Newbie #840 (Game Over!)

[geekalicious]

Yes, I’ll agree with Sposh that we don’t need to vote for anyone until we come to an agreement about who the scum is. If we vote before we’re decided, the scum could just come in and hammer, thus ending the game.

WHY would someone kill SpyreX?

Speculation about the night kill isn't the best way to go... It tends to lead down a dark WIFOM laden path.

I don't like muh's rationale behind the vote, and I think geek has been coasting through the game, but I definitely find CooLDoG more suspicious from a rational point of view, whereas Spyre is only suspicious because of what Neto said.

I’ll go ahead and respond to the idea that I’ve been coasting through the game. Honestly, this is one of the fastest games I’ve seen. As an example, in my previous game to this one, we spent about 19 pages arguing and went almost to the first deadline (which would have been September 30th for us) before we lynched. I definitely try to be an active poster.

[muh316]

Just the three of us remain. The thing is WHY would mafia kill spyrex if he was our main suspect. It would make sense if they killed one of us but Spyrex was unexpected. This has come to one last lynch. We lynch or We lose.

[muh316]

Can you two state why you think that you should be trusted as townies and not mafia. I want to hear what you have to say.

[Sposh]

END OF RVS VOTES:

CooLDoG (1)

-

Netopalis

Sposh (1) -

SpyreX

SpyreX (1)

- Snow_Bunny

Netopalis (1)

-

DarkLightA

DarkLightA (1)

- Sposh

Not Voting (4) - muh316, geekalicious,

Santos, CooLDoG

MID DAY ONE VOTES:

DarkLightA (3)

- Sposh,

Netopalis

,

CooLDoG

CooLDoG (2)

- geekalicious, muh316

Netopalis (1)

-

DarkLightA

Not Voting (3) -

Santos, Snow_Bunny, SpyreX

END OF DAY ONE VOTES:

DarkLightA (5)

- Sposh,

Netopalis

,

CooLDoG, SpyreX

, muh316

CooLDoG (1)

- geekalicious
Sposh (1) -

DarkLightA

Not Voting (2) -

Santos, Snow_Bunny

END OF DAY TWO VOTES:

Netopalis (4)

-

Snow_Bunny,

Sposh, muh316,

SpyreX
Snow_Bunny (1)

-

Netopalis

Not Voting (2) -

CooLDoG,

geekalicious

END OF DAY THREE VOTES:

CooLDoG (3)

- SpyreX

, muh316, Sposh

SpyreX (2)

- geekalicious,

CooLDoG

I still think muh's random hammer at the end of day one is incredibly scummy, but I also find the fact that geekalicious was sitting out on Neto's lynch odd as well.

[muh316]

Geek was never been voted for throughout this entire game. He has also been lurking a lot. He seems a bit suspicious as he has been staying on everyone's good side and not getting into serious arguements. He's playing a bit too safe. The inactivity and what I mentioned just puts the clues together. HE could be the one. He could be part of the mafia.

[geekalicious]

END OF DAY ONE VOTES:
DarkLightA (5) - Sposh, Netopalis, CooLDoG, SpyreX, muh316
CooLDoG (1) - geekalicious
Sposh (1) - DarkLightA

Not Voting (2) - Santos, Snow_Bunny



END OF DAY TWO VOTES:
Netopalis (4) - Snow_Bunny, Sposh, muh316, SpyreX
Snow_Bunny (1) - Netopalis

Not Voting (2) - CooLDoG, geekalicious



END OF DAY THREE VOTES:
CooLDoG (3) - SpyreX, muh316, Sposh
SpyreX (2) - geekalicious, CooLDoG

I still think muh's random hammer at the end of day one is incredibly scummy, but I also find the fact that geekalicious was sitting out on Neto's lynch odd as well.

I already explained why I wasn't present on Day 2. I literally woke up that morning, then came to find Netopalis to be lynched that afternoon. Literally no time for commentary.

Geek was never been voted for throughout this entire game. He has also been lurking a lot. He seems a bit suspicious as he has been staying on everyone's good side and not getting into serious arguements. He's playing a bit too safe. The inactivity and what I mentioned just puts the clues together. HE could be the one. He could be part of the mafia.

This goes back to the issue of being too town. What do you define as "playing too safe"? I've put votes out on people and stated my opinion as the game has gone on. So, are you going to go with voting for me specifically because I haven’t drawn a lot of suspicion? Or could you actually give me solid examples in the thread where I’ve been scummy?

I can’t post any more right now, but I plan to post my reads soon.

[muh316]

This goes back to the issue of being too town. What do you define as "playing too safe"? I've put votes out on people and stated my opinion as the game has gone on. So, are you going to go with voting for me specifically because I haven’t drawn a lot of suspicion? Or could you actually give me solid examples in the thread where I’ve been scummy?

I can’t post any more right now, but I plan to post my reads soon.[/quote]

You are being too pro-town. Which us leaving me to my suspicions. Most of the townies here have made many slips. You on the other hand have none.

[Sposh]

I don't follow, muh. Just because someone is pro-town to the point of not being able to be faulted, it doesn't mean that's suspicious. You never explained your hammer, did you?

[muh316]

I don't follow, muh. Just because someone is pro-town to the point of not being able to be faulted, it doesn't mean that's suspicious. You never explained your hammer, did you?

I did explain my hammer

DarkLightA wrote:
EBWODP: I really enjoy really fast games. My first one completed day 1 in 2-3 days, with 520 posts.


This is what got me a bit suspicious as if he was telling us to hurry up with the game. Like he wanted to get someone out. Then after rereading the whole topic I just felt it in my gut

DarkLightA wrote:
I'm voting for you for acting town by posting lots of short posts.


This too. It seemed like he just wanted to get in a vote for no good reason.

