[quote="mysterious numbers (hai Count of Monte Cristo)]4-2-2[/quote]
Hmm.
Alive, Day 2:
4 - Town, fairly clearly. (presumably Tarhalindur, Isacc, veerus, UROE)
2 - Mafia (forbiddanlight, MafiaSSK)
2 - Neutral (poptajo, Vi?)
1 - Not a Faction (Illumina*)
Dead, Day 2:
2 - Town (Natirasha**, zwetschenwasser)
1? - Mafia? (Kinetic?)
1 - Neutral (hp [leaves])
* - Count of Monte Cristo has always provided a list of factions. I've only made one neutral with a triggered win condition that counted as a member of a faction (Star Child, Mind Screw 1 - Babylon 5 Soul Hunter doesnt count due to the anti-factions), while all others that didn't have to kill off all other factions (Mind Screw 3 Haruhi, all Mind Screw 3 Jesters, Ocarina of Time Past-Ganondorf - all didn't have to be killed off for other factions to win) have explicitly said they don't count as a faction.
Now, the standard wording of the Count of Monte Cristo ability:
Mind Screw 3 wrote:The Day of Sagittarius:
"Until further notice, each Vote Count will contain a list of the number of factions and the number of surviving players in each of those factions."
If Illumina had the "are not counted as a faction" clause in his win con, the mysterious numbers make sense as a Count result: Illumina wasn't a faction (and hence not counted) and Vi was an SK-miller (can you confirm this, Vi?).
Hell, this theory would also explain why Nat screwed up on the original Count result (4-2-
3
) in the first place - he forgot that Illumina wasn't a member of a faction (as per win condition) and included him in the count of the neutrals.
I probably should have caught on to this earlier.
** - Natirasha wasn't Prinny at the point of the original Count, since he was revived at end of Day 2.
Now, I just had another, probably insane thought... what if Kinetic's role was such that two players (Kinetic, MafiaSSK) had the same role, but only one counted towards the Mafia win condition? When the first one died off, the second would become the only real player...
Doesn't affect the play today at all, but it's an interesting idea to speculate on.