Stars Aligned - GAME OVER

[DeathNote]

I got a prod for not posting so I just threw something out there, but from what I gather, Mastin usually doesn't contribute much other than being a distraction for the first and maybe second day. If you really want to focus on other information, which there really isn't any at the moment, then I suggest we vote off Mastin like he seems to want us to do.

[dramonic]

@Nhammen

Another rule I misread. I missed the:"or half the cult, whichever is smaller."

vote: DeathNote

For reasons explained above.

[dramonic]

above as in by players before me, specifically Nhammen

[Magua]

Pardon my triple post here. I'm not saying I'm 100% sure that Mastin has an insanity -- though I will say that his gambit of faking an insanity is 100% town. All I'm saying is, *if* Mastin does have an insanity, it is because he stalked. If he stalked N0, he should be lynched. Trying to divine what insanity he might've gotten from stalking is, IMO, useless.

This statement is almost all wrong. Faking insanity is not 100% town. And if he stalked, that does not mean he should be lynched. Stalking can be used for the equivalent of a 1-shot vig.

Yes, I meant 100%

anti

town, but didn't feel like making a quadruple post to fix what should've been the obvious intent. Stalking for a one-shot vig N0 seems pretty anti-town to me; claiming a faked insanity also seems completely anti-town to me.

[Drench]

Did you not pay attention? It would be vastly better to use our lynch to get information, rather then just getting rid of some noise. Also, this looks a bit like bandwagoning.

What lynch would you suggest gives us the most information?

At the moment, it's too early to determine this, but I think a policy lynch ain't going to get us much information at all.

above as in by players before me, specifically Nhammen

Do you mind putting it in your own words, rather than echoing others' opinions?

[Datadanne]

Lynch, vig-kill... one in the same as far as I'm concerned.

Vote: Drench

If you don't think he's lynch-worthy but do think he is vig-worthy, something isn't adding up. Either you want him dead or not.

What? Are you insane?!

Vote: Kise

[DeathNote]

Lynch, vig-kill... one in the same as far as I'm concerned.

Vote: Drench

If you don't think he's lynch-worthy but do think he is vig-worthy, something isn't adding up. Either you want him dead or not.

What? Are you insane?!

Vote: Kise

Why would he be considered insane? His logic is sound. You either kill or you dont kill.

[Datadanne]

Not insane in-game way.

[Datadanne]

BrAiNwAsHiNg HeRe.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rkhnGT4hM6s

[Tuberkulos]

Stalking for a one-shot vig N0 seems pretty anti-town to me; claiming a faked insanity also seems completely anti-town to me.

Agree. We have absolutely nothing to go on N0, so stalking someone to kill them N1 is pretty anti-town.

If you really want to focus on other information, which there really isn't any at the moment, then

I suggest we vote off Mastin like he seems to want us to do

.

Why do you think he would want this? Also, do you think we should lynch people based on what they want?

unvote: Mastin

vote: DeathNote

[DeathNote]

If you really want to focus on other information, which there really isn't any at the moment, then

I suggest we vote off Mastin like he seems to want us to do

.

Why do you think he would want this? Also, do you think we should lynch people based on what they want?

unvote: Mastin

vote: DeathNote

[/quote]

I don't see why not. I don't believe there is a role where you benefit from dying. I was simply joining along with everyone on voting Mastin but now I keep getting myself more and more votes.

[Tuberkulos]

You just wanted to follow the pack?

I don't like that you are justifying your vote by phrasing your reasons as you were doing some kind of "favor". This is not how mafia works. We don't do favors. We lynch people because we think they are scum. Do you think Mastin is scum?

[DeathNote]

I think he prohibits us from finding the "scum." Beside the term is bandwagoning and people do it all the time.

[Mastin]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 03#1785803

[Datadanne]

If you really want to focus on other information, which there really isn't any at the moment, then

I suggest we vote off Mastin like he seems to want us to do

.