You know that you were also part of that lynch. After that SB said that she was going to hammer anyway. DLA did not play well.[/quote]

[geekalicious]

You are being too pro-town. Which us leaving me to my suspicions. Most of the townies here have made many slips. You on the other hand have none.

Oh, so you what, do you like the occasional scum slip out of someone to clear them as innocent, eh? Also, I note that you still haven't given any solid evidence on why you're suddenly finding me so scummy when I don't recall you expressing any suspicion before.

[muh316]

You are being too pro-town. Which us leaving me to my suspicions. Most of the townies here have made many slips. You on the other hand have none.

Oh, so you what, do you like the occasional scum slip out of someone to clear them as innocent, eh? Also, I note that you still haven't given any solid evidence on why you're suddenly finding me so scummy when I don't recall you expressing any suspicion before.

Previously I had all suspicions on other users. I had thoughts about you but the others were much more important. At some times I completely forgot who you are.You were lurking.

[geekalicious]

Previously I had all suspicions on other users. I had thoughts about you but the others were much more important. At some times I completely forgot who you are.You were lurking.

Alright, so I'm getting strong accusations of lurking from the player that didn't show up until page 7 of the game? Uh huh. Additionally, you keep evading the request: Give me specific instances of me engaging in scummy behavior. If you don't have any evidence, then you're just pushing a case along for no reason which looks very scummy to me.

[muh316]

Previously I had all suspicions on other users. I had thoughts about you but the others were much more important. At some times I completely forgot who you are.You were lurking.

Alright, so I'm getting strong accusations of lurking from the player that didn't show up until page 7 of the game? Uh huh. Additionally, you keep evading the request: Give me specific instances of me engaging in scummy behavior. If you don't have any evidence, then you're just pushing a case along for no reason which looks very scummy to me.

This is my first game and I had completely forgotten that I even signed up for mafiascum until i got a PM notification from iamusername.
I never said you were engaging in scummy behavior all I said was that you were lurking. Which MIGHT be what a scum does.

[geekalicious]

This is my first game and I had completely forgotten that I even signed up for mafiascum until i got a PM notification from iamusername.
I never said you were engaging in scummy behavior all I said was that you were lurking. Which MIGHT be what a scum does.

So, before when you said this:

You are being too pro-town. Which us leaving me to my suspicions. Most of the townies here have made many slips. You on the other hand have none.

what do mean by suspicions if you don't see aren't accusing me of undefined scummy behavior?

[geekalicious]

EBWOP: what do mean by suspicions if you aren't accusing me of undefined scummy behavior?

[muh316]

Its just a strong feeling I have in me about you. In this game you can't trust anyone. We trusted Neto and he turned out to be scum. I'm just trying to get this game somewhere. I havent voted yet so dont be worried.

[Sposh]

Muh, you still hammered him after his claim. Why. Why would you hammer the claimed power role?

[muh316]

Muh, you still hammered him after his claim. Why. Why would you hammer the claimed power role?

I hammered him BEFORE DLA did the claim that he was doc.

[geekalicious]

Its just a strong feeling I have in me about you. In this game you can't trust anyone. We trusted Neto and he turned out to be scum. I'm just trying to get this game somewhere. I havent voted yet so dont be worried.

Claiming to have suspicions about me without summoning any solid evidence is scummy.

I hammered him BEFORE DLA did the claim that he was doc.

So, you're basically admitting that you hammered before you gave him an opportunity to clarify his claim?

[muh316]

So, you're basically admitting that you hammered before you gave him an opportunity to clarify his claim?

Who would have believed his claim. Even if he would have made the claim nobody would believe him as most people thought he was playing scummy. I believe all of us agree that he was playing scummy.
Right now we have no proofs of anybody doing any scummy activity. This decision will be a hard one. Why don't all of us just put our FoS's.

FoS: Geekalicious
He just seems scummy. Its just a feeling. Sposh seems more like a town person. If sposh is town then of course it HAS to be Geek.

[geekalicious]

FoS: muh316

Since we've been in lylo, he's been throwing suspicion on me without producing any evidence when previously he never expressed any sort of suspicions. Coupled with the hammering and admission of being too lazy to read the thread earlier in the game, I just feel he's distinctly scummy.

[geekalicious]

Oh, and Sposh, most of this past page seems to be interaction between me and muh316. Could we get your opinion at the moment and FoS?

[muh316]

FoS: muh316

Since we've been in lylo, he's been throwing suspicion on me without producing any evidence when previously he never expressed any sort of suspicions. Coupled with the hammering and admission of being too lazy to read the thread earlier in the game, I just feel he's distinctly scummy.

The thing is that before most of my time went by focusing on NET, DLA and CD. They were my main suspicions. Sposh was out of my mind and so were you. Now that the two people who I LEAST expected can be one of the scum. The lazy part was referring to my personal college life not my in-game life. The hammer was explained.
You can vote for me if you wish but remeber that it might not be the best decision you make.

[Sposh]

I'm observing the interactions at this point, and I'm waiting to see how it plays out. At this point, I'd vote muh over geek, but I'm still undecided, because I think muh has played scummy enough to where geekscum could paint him as a Mafia member quite easily!

[geekalicious]

I'm observing the interactions at this point, and I'm waiting to see how it plays out. At this point, I'd vote muh over geek, but I'm still undecided, because I think muh has played scummy enough to where geekscum could paint him as a Mafia member quite easily!

Not quite sure about your logic behind this.... You admit that muh316 has played scummy, yet somehow I'm the one painting him as scummy? Didn't he paint himself scummy through his actions?

Also, laying back and trying to see what interactions come out of lylo isn't exactly pro-town, Sposh. It makes you seem like scum that's opportunistically hovering.