Newbie 762 - OhGodMyVillage - Game Over

[PhilyEc]

/Confirm~

[PhilyEc]

Mod: Sorry to bother ya, are dvdkid13 & astil eligible for a prod? Seems like theyve flaked =/

[PhilyEc]

Vote Santos

for his was the first name I saw.

[PhilyEc]

Wow. huge explosion in wall of texts. I'll read through them but I struggle with these kind of beginnings. Makes it hard to analyse for me .-.

[PhilyEc]

And I do consider the fact that phily is around the site important, yes.

I am not too keen on this over analysis off of Mastins, he is analysing every single sentence ffs and sugerically mutilating posts.

FoS Mastinsp

I think theres far more agreeable ways of behaving without confusing town members such as Santos and I. Mastins, you need to quit it with pure 'logic' and simply give shorter posts. Keeping up with the game and going through one post at a time might help. For votes obviously a case quoting multiple posts is fine.

(Note: Overanalysis is common place in newbie games)

[PhilyEc]

ignore the p in my FoS <_<

[PhilyEc]

If not do you see anything interesting so far within his posts; anything either directed at him or in who he is pestering?

The fact that I saw a thick loooong wall of text pestered me. I think others can speak for themselves, I'm merely posting the reason why I've not helped much. I really dont tend to analyse MASSIVE texts as much as I do short-normal sized texts until the game starts actually going somewhere. I doubt he can go anywhere this early thus such long elaborations are unnecessary. MY OPINION.

Do you think that Mastin's long posts and analysis are any kind of tell? If not do you think that it might at least be some kind of tactic that we should be able to read the motives of?

TBH I'm skimming at the moment, been tired all week after Oral Exams (do not giggle) and a game with this kind of start completely turned me off of getting very involved. Too honest?

What are your thoughts beyond the fact that you think he talks too much? Just curious.

Sounds liike hes really into this game and likes checking up on it, does he act dimmissive in his banter? If so then hes more likely to be scum.

(Hope that helps and I do apologise for letting myself get this worn out)

[PhilyEc]

Phil disliking long posts and wanting shorter posts might be just an opinion difference, but I found it rather anti-town

LOL I think thats the case

well into the game

. Its a fucking turn off all together from the very beginning. My lack of energy is probably contributing to my opinion to be fair.

So...you're FoS'ing me...for being thorough? For looking for scum tells? For actually contributing to the game with my thoughts?

I'm FoSing you because I'm suspicious of you. I'm suspicious of you for playing so aggressively('thouroughly') so early. Far too eager to find scum when we have a ton of time to get a mass of scum acts from players.

So...you want me to stop making sense...to stop actually explaining my actions...you want me to stop showing logic and just go off of other things such as gut...for no other reason other than to have shorter posts? Again, that's just something which I can't feel is anything but scummy.

Get your foot out my mouth plz? Done? Thanks! Any example of what I think of your actions is;
Dude: Vote Blah, sorry but you're obviously the last scum.
Mastins: ZOMG 'sorry' buddying if I've ever seen it! Lets waste an entire page into why it is or not! Why do you question me? ITs pro town! You're anti town for thinking its not helpful!

Fin~

And what do you call what I'm doing right now?

You're making mince of posts and overcomplicating things. It 'pesters' me. Makes me not want to play to be frank. Relax and take your time is my only advice, I'm not the only one that doesnt find your MASS POSTING helpful. Are we all wrong?

---

Are your questions answered? Should I expected another array of them? ¬¬

[PhilyEc]

as the game has not really started.

The game has become stagnant and alot of people aint posting. Its because those GIANT posts so early are selfish efforts to look town to other players. Unfortunately, this act discourages widespread contributions. I think acts which stagnate the entire game deserve an FoS as its directly effecting our ability to find scum.

Towards the second half of your post. Its called grandstanding. Scum attempting to take over the reigns of scumhunts to direct them in the wrong way. It takes skill but I dont quite buy it. I think the effort to look town is far too strong on his part (considering its only been 4 pages and his posts are huge).

Afraid of his posts? No. Find them majorly needless in size? Yes. Its making me not want to play the game and I'd say others could agree on this opinion considering the amount of activity.

Why is him talking so much a bad thing?

As if I want him to stop posting? You can stop right there. I dont approve of HUGE POSTS IN FIRST 3 PAGES.

Kay?

But so far in this game you have done nothing but want to limit what is said.

Bull. I want this game to go efficiently and be readable. Not see this game turn into a 3 hour shitting session every page every post, giant walls of text boucing back and forth between a minority of players.

It creates confusion, end of.

