Mini 788 - Fantasy Mafia [OVER]

[Empking]

OP: Because I'm town.

OP: I think my posts made it very clear that my point on the island wasn't about not using meta.

OP: Why should I post about things I support?

[Shadow Knight]

Ok. Sorry all, should have time this evening to do my re-read and post. Summer classes started and work is kicking my ass. Don't want to be replaced though, so please bear with me.

[orangepenguin]

OP: Why should I post about things I support?

Well, what if someone you think is town and is about to get lynched. Do you not defend them? Or do you just let them get lynched?

If you post about what you support, it can be useful for the town (on the downside: it can also give scum info, depending on what you say)

[TonyMontana]

Sorry, hectic week. I'll be V/LA until sunday, will post something relevant after.

[SensFan]

*sigh*
Need to replace Mixologist.
Looking...

[Empking]

OP: Why should I post about things I support?

Well, what if someone you think is town and is about to get lynched. Do you not defend them? Or do you just let them get lynched?

If you post about what you support, it can be useful for the town (on the downside: it can also give scum info, depending on what you say)

Is anyone about to get lynched?

[orangepenguin]

Not really, but that's not the point.

[orangepenguin]

Mod, I will be V/LA from June 15 - June 18

[Goatrevolt]

Nothing has happened in the last few days.

I'm waiting for Tony Montana to come back, and I would still love to see ZazieR address my post, as was promised a real long time ago.

[Starbuck]

This game just seems to be dragging.

Or is it just me?

[Goatrevolt]

This game just seems to be dragging.

Or is it just me?

Dragging? What would make you say that?

[ortolan]

[Goatrevolt]

And the game is now officially dragging.

[Starbuck]

Well it took someone (you), two days to respond to that question.

I'd say that's dragging.

[Starbuck]

Well it took someone (you), two days to respond to that question.

I'd say that's dragging.

[TonyMontana]

Life is kicking my ass.. I don't wanna burden SensFan with replacing me (especially since there might be more to replace) And summer break is not that far away.

I think KMD is scum with goat, and goat is empkings lover. Zazier is an NK immune SK, with personality disorder.

[Empking]

Who are everyone's two main suspects?

[TonyMontana]

orangepenguin, closely followed by ortolan.

[ortolan]

Still Sudo and Izzy

I dare anyone to quote me one attempt by Andycya to actually find scum for his whole tenure in the game, before being replaced out look a good scum should (check the statistics if you don't believe me). My scumdar is unbeatable, even when it threatens my own safety. I would be very displeased with being lynched, what has led you to join the naysayers Tony?

[TonyMontana]

I instantly suspect people who claim an impeccable scumdar. I'll give my own scumdar a C+

[ZazieR]

First of all, the questions Star hasn't answered yet during my first read:

Post 66 bothers me a lot. This is luckily questioned and Starbuck later gives some explanations:

Why do you think we should be going for Emp?

It was just a question. I'm not sure which way we should be going as I have never played with any of you before. I don't know how you play when you are scum or when you are townie, and the same for everyone else.

Ok, but why specifically did you suggest Empking? Why didn't you instead say "shouldn't we be looking at Goat? or "shouldn't we be looking at KMD?" What made you pull Empking out of the pack?

Because Emp was the other person recently being discussed.

The reason why this bothers me, is because she doesn't ask why. She saw two players being discussed, asked why not that one instead of him and that's it. Yet, for somebody who doesn't know how the players here play as scum or town (as she stated), I'd expect that she'd ask why Bear and Empking were being discussed. So Starbuck, why's that?

Yes, she responded to it, but she did not explain why she didn't ask for the reasons why Empking and Orto were being discussed.

Emp, my avatar bet has expired. I'm gonna find out pretty soon about another though. If I lost, I'll have a new avatar. If I won, Ether has one waiting for me.

Andy is scummier.

Goat, fair enough I guess.

Star, you have

one

vote. Why are you freaking out over one vote?

When I posted I had orangepenguin and Mix, and it seemed like it was added up a lot of votes with just no reason at all behind them.

I don't care if I get votes. This is Mafia, you have to expect it. I just expect a reason or an explanation. Or is that wrong in this game?

The point is that you haven't really commented on any discussion. Yet, when you get voted, you step up. Why's that?

In post 148, Star finally states finally her suspicions.
-Why didn't you respond right after the posts where you got the quotes you put up in that post from, Star?
-Why no vote on your top suspicion?
-

I'm not sure which way we should be going as I have never played with any of you before. I don't know how you play when you are scum or when you are townie, and the same for everyone else.

Why doesn't this matter anymore?

She answered the first two, so I only want to hear the answer to the third question.

You have a point. All I was doing was discussing. But seeing how quickly you jumped, you just got a bit more of my suspicions.

This to me doesn't make sense at all. Kevin disagreed, which is why he responded. She later admits that he has a point, yet it's scummy to her that he 'quickly' jumped on.
If you disagree, you try to stop it asap. So I want to hear why it's scummy according to her.

Star, regarding the powerroles.
The scum know which powers they have. If our powerroles will claim, they will know what each player has as role and can take down the stronger ones.
We'll only know what our side has. So we'll be fighting an invisble enemy.

Is this good or bad according to you, and why?

[ZazieR]

Second, questions that came later for Star:

Because I live in Italy because I'm stationed here with the Navy, and a lot of the time all I get to do is read to catch up and not add any posts of substance.

Is the Navy part the explanation, or the part that you live in Italy? Or both?

Because I'm not really sure which one I want to vote for yet, because I have two.

One has two votes, the other one. Which would be more likely to vote if you suspect both?

Anyway, yes she did ignore the question, and also this time didn't answer it as she didn't say how Kevin has been insulting or defensive.
Also, do you think it's scummy when a player claims to have all three scum caught on day 1? And why?

Last sentence of this post indicates to me that you know you haven't answered them all.
But I'll happily point those questions out when I'm done responding to other posts.

And explain why you stated that you had answered them all, while the last sentence in the linked post shows something different.

[ortolan]

I instantly suspect people who claim an impeccable scumdar. I'll give my own scumdar a C+

Do you think this is the only game in which I've given this assessment of my own abilities?

[ZazieR]

Then stop this pyramide (you both remember Open 118), and Kevin can you then tell what his meta is?

Still this

[ZazieR]

Zazie is an NK immune SK, with personality disorder.

If that was indeed true, I'd be mean towards Kevin and I'd be flirting with Bear. Neither is happening, so the above quote is obv false
Also, this is personality disorder :