Martyr Mafia - Game Over

[Double A]

But it's my first game... WAAAAH!

[Zakeri]

I'm going to have a lot of spare time tomorrow on the computer, so I'll make the effort to post all of my thoughts on here. If nothing else, you can all use it as information for the rest of the game if I get lynched.

[Indigo Heron]

Reporting for Mafia game. I'll be catching up over the next day or two, hopefully.

[DrippingGoofball]

Hey guys, I'm here to replace some guy.

So who's God?

And in the meantime:

VOTE: ZACHARI

This player is scum. Replacing in and just like that, adding a vote to the biggest wagon.

Thanks for replacing BTW

[mykonian]

Hey guys, I'm here to replace some guy.

So who's God?

And in the meantime:

VOTE: ZACHARI

This player is scum. Replacing in and just like that, adding a vote to the biggest wagon.

Thanks for replacing BTW

that player is not the most experienced player in the world.

[DrippingGoofball]

that player is not the most experienced player in the world.

I reckon but it still my duty to look for scum!

[populartajo]

DGB is scum. AMIRITE, AMIRITE?

[Double A]

I seriously have no strategy other than to not die...

Like I said, this is my first game.

[Double A]

And how can I get the FoS in a game without scum?

[Double A]

...and how can I get the FoS in a game without scum?

[Jahudo]

If I read it correctly, she wasn't thinking about reactions at all, not that she didn't know what reactions to expect.

Agreed. On the surface he is stating the latter is true, but since the results and implications of these reactions were not part of his motivation to change his vote, I think that either:

A) he was not looking for reactions but instead getting his way out of a serious situation to a non-serious one, or
B) he wouldn't think about the effects until after the experiment and also not care about suspicion he received because townies aren't afraid of being under suspicion.

So if/when he does have a case for these reactions his motivation may become clearer.

And in the meantime: VOTE: ZACHARI

Double A, is this vote a joke or do you think he is scum? If so, why? If not, why?

DGB is scum. AMIRITE, AMIRITE?

How so?

And how can I get the FoS in a game without scum?

God and cults are scum in this game.

MOD: PROD INACTIVES

All you've done is call zwetchen stupid so you're not exactly active either. What else do you have to say?

[zwetschenwasser]

DGB is trying to lynch me with no good reason. That's why.

FoS: DGB and Double A

[Jebus]

Thank you pop! Care to explain to the world why I'm an obvious agnostic?

Only a retarded cult leader or a retarded God can dare the whole town to lynch him in D1 (policy reasons, antitown behaviour, etc). Or a genious and I dont think you are that good. (Are you an alt of someone?) I buy that making fun of things can be a lifestyle. And meta reasons.

And it's exactly this logic that gets me killed every time. As in, very bad logic, even for this setup.


So I ignore this altogether (as much as I hate it) and assume it's a joke. I thought I unvoted zwet already, but either way,

unvote

[zwetschenwasser]

Bad logic? I don't follow you.

[Bloodmoney]

Just got home. Need to get some sleep in. Will take a look in the morning.

[zwetschenwasser]

Hopefully he's not as nasty and unfriendly...

[populartajo]

@zwet, I would like your experience in mafia games in your next post.
@Jahudo: I was joking with DGB. I always guess her alignment in every game we have been together so far, IIRC.

[X]

quote="zwetschenwasser"]Thank you pop! Care to explain to the world why I'm an obvious agnostic?

Only a retarded cult leader or a retarded God can dare the whole town to lynch him in D1 (policy reasons, antitown behaviour, etc). Or a genious and I dont think you are that good. (Are you an alt of someone?) I buy that making fun of things can be a lifestyle. And meta reasons.

And it's exactly this logic that gets me killed every time. As in, very bad logic, even for this setup.

So I ignore this altogether (as much as I hate it) and assume it's a joke. I thought I unvoted zwet already, but either way,

unvote

[/quote]QFT.

I seriously have no strategy other than to not die...

No one else answer this - can you win if you die?

If I read it correctly, she wasn't thinking about reactions at all, not that she didn't know what reactions to expect.

Agreed. On the surface he is stating the latter is true, but since the results and implications of these reactions were not part of his motivation to change his vote, I think that either:

A) he was not looking for reactions but instead getting his way out of a serious situation to a non-serious one, or
B) he wouldn't think about the effects until after the experiment and also not care about suspicion he received because townies aren't afraid of being under suspicion.

So if/when he does have a case for these reactions his motivation may become clearer.

Okay...I gotcha. It's a nulltell. And you just made me realize that Zakeri's a guy.

Hm, so back to my old hunch, or a new one? I'll see what Double A says first...

Unvote: Zakeri

,

Vote: Jebus

.

[zwetschenwasser]

poptajo: My meta is posting short, quick things. Although they may seem concise, I personally do not prefer long detailed reads, as I believe that I can come up with my own conclusions and post them in a much more to the point, concise way. I only goof around when I see nothing to be gained by posting serious thoughts. I'm currently in nine games in MafiaScum, I'm modding a theme game in another forum, and have been playing the game on other forums for about six months.

[Indigo Heron]

I think that Double A is acting the way he is because of his play style. Granted, if it is, it's extremely unorthodox, but it's a play style nonetheless.

In any case, we don't know whether he is a veteran of Mafia games, so we'll just have to take it that he is an IC. I can see Double A as someone whose predecessor has been recruited into a cult, and is now taking pains to take the heat off God or cult leader (whichever one of the few people you think right now is). Or, he can simply be a enthusiastic agnostic.

[zwetschenwasser]

I'm guessing agnostic, as he seems quite harmless... "Guchi gugu. Good baby. Pwetty AIIIGH!!! The #$%$#@ baby bit my $#!@$% finger!"

[Double A]

Err... I thought this was the first day, so I can't be recruited.

How can God be scum?

Yeah, I am unorthodox. It's a side effect of watching Red vs. Blue a lot. And South Park.

Plus, my vote kinda was a joke, I was just bored. so

UNVOTE: ZACHARI

until I get a better reason to vote.

[Jebus]

How can God be scum?

We are agnostic. We win if we stay agnostic. Cults lose if God dies. Cults stop us from being agnostic. Cults win if we kill the leaders of the other two cults. Therefore the only way for us agnostics to win is to kill god.

The question scares me.

[Indigo Heron]

Just to clarify a few things surrounding my relatively ignorant knowledge of cults...

1. If a cult leader is killed off, what happens to the cult (and all its members)?

2. Can a cult leader turn an enemy cultist? If he/she can't, then can he/she turn an enemy cultist after the enemy cultist's leader is killed?

[Double A]

And what happens to the rest of the cult when their leader dies?

Or did Indigo already ask that?