not thinking like a townie should.

Vivax gets a bit more leeway because his reads often do not make sense to me as either alignment.

I am not sure vivax cares if his scum teams make sense as mafia either (at least he didn't last time I played with him and he was mafia)

[Oatsmaster]

gun to head i think luca is town

Do you think the same things that myself and ooo have noticed are untrue? not alignment indicative?

the whole luca contradicted himself by saying ninja's posts reflects his thoughts on the game almost entirely thing does nothing for me

the most compelling points to me were about luca seeming passive and being content with the gamestate and overly reasonably

i'm not really seeing the latter anymore

as i said the former does nothing for me

How is Luca not passive? He still basically just comes out to talk some shit with me and dp and leaves. He posted some quick iso “reviews” at the end of d1 but didn’t follow up on any of them

[Vivax]

Town: OOO, Hu Tao, Ninja

i think this is a pretty solid top town tier and as such I want to say vivax is also town

for other reasons too but i think this is a cute reason

Can you expand on the other reasons cause i am having trouble reading his slot with his wild scum teams.

Dann might take your place if he doesn‘t explain the gun to head.
Still don‘t see what would make Grack townish. He contributes nicely but that he also does as mafia. As town he‘s less performative from what I remember and doesn‘t shy away from the occasional shitpost.

[DarthPunk]

I can yeet gob for never trying to make sense.
But that‘s about my only reason, I think the derp is more often town but I can‘t know it for sure.

And Ninja it‘s not that Luca is the only one forcing himself through unpleasantries but rather that he acted as if Oats was his only concern there (maybe cause he‘s so obstinate which takes away all energy from scum.)

I want to lim into gob/luca/HT

[Oatsmaster]

Mildly confused why dann didn’t seem to react to my response to his “case”

[DarthPunk]

Town: OOO, Hu Tao, Ninja

i think this is a pretty solid top town tier and as such I want to say vivax is also town

for other reasons too but i think this is a cute reason

Can you expand on the other reasons cause i am having trouble reading his slot with his wild scum teams.

Dann might take your place if he doesn‘t explain the gun to head.
Still don‘t see what would make Grack townish. He contributes nicely but that he also does as mafia. As town he‘s less performative from what I remember and doesn‘t shy away from the occasional shitpost.

What do you think of Dann's case on oats?

[Dannflor]

grack has also been going against the grain of late

i feel like he had a natural evaluation between D1 and D2

fair point about Vivax's reads not making sense as either alignment though

[Vivax]

This game might turn me into a fan of Oats though.

Really liked how he made Dannflor dance on the last page.

[Dannflor]

Mildly confused why dann didn’t seem to react to my response to his “case”

i do not think it productive

[Dannflor]

I can yeet gob for never trying to make sense.
But that‘s about my only reason, I think the derp is more often town but I can‘t know it for sure.

And Ninja it‘s not that Luca is the only one forcing himself through unpleasantries but rather that he acted as if Oats was his only concern there (maybe cause he‘s so obstinate which takes away all energy from scum.)

I want to lim into gob/luca/HT

of these names I would join you on gob

[Dannflor]

How is Luca not passive? He still basically just comes out to talk some shit with me and dp and leaves. He posted some quick iso “reviews” at the end of d1 but didn’t follow up on any of them

I think he's pushing a narrative of the game that he believes is true now

I think he believes there's scum in you/DP and is doing with his time in thread what he can to further that

[Dannflor]

I refuse to dance

[DarthPunk]

Dann, doesn't your case on oats kind of rely on HT being town though.

If HT is mafia what does that mean about oats?

and if Oats is town what does that do to the rest of your reads.

[Oatsmaster]

Mildly confused why dann didn’t seem to react to my response to his “case”

i do not think it productive

Okay so I assume you agree with the things I brought up and are literally just sticking with “oats was awkward”
Because if you wanna yeet me off of that you can. Don’t think it’s a really strong argument and I’m pretty sure you know it’s not a strong argument either

[Oatsmaster]

How is Luca not passive? He still basically just comes out to talk some shit with me and dp and leaves. He posted some quick iso “reviews” at the end of d1 but didn’t follow up on any of them

I think he's pushing a narrative of the game that he believes is true now

I think he believes there's scum in you/DP and is doing with his time in thread what he can to further that

Okay so what you mean by not passive, you mean having strong opinions. Not actively trying to recruit other people into their mindset, trying to figure out who mafia is, trying to get other people yeeted.
Gotcha

[DarthPunk]

well there is no reason for gob to be town imo.

Shall we yeet him?

VOTE: gob

[Dannflor]

It does, I think HT is town.

If HT is mafia then I think oats is almost definitely town. If HT is mafia...

it probably makes it more likely that I'm wrong on Luca Blight

gob still probably has equal chances of being scum

[DarthPunk]

Look ill just come out and say it

The whole part of the game focusing on Luca Blight, Oats, Vibax and NinjaGirl is SHITE. Its so impossible to keep track and follow that groups reads on eachothers. It also doesnt help its hyper bloated.


Someone give me the rundown in a paragraph. If it cant be condensed in a paragraph, we need to move on from that whole conversation and history entirely.

In my opinion

Gob why did you leave my name off of here when you are having me in your lynch pool since day 1?

[Dannflor]

it looks like luca is trying to get people to see his side of things / get you yeeted to me

[Dannflor]

VOTE: gob

[Vivax]

grack has also been going against the grain of late

i feel like he had a natural evaluation between D1 and D2

fair point about Vivax's reads not making sense as either alignment though

Town: OOO, Hu Tao, Ninja

i think this is a pretty solid top town tier and as such I want to say vivax is also town

for other reasons too but i think this is a cute reason

[Dannflor]

we were talking about your scum reads there