Alright. Lets begin with a list.
Kairyuu:
I obviously know myself to be town, but I think that an outside viewpoint may be iffy on me based on the extended V/LA and the arguments with Illumina.
forbiddanlight:
I have barely any read on her. Nothing overly scummy, nothing overly townie. I am biased towards believing her about growing apathetic about this game, since I ended up doing that in a different game I was in for low activity reasons as well.
hp [leaves]:
I think that the note issue as well as the unprompted defense of him by Illumina paints him in a very scummy light. I would be happy with his lynch.
Illumina:
I've laid out my many reasons why I think he/she is scum. The recent defense of hp [leaves] right out of the blue is scummy as heck to me. There is no valid reason that I can think of other than masonship, which is nowhere close to guaranteed in a mind screw game, that he/she should be defending another player D1. Plus some more misrep that I will get to later.
Kinetic:
Another one I have nothing really to comment on. I'm curious to the extreme about how neutral he is on Illumina (take a side so I can update my notes already). Also, I still want to know why he seems to think I am scum.
MafiaSSK:
I asked him to try to contribute more, but he has not listened. I therefore have no information at all on him outside of small tidbits that remind me strongly of Empking's playstyle.
tajo:
The incident earlier makes him look somewhat scummy to me, but not at the top of my list or in danger of getting there anytime soon.
malthusis:
I didn't even realize that he was playing in this game until I saw Illumina address him about something. He needs to post more content.
Isacc:
Not a bad start. I find the position on Illumina to be strange (He attacks him/her and then when he/she decides to completely misrepresent our argument Isacc retracts most of the suspicion).
Tarhalindur:
Probably the strongest town read I have now that the information about the note is out in the open. Good ideas, and strong town play in my opinion.
veerus: There are a surprising number of people I have no read on in this game. He is one of them. People need to post more solid content.
Vi: Confuses the hell out of me. Flips straight from commenting on Illumina's scumminess to saying that I am the one who is scum within a few posts. Follows that with a refusal (with perfectly acceptable reasons) to elaborate on why I am scummy. I would still like an explanation, in small parts if necessary.
Natirasha: Is apparently a player in this game. Probably G-Man. Apparently Tar thinks he is metal, and Nat is claiming that there is no mycosinth pit in this game. Nat is also claiming to be town. If Nat is metal and is telling the truth about the pit, then he must be telling the truth about being town as well. Otherwise, we would be dealing with an anti-town player that is invincible, and I doubt even Nat would be that evil.
Therefore, I think Illumina is the most likely scum, but I think that Nat may be the best lynch information-wise.
unvote
and
vote: Natirasha
Because, no matter how you dress it up, that's what the world is. A community of idiots doing a series of things until the world explodes and we all die.