Why do you think he would want this? Also, do you think we should lynch people based on what they want?

unvote: Mastin

vote: DeathNote

I don't see why not. I don't believe there is a role where you benefit from dying. I was simply joining along with everyone on voting Mastin but now I keep getting myself more and more votes.[/quote]

Phhhphghhhn.... Phuhuhphup....

[Datadanne]

Quotetag fail.

[JamesBond]

I belive DeathNotes play is the worst (scummiest) so far, and I dont think I would mind a lynch on him. I dont think we are in a hurry though, and since I dont wanna encourage the bandwagon, I wont vote. He is on the top of my list right now.

Mastin, this guy defenitvly have an insanity. Aint sure its an ingame one tho

@ Datadanne. Heja Sverige friskt humör!

[Nyx]

If you really want to focus on other information, which there really isn't any at the moment, then

I suggest we vote off Mastin like he seems to want us to do

.

Why do you think he would want this? Also, do you think we should lynch people based on what they want?

unvote: Mastin

vote: DeathNote

I don't see why not. I don't believe there is a role where you benefit from dying. I was simply joining along with everyone on voting Mastin but now I keep getting myself more and more votes.

Are you for real. Admitting you're just joining the bandwagon is mighty scummy bro.

@Datadanne What's up with the random posts.

[chenhsi]

They can still take an action in addition to performing the ritual, which means after night zero they kill every night as long as they can get a new fetish each night in addition to performing the ritual.

Is this mod info?

Cultists may participate in the ritual and perform another Night Action.

However, I had a thought... we all have 1-shot vigs... Texas Justice anyone?

I have never played Texas Justice before, can you explain what you mean?

DeathNote is sounding stupid and extremely scummy, but I'm not sure if that is just a newbie's behaviour.

Datadanne needs to contribute something useful, and give reasons for voting.

Awaiting responses from:
Mastin to vote someone who hasn't voted him
A few people to give their ward/noise claims

[semioldguy]

They can still take an action in addition to performing the ritual, which means after night zero they kill every night as long as they can get a new fetish each night in addition to performing the ritual.

Is this mod info?

No. It's part of the rules post.

I'd say that they are confirmed town if they come forward with it. Revealing yourself as a stalker when you are a murder is foolish, because you will die at the hands of one of the factions in this game.

Except if someone is confirmed town by coming forward as having stalked, then any murderer should do so, because that will make them "confirmed town". So obviously coming forward as having stalked does not make you confirmed town.[/quote]
Except them coming forward will make them known to us and if investigations and/or research suggests that they are likely murderers then we lynch them since murders will have different trends of investigation results than town players.

[xxFabianxx]

Prod received, just trying to deal with a hectic work schedule at the minute, I'll post something of content later and try to post at least once a day.

[nhammen]

I have never played Texas Justice before, can you explain what you mean?

In Texas Justice, all members of the town have a 1-shot vig. It has been discovered that there is a breaking strategy in Texas Justice: If a list is made with all of the players in a random order, and everyone vigs the person below them on the list on the same night, then town wins unless the scum happen to be next to each other on the list. Scum being next to each other on the list only happens about 10%-20% of the time, giving town a 80%-90% win.

The problem with using that strategy in this game is that scum can kill twice in the same amount of time that this one shot vig requires. Thus scum win if they are right next to each other in the list, or are only separated by one townie. This happens much more often.

Hmmm... now that I think about it, if we do this, the worst situation we can be in is 2 scum left and 4 town left. Much more likely, it will be 1 scum and 5 town.

[semioldguy]

I think we should nominate one person each day to Rob Grave the person we lynch so that multiple people aren't doing it and all gaining insanity and so that at least someone does it so that we know the alignment of the players we lynch.

[DeathNote]

Ok... so... I am acting scummy. Hmm....

Unvote

Vote: DeatNote

[Tuberkulos]

DeathNote, what are you trying to accomplish with a self-vote?