[PhilyEc]

My posts are being taken wildly out of context by the butcher known as Mastins.

quote1.
Okay, so I dont like your playstyle? Its still bad for town in the long run as it promotes back to back long posts and leaves other players/replacements in the dark. Scum keep to their playstyles to avoid metaing so why would this matter? you are still fully possible scum.

quote2.
Read your posts and you'll see what parts I decided to bring into my 'paraphrasing', this is exactly how I see you. A butcherer of text and manipulation of (my) opinion.

quote3.
Yet you leave me having to explain my own opinion on long/short posts, more reason for me think consider your posts a waste of town time. Of players effort. Of efforts that could be devoted towards reading more inviting texts in order to see any scummy traits. Me not liking your play so far = scummy? Its completely irrelevant to wheter I got a scum role. Opinions definately vary and ours definately dont see eye-to-eye.

quote4.
More butchering, I said 'relax and take your time' never have I told you to STOP. Suspicions grow as the thread grows. Hurling in every suspicion into the same post that crosses your mind doesnt help, understand what I'm getting at yet? Concentrate on the scummiest actions until you're satisfied. Thats what I think helps all players and not just your own position(town or scum) in others opinions.

quote5.
Again, I fear nothing from this game. I'm open to opinions but your questions settle only your curiousities about my opinions rather than pursuing something that could imply im scum. Seems a direct confrontation for personal reason since I have only recently voiced a growing suspicion on you. Do you see the scumminess in that? The amount of questions over such an easily understandable fact?

I've answered all questions directed at me, doesnt mean I have to approve of them. I in fact, find them very useless and this was my point from the beginning.

[PhilyEc]

Ironic considering that you are trying to get people to talk less.

Due to the volume of text this early, I think its a fair enough opinion. Though im sure I'll have to say this again another half dozen times ¬¬ Use of the word people isnt something I like to see. Theres one person who seems to be confusing town, everyones just responding to that volume. Heres an example of these posts and their results;

I'm leaning towards Mastin. The vote-or-die-mother****** on his self is suspect.

And yes, his habit of quoting ever single line is hard as hell to read

I know, but its brutal to read the discombobulated posts :/

---

Scien, far too dismissive. Defending Mantins from what I see as you continue to question and dismiss whatever I say. Town should really look into how credible this is when considering this is the kind of action we wait for scum to make.

Vote Scien

far too devoted to this little topic.

[PhilyEc]

FoS The obvious Mastin/Scien team

Mastin, I'll read your response at some point but I really cant humour it right now for obvious reason.

[PhilyEc]

Phily: I do not like at all how you are dismissing the begining discussion stages of the game, and in my eyes it is very anti town to do so, and thereby quite scummy.

Their gameplay is something I dont like. Scum team be grandstanding and I am adamant that Scien is scum. As for Mastins it could be a case of him being leeched off. Scien jumped to defenses the second I posted negativity towards Mastins which just screams scum trying to look as town as possible and reflect suspicion.

Isn't this exactly whats happened? I never address Scien until he did the favour first and then after he got HEAVILY involved. I even got double teamed at some point on page 4 for a good few posts~

Either
1) Hes scum defending a town player.
2) Scum team have stupidly revealed themselves through buddying.
3) Both are town and merely semantic fanboys. (Unlikely due to context of disagreement being so dwelled upon).

Note, I've never demanded restriction of posts. I've voiced my dislike of how the Day has begun and how awkward the game will become

in my opinion

. Early grandstanding = ambitious scum. Got it yet?

[Moves onto read page 5]

[PhilyEc]

Um... there is still the same things I disagree with the above two posts. And I might post on it when I have more time. But this one is worth posting now:

Either
1) Hes scum defending a town player.
2) Scum team have stupidly revealed themselves through buddying.
3) Both are town and merely semantic fanboys. (Unlikely due to context of disagreement being so dwelled upon).

I know that you are just simplifying things. But just because I am townie doesn't mean that Mastin is. Don't jump the gun there. You know what I'm going to tell you, that I have a protown role. But if the town is truly irritated at my play and when I flip townie, don't go and assume Mastin is town as well. Just saying.

Wait..I think I've been tunneling too much too. I'm looking at this game as figuring out wheter both of you are one of 1-3 but only when you addressed that situation and asked town to not 'mislynch' Mastins immediately did I realise this town you've addressed has people merely watching our arguement.

In the end we disagree on semantics and no one else felt added anything to the dispute.

In summary, high chance the readers are mainly scum. Whos lurking at the moment (incl active lurks)

[PhilyEc]

I'm here reading, so far it seems theres been another semantics arguement, Mastins has vanished and sirdanilot has just got a shot of steriods in the ass since this is the first time I've seen him contributing like this.

Sirdani is making a meal of his approach on Papa but hes definately over investing his focus. Could fall into a steep tunnel soon~