Newbie 762 - OhGodMyVillage - Game Over

[Scien]

Sorry catching up with the explosion... will post soon.

[Henrz]

Oh place it now... Probably on You/Reckoner.

[Henrz]

Whey!

[Scien]

Ok... Henrz and PapaZ are now proved to not both be scum (although one or the other could be). Otherwise they would have hammered.

Let me think of what else we can get out of this...

[Henrz]

Dum de dum dum de dee...

[Scien]

I can't believe that Mitey and Reckoner are doing this to distance. So one of them are scum.

That means one of the outside party (Henrz, PapaZ, Scien) are scum, I trust PapaZ and know my role, and can't make up my mind between Mitey or Reckoner.

I think in this situation we should lynch Henrz. Strange though, I didn't think the case on him was that strong, thats why I was never pursuing him hard, just posting observations for him to comment on.

[Scien]

EBWOP Case on him wasn't that strong. Sorry.

[Scien]

What do you think Papa?

[Scien]

(Also since Henrz is apparently watching the thread you can infer that both of us are not scum, however one or the other might be)

[Henrz]

Huh what, why me? Or maybe I was right, and it's a Reckoner Scien combo... Or a Reckoner Papa combo, or a Mitey Scien combo, or a Scien Papa combo, and it could go on and on

[Henrz]

You could always make up your mind to go for Reckoner or Mitey...

[Henrz]

My gut instinct would be Reckoner... But it could be either really...

[Scien]

You could always make up your mind to go for Reckoner or Mitey...

Eh, I tried to explain. I don't think that both Mitey and Reckoner are scum, but one is.
Since both you and PapaZ were posting at the same time, if you were both scum you would have hammered the townie with a vote on them.
That means that there is a scum in the current votes, and a scum outside.
I trust PapaZ. I know my role. That leaves you.

You could always make up your mind to go for Reckoner or Mitey...

You don't care? Thats suspicious. Which would you like to see lynched?

[Scien]

My gut instinct would be Reckoner... But it could be either really...

Woah. No you would never try and suggest someone lynch what you claim you think is a 50/50. Assuming you are townie for a sec, using the logic I just posted you could decide almost certainly which between Papa and me are scum depending on who you think is more townie between us. Are you saying you think we are both very town?

[Henrz]

OMG U TRUST PAPA Z U MUST BE BUDDING!!!!111 LOLWUT NOOB.
Why'd you quote twice? The same phrase? And I already put who I'd like Lynched.

[Scien]

I'm not doing anything until Papa comes back and posts on my comments.

I am ready for a vote on you now though.

I will be away for around 3 hours I have a flight lesson, but I will be back after that to check in on things.

[Henrz]

But it could be either, we don't know. In response to your previous post (588). It was like I said that you and Reckoner were both at the top, but not at the top together, because it's one or the other, the same with this. Papa's been fine the whole game, so have you. It all depends really, I won't give anymore away. If I'm lynched, nothing will happen, except for a town loss. Basically, you're both roughly the same scummyness level, I wouldn't want either of you lynched today, Miety/Reckoner, Reckoner would be my candidate.

[Scien]

Oh, just to get more information out there...

You can look at my play here as information as well. Am I pressing for Henrz or PapaZ to place a vote on one of the easy targets at the moment? No. I am pressing for what I think is the sure scum at the moment. The hard person to lynch currently.

If I was scum I could just throw up the cloud of "Oh either of the people with votes on them I can't decide" and hope for a townie mistake, as opposed to thinking about what the current situation logically means about roles.

[Henrz]

Just a question, can you draw in a mafia game?

[Papa Zito]

What do you think Papa?

Sorry, was AFK. (I'm at work)

Like I said earlier, I'm good with either Henrz or Mitey, though I'd prefer a Henrz lynch since he's my top suspect. I didn't want to make a move either way until you got a chance to review though.

[Papa Zito]

xRECKONERx, would you support a Henrz lynch, or are you absolute on your Mitey vote?

[Henrz]

Do not Lynch me, I've

LOGICALLY

worked out who's scum.

[xRECKONERx]

Well, I'm kinda in the same boat where I'm very confident on Mitey, but rather 50/50 on Scien/Henrz. However, given Scien's current willingness on a Henrz lynch, I'd be more than willing to switch my vote to Henrz.

[Papa Zito]

I did a pseudo-vote count, based on what's been said in the thread. Votes in bold are real votes.

Vote Count:

3 to lynch

Henrz: 2 (Scien, Papa Zito)
xRECKONERx: 2 (MiteyMouse, Henrz)
MiteyMouse: 1 (

xRECKONERx

)

[xRECKONERx]

New Updates:

Zito:

Still getting strong town reads on him, and apparently he's the designated "He's our most probable town, so everybody try to get on his good side" player. Seems like almost everyone is FoS'ing one of either me, Mitey, Scien, or Henrz, and Zito is kind of the one who has to sort it all out.

Mitey:

Lurks. Lurks. Lurks. Says I'm her top suspect. Then has to go back to "form a case" and... comes up with almost nothing substantial. Still my most probable scum.

Henrz:

I was pretty much honing in on Henrz yesterday, and due to the me vs. Scien thing at the start of today and Mitey's un-lurkage, he kind of took a backseat. He's my #2 at the moment... I'd be more confident on Mitey, alas, if Henrz is who the rest of the town wants...

Scien:

Townish read, but I think Scien's a very good player and could easily be scum appearing very pro-town.