Martyr Mafia - Game Over

[Gorrad]

I came, I had fun, I conquered.

[PokerFace]

So wait this game boiled down to a war between Jews and Islams?

Who was the only Christian? Wierd how Je

b

us was the Bad Son.

Nice No Town, Heavy Cult & Lyncher setup right here. Go Gurgi!

You are an

Altar Boy

. You can not win unless you are recurited by a Cult. Good Luck.

You are a

God Son

. You can not win unless you are recurited by a Mafia. Good Luck.

[PokerFace]

Who was the only Christian Recruit?

Fixed*

[populartajo]

[mykonian]

I hope that all these are all Islamitic. Or else...

DrippingGoofball, Gorrad, populartajo, al_kohaulec, SilverPhoenix, Indigo Heron

[SilverPhoenix]

I didn't die in vain! DGB is awesome! And the rest of my cult!

I think I got recruited night 1?

It would have been fun to lynch Zakeri in the first place like I wanted to, but I'll take this win too.

Yes, but DGB was my Night 0.

I was the Islamic CR. DGB is entirely in my debt for being such an unapologetic cult "leader" in my place. My Night 0 choice was probably the best decision I've ever made in a game thus far. Good win, Islamites!

[SilverPhoenix]

Also, we found about X being CR during Night 4 when I tried recruited you the previous night and failed. This combined with semi-intense protection of zwet during the day made it crystal clear that you were CR.

[Jahudo]

Yes DGB was a good choice. That was amazing watching her order everyone around by telling them how to vote

Looker, man, you gotta read the new stuff when you enter into the game as the most important role! I was so pissed when you killed the wrong person. It's a good thing you know how to lurk and DGB knows how to distract and distance.

[X]

Also, we found about X being CR during Night 4 when I tried recruited you the previous night and failed. This combined with semi-intense protection of zwet during the day made it crystal clear that you were CR.

Dammit. That's actually pretty bad, because I was doing that because it was my honest understanding of what the best agnostic play would be. I wasn't really protecting ZSW because I had recruited him. That was coincidental.

DGB was a fantastic choice. Zakeri and Looker played fairly poorly - I'm amazed they fulfilled their win conditions.

Also, how did you guys figure out that I failed at recruiting so many times?

N0:

Jebus

Yeah, that made me confused for a while.
N1:

ting =)

A player that wouldn't be too obvious. I feel that I got gipped because of MafiaSSK's playstyle.
N2:

Adel

That's right. Adel was an Agnostic throughout her whole tirade against Jebus. Looker screwed me over on this one.
N3:

ZSW

I was pretty confident he hadn't been recruited yet. Then you guys decided to make a huge random wagon on him.
N4:

PIP

Already culted.
N5:

ortolan

Really wish he hadn't actually confirmed that I was CL.
N6:

No Recruit

I didn't want to be a dick, if the Muslims were going to be kind to the Agnostics. That was all in vain, though.

So yeah, nice job SilverPhoenix. You played that really well, and deserved to win. I thought you were possible cult on D2, but I wasn't sure.

Mod, great job. This game should be run again, no matter who runs it. I can't guarantee that I'll be able to be in it, but it's a great idea and was tons of fun.

[X]

Oh, it's fine with me if you post the QT, MafiaSSK, seeing as we're the only two who have posted in it.

[Adel]

Also, how did you guys figure out that I failed at recruiting so many times?

they didn't. You and ort got played. I was pulling out my hair with frustration.

If Looker hadn't killed me (which would've been a genius move had I been N, and I don't think that killing me was a bad move for him, killing me was insurance in case Jebus really wasn't N.) I think this game would've played out quite differently.

[X]

Also, how did you guys figure out that I failed at recruiting so many times?

they didn't. You and ort got played. I was pulling out my hair with frustration.

Me? I didn't let on that we had failed at recruiting. I tried to play Agnostic up until post 1881.

[populartajo]

When did you realize I was not an agnostic?

[Adel]

Also, how did you guys figure out that I failed at recruiting so many times?

they didn't. You and ort got played. I was pulling out my hair with frustration.

Me? I didn't let on that we had failed at recruiting. I tried to play Agnostic up until post 1881.

but you gave up and didn't push NL as being the optimal move for agnostics (it was). Once you were outed you didn't bluff (or mindfuck) them into thinking that that you had superior numbers.

I really wish I hadn't been killed by god. I think we would've made a good team.

[Adel]

gg. The House of Islam really played well.

[al_kohaulec]

I was the agnostic cop. I could investigate one player each night and determine if they were a cult recruiter or not. I won when I got two CL's lynched (they couldn't be nightkilled).

[populartajo]

Now that I think about it agnostics would have easily won this game day 1 if zwet hadnt claimed cult leader.

[Jahudo]

Now that I think about it agnostics would have easily won this game day 1 if zwet hadnt claimed cult leader.

Or just listen to EA: He called the game on page 3. I kept wondering why no one speculated why he died night 1.

[ortolan]

Really wish he hadn't actually confirmed that I was CL.

This had no bearing on the game. We were outnumbered. You should have protected your recruit (zwet) the previous day instead of hiding for no reason. There was no reason to hide from the other cult when they didn't have a clear numerical advantage (and even if they did you're pretty much unavoidably screwed at that point anyway). Also, if you'd actually helped with a display of power at the start of day six we were (more) likely to win. I already had mykonian and Indigo Herron acting like potential Jews.

I was sad that I to tried to appeal to al_kohaulec's emotion when he stated a preference for the more numerous cult, then have him change his mind (when ironically we were in the minority) and vote for the "minority" cult.

[Adel]

hey ortolan, I really enjoyed interacting with you Day 2. I look forward to playing with you in future games.

[ortolan]

same You were Jew at that point, right?

[Adel]

nope. agnostic. I was recruited in the same period of night that god killed me, that bastard I figured that I would be recruited night 2 regardless of what I typed during day 2, so I felt that I only had that one day to fulfill my current win condition. I think I would've been more successful had Jebus been more active and involved, and if you hadn't given me so much grief. Looker was in my top 3 IIRC.. let me check..

[Adel]

1 out of (Jebus,zwet,zakeri,Jahudo) is god. There is a real chance that qwint naming Jebus as unrecruitable was a wifom gambit.. he had nothing to lose at that point.

fuck, with the lynch and N. kill we had a 50% chance of winning off of this list.

[Indigo Heron]

Well, I got screwed out of a spot in the winning cult...

I'm still agnostic, damn it!

[ortolan]

I'd forgotten that I'd actually been trying to lynch Zakeri, who turned out to be God, pretty much all of days 2 and 3.