Newbie #840 (Game Over!)

[CooLDoG]

I still say we need to think about this more SB is right, we need more info... but seeing as there are 3 votes, might as well...

vote:

darklighta

and fyi I will not change this vote unless he can prove he an't worth a lynch.

[SpyreX]

Unvote

No. Don't push it to L-1 (or fake the attempt) when we still have two people MIA.

[CooLDoG]

well they will get proded, and he just has 3-4 votes, plus what difference would it make?

[SpyreX]

4 votes + one of the two coming in and voting = hammer = bad news at the moment.

[CooLDoG]

well you seemed to think he was scum before... have you changed your mind?

[SpyreX]

No. Not in the slightest.

However, that does not alter the fact that we need everyone contributing. Which, at this point, an L-1 with two people not even in the game doesn't help.

[CooLDoG]

Somone needs to poke them...

[CooLDoG]

well just unvote and vote him back once we hear from those 2 peeps.

[SpyreX]

Which is what I did. Because you voted

[CooLDoG]

soooo what’s the problem? Once they get prodded, and if we don't have to find a replacement, we shall then proceed to pull his neck...

@sb, what was so scumy about pointing out what they could be doing?

[SpyreX]

No. Once they are ACTIVE in the game it'll be reassessed AND he'll talk AND then there will be a lynch.

[Netopalis]

Can we get a consensus on the need for Darklight to claim once the other two players show up? I don't want him to unless the other players agree...but I think it's a fairly important move.

[Netopalis]

Oh, and by the way, Cooldog, what exactly was it that you wanted me to answer for? I'm afraid that I wasn't able to really extract your need from the weird post you made previously. Please, state it in as clear terms as you are capable of.

[CooLDoG]

Look lets stop bickering among our selves it gets us nowhere, so far we are playing more like jesters then towns men/scum... Lets focus on DarklightA, or what ever his name is. Would you honestly expect him to claim any role other then town/cop/doc? I say after we see what the new players have to say we just foget about role-claming and lynch him on the spot. If we want to pull his neck lets not give the SoB an chance. However, if you think it is necessary for you to vote agents him only after he has role clamed you will get my permission, and I think every-one else. Also to note he has yet to post in a long time, so maybe he is scum. Now after we force him to claim, and when he says town/cop/doc do we pull his neck or let him go free? All I am trying to say is does it really matter if he role clams or not?

Just to remind all of you how close to a lynch we are, spy will vote once we hear from the two that have yet to post, and then if we just get one more we have him.

If he does turn out to be a town, just out of thin air whom should we gun for? Next on net's list is me... but what about other peoples?

Lets see anything else??? No...

End of post.

[muh316]

I am sorry i didnt post yet. I thought i was gonna get a pm would notify me it started.

[Netopalis]

Cooldog, cooldog, cooldog.....

Roleclaiming gives us much information. Let's say that the person claims cop or doc rather than town - if that's the case, the real cop or doc can counterclaim. Sure, we lose the power role, but in exchange for a mafia - more than a fair trade. As for DL not having posted in a while, it's only been a number of hours, and we don't expect every single player to check this site every hour on the hour. And yes, you are most certainly next on my list. You're lucky that Darklight made such ridiculous claims today, or it would be your head on the chopping block, most likely. As for other players that we should be concerned about, I'm not convinced that we really need to dig down that far just yet - we have two excellent suspects - should we exhaust those, then I would be more than willing to state my other, far lesser suspicions. I guess I could anyway, if you folks want, but they're really rather tenuous....

[CooLDoG]

Right, no hard felling muh, I think they should send you a "game start pm"...

But look what if their an't a doc, he clams doc and we have no one to counter claim. I guess that is a risk we will have to take, but very well we only need one more person to post and then we shall start the speedy trial. Who cares about speculations, we just need to be sure we get this guy and we limit the error that we may have, but if he role clams doc my vote stays.

[Netopalis]

Cooldog, I didn't think it was possible, but you did it - you convinced me even further that you're mafia. Good job, kiddo! Your hastiness to lynch is a bit over the top. What did your partner ever do to deserve such a harsh bussing?

[CooLDoG]

I am just saying, if he turns up town he's not my fault. Now look I can keep telling you if you wanna do a role claim then get it over with, stop asking me! Make up your mind and force a role claim or don't, the next day you wanna lynch me because you know that I wil make it past the night kill. So lets look at what we have:

We wanna lynch darklight, but we wanna be sure so we are thinking about doing a role claim right? That's all. We will talk about me after day one, now we just need to think about what we have infront of our nose. Lets just make him role claim, then he says doc and we lynch him, it's that simple. Why else would he say anything but doc? Think about it before you next post. All I am trying to get into your very thick skull is that it won't matter at the end of the day, he will hang even if he is the doc.

my vote on the roleclaim issue is as folows:
if net wants to do it then let him, and keep your mouth shut.

[Netopalis]

Cooldog, we don't want to force a claim until Muh and Santos both evaluate his play and give their opinions. We also don't want to lynch without a roleclaim. If you're not willing to understand the reasonings behind these actions, then I don't know what to tell you - we've tried to explain these several times.

[CooLDoG]

I understand, then do it!

[Netopalis]

DO WHAT?!?! WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO DO, COOLDOG?!?! LYNCH!?!! FORCE A CLAIM?!?!! HAVE YOU NOT BEEN READING THESE LAST POSTS EXPLAINING ALL OF THIS STUFF?!?!?!

I'm taking a break before I say something I really shouldn't say...

[CooLDoG]

I understand why you wanna roleclaim, and just whait over night to see what the others say. Once they give their say we roleclaim then lynch, thats all from me tonight.

[muh316]

Vote: CooLDoG

I believe that is how you vote for a lynching.
I believe CooLDoG is extremely active and is convincing people to vote for another player. It seems logically clear that he seems to be the one to be the most suspicious.

[muh316]

I'm sorry if some of my info is inaccurate because i dont understand what most of you are saying.