Mini 763 - Carnival Mafia - Game Over

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

First things first, let's talk about how awesome I am that I got you people to put me at L-1 in two pages and then got all those votes off me in the same time span. Simply put, I rule.

Simply put that wasn't useful.

Sure was fun though.

[Shanba]

Town never lynches scum day 2. Honestly, we're better off random lynching.

Vote: grimmy

for weak distancing coupled with trying to distract from the ChiefSkye wagon. Not

too

keen on lynching Nocmen, but I could run with it.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Shanba replaced Datadanne, right?

Vote: Shanba

[WeyounsLastClone]

@DDD: I don't think getting yourself at L-1 in two pages gives you bragging rights.

I don't know what Shanba is doing, but 'we might as well lynch randomly' seems awfully familiar and awfully disappointing to start day 2 with. Coupled with Datadanne's behavior before Shanba, I'm gonna

vote: Shanba

.

[WeyounsLastClone]

Hmm, missed the smiley in Shanba's post. (but my vote still stands for even uttering the words 'random lynch'... )

[Shanba]

...

[Shanba]

I'm lost for words.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

I'm lost for words.

I have some words you could borrow...

Unvote

Vote: WLC

[VP Baltar]

I approve that message from Danny.

Vote WLC

Why should you vote Shanba even though you know he was joking?

Where were you after Chief came under suspicion?

In fact, looking back at the posts, your last post on Day 1 was #142. I made a PBPA of you in post 145 and you never came back the rest of the day to answer or make any contribution to the game whatsoever.

[Empking]

I'm lost for words.

I have some words you could borrow...

Unvote

Vote: WLC

Why was that scummy?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Not picking up on sarcasm is the clearest scumtell in the book, empking. Surely you know that.

[Nocmen]

First things first, let's talk about how awesome I am that I got you people to put me at L-1 in two pages and then got all those votes off me in the same time span. Simply put, I rule.

Simply put that wasn't useful.

Noc: Did you gdet any money last night or did I read your role wrong?

I got no message at all, so I'm assuming I have not.

DDD: Getting to L-1 is nothing to brag about at all.
Why so happy to jump and Vote WLC?

WLC: Why so quick to vote Shanba for that?

[WeyounsLastClone]

I guess I was just a bit disappointed in Shanba in the way that he posted a lot of interesting content on day 1, and then he starts with not much more than a random comment (which contains the words 'random lynch', something that I think was talked about enough, whether in a funny way or not) on day 2. There is a reasonable decent explanation for Grimmy, but I don't like how he expresses his meaning on an eventual Nocmen lynch, seems it could be used too much as a fallback.

I don't really like the ease with which DDD is switching his vote. As for my absence the rest of day 1: real life didn't leave me much time for mafia, and another game I was in (War in Heaven II) took that time because I was about to be eliminated there.

[VP Baltar]

It was pretty clear that Shanba was teasing DDD about his plan for lynching day 1. Not sure why you didn't get that since you participated in that discussion (before you disappeared).

[Kairyuu]

As much as I hate to do this because I like the way he is playing, I must

vote: Nocmen

. You proved that you were not aligned with the town during D1. Unless you can provide a good reason why we should keep you alive, I think you are the best choice.

On another note, WLC I could run with, but not Shanba. I see no reason to lynch him.

[VP Baltar]

One thing I think you should look at Kairyuu is Nocmen's interaction with Chief yesterday. I looked back over it and it comes off town to me. He was one of the first to push chief for her slip ups.

That being said, ortolan was also suspect of him. Could be a scum ploy to draw attention to Nocmen though with that kill, since Nocmen had some suspicious statements about alignment.

Weyouns, do you care to respond to my PBPA or do I need to formulate questions for you?

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Convenient, VPB, that you don't mention that Nocmen was posting about your slip-up in estimating the number of scum.

[Shinnen_no_Me]

Hmmm... Weyouns' case just don't seem quite appealing to me. I mean, it's possible he slipped the smiley face, hence thinking that Shanba was really for a random lynch. However, I'm suspicious about Nocmen and his slip with his goal. But, didn't the mod told us the last time to stop making cases based on the PM roles? What would be different this time? Also, VP has a point there. When I read Nocmen, there are times when I get good pro-town vibes from him. However, there are other times when I smell something fishy... So, I can't really make a stance just yet based on what we have. Though, IGMEOY.

[VP Baltar]

Convenient, VPB, that you don't mention that Nocmen was posting about your slip-up in estimating the number of scum.

Yes, I tend not to bring up irrelevant facts. If you would like to lynch me because my math is awful, then I suppose there isn't much I can do.

I would as you this as well, however: if I was scum, why would I be defending someone who is suspicious of me when I could easily push for his lynch?

[Grimmy]

You should probably claim, Chief.

WOAH.

Totally missed this post.

And, once again, sorry for the double-post.

I'm the Bearded Lady. I'm a little off, but not crazy. The entire freakshow has been taking hits lately with the Puppeteer stealing my fans. I don't have any special abilities.

This post occured after I had left and I wouldnt have been able to see this until monday, as i am away on weekends.

but for what its worth, this would have gotten my immediate vote as the description in the beginning of the game stated the bearded lady was dead.

Grimmy
for what its worth

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Anyways, it appears that Empking has some sort of investigative role and from his reaction to Nocmen I'd suggest that Noc's role isn't overtly scummy. So, I'm personally crossing those two off my possible scum list for the rest of the day.

[VP Baltar]

Dear scum, please kill the following two persons....

*fixed*
Why the hell would you say that even if you believe it? I would policy lynch you if WLC wasn't obvscum.

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: Noc

I don't beleive he's town.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Dear scum, please kill the following two persons....

*fixed*
Why the hell would you say that even if you believe it? I would policy lynch you if WLC wasn't obvscum.

Just trying to help the town out, removing two people from consideration. Though Empking's last post really blows that idea to hell, I'd like to know what seemingly inside information he has that the rest of us don't.

[VP Baltar]

reading emp's posts I don't see anything that indicates he has an investigative power, nor do I think we should be speculating on it until the town comes to an agreement that we should do so.