Newbie #840 (Game Over!)

[muh316]

I dont know how I am playing scummy. I was just stating my opinion on Geek.

[Sposh]

>.>

Want to revise that statement, muh?

[geekalicious]

I dont know how I am playing scummy. I was just stating my opinion on Geek.

Stating your opinion about me without stating evidence behind it is scummy.

[muh316]

I dont know how I am playing scummy. I was just stating my opinion on Geek.

Stating your opinion about me without stating evidence behind it is scummy.

Believe what you want to. It's called an OPINION. What you are thinking at the time. It was just a thought that came into my head that was telling me that you were scum and I thought I should share it with you. If I was by any chance mafia then I could have targeted Sposh.

[Sposh]

What? How does who you target have anything to do with you being Mafia or not!! If you targeted me OR geekalicious, we're both town, so it's good for you either way! (If you're Mafia!)

[geekalicious]

Believe what you want to. It's called an OPINION. What you are thinking at the time. It was just a thought that came into my head that was telling me that you were scum and I thought I should share it with you. If I was by any chance mafia then I could have targeted Sposh.

This is not a game of only opinion. Either you bring solid evidence against a person, or you look scummy for trying to push a case along without any substance. Additionally, targetting me does not make you any less scummy. In fact, it makes you more scummy since you can't even bring up instances of me engaging in scummy behavior.

[geekalicious]

Hm.... As the game continues to move further and further into the Day, I'm just becoming more and more convinced that muh316 is our final scum. He just keeps trying hard to displace suspicion onto me, a player he can't even summon instances of scumminess on. The SE in my last game told me that when you're in lylo, you vote whenever you really become convinced that a player must be scum. I'm almost at that point here. muh316, either give some actual evidence or cases on who you think to be scum, or I'm going to go ahead and vote for you.

[muh316]

What? How does who you target have anything to do with you being Mafia or not!! If you targeted me OR geekalicious, we're both town, so it's good for you either way! (If you're Mafia!)

I was just saying that I could have targeted you IF i was a mafia member because you seemed to have played a bit more scummier than Geek. It could have been an easy lynch for you. And how are you so sure that Geek is town. I must say that I am town. The problem is whether you believe it or not. I could soon be said to that I was the worst townie ever. Geek go ahead and vote for me. I bet sposh is waiting anytime to hammer any of us so be careful. If i vote for you then hammer comes down on you and if you vote for me then hammer comes down on me. He could be our scum geek.

[geekalicious]

I was just saying that I could have targeted you IF i was a mafia member because you seemed to have played a bit more scummier than Geek. It could have been an easy lynch for you. And how are you so sure that Geek is town. I must say that I am town. The problem is whether you believe it or not. I could soon be said to that I was the worst townie ever. Geek go ahead and vote for me. I bet sposh is waiting anytime to hammer any of us so be careful. If i vote for you then hammer comes down on you and if you vote for me then hammer comes down on me. He could be our scum geek.

Oh, so now you go from having suspicions against me without any examples to having a case against Sposh without any concrete examples mentioned against him, all while STILL not providing any evidence against me.

Vote: muh316

[muh316]

In the end you will learn who I really am!!!!!!!!

[geekalicious]

Wow. Putting up demonic faces after someone votes for you. That really makes you not look like scum. [/sarcasm]

Sposh, I've put my vote out there. What are your thoughts/ analyses at the moment?

[iamausername]

-=Vote Count #12=-

muh316 (1) - geekalicious

Not Voting (2) - muh316, Sposh

2 to lynch.

-=Sending out a slightly early prod to Sposh, since I'll be at work when the 72 hour limit actually hits=-

[Sposh]

Hmm. I think you've voted first, that's for sure!

I don't know. At this point, muh seems a lot more Mafia-ish... but he's also a newer player than you, so you COULD be using that against him. Still, I don't want to run around in circles. It is very clear to me that muh is much scummier than you, so I'm willing to do this:

(Town, I am so so so so so sorry if geek is the last scum!)

Vote: muh316

[iamausername]

-=Vote Count #13: The End of Day Four Vote Count=-

muh316 (2) - geekalicious, Sposh

Not Voting (1) - muh316

2 to lynch.

muh316, Townie - Lynched Day Four
Sposh, Townie - Killed in Endgame

geekalicious, Mafia Goon - Survives

MAFIA WIN!

[iamausername]

Full List of Roles:

geekalicious - Mafia Goon
Netopalis - Mafia Roleblocker
Snow_Bunny - Cop
DarkLightA - Doctor
Santos - Townie
CooLDoG - Townie
SpyreX - Townie
muh316 - Townie
Sposh - Townie

Night Actions:

Night 1
Snow_Bunny investigates Netopalis
Netopalis kills Santos, blocks SpyreX

Night 2
Snow_Bunny investigates SpyreX
geekalicious kills Snow_Bunny

Night 3
geekalicious kills SpyreX

The game is over now, but everyone is both welcome and encouraged to talk about what went on, what they could have done better, etc.

[geekalicious]

WHY would someone kill SpyreX?

The thing is WHY would mafia kill spyrex if he was our main suspect. It would make sense if they killed one of us but Spyrex was unexpected.

Hm, I wanted to go ahead and post commentary on why I chose SpyreX as the Night 3 kill over muh316 or Sposh. It was a difficult decision, but there were two main factors:
1. SpyreX was our IC and hence I figured his scum tuners would be much more likely to zone in on me with CooLDoG gone. He was already starting to get suspicious, and I didn't think I'd be able to survive lylo easily with him present.
2. I knew that I wouldn't really be able to sway votes toward SpyreX on Day 4 based on the following:

I don't like muh's rationale behind the vote, and I think geek has been coasting through the game, but I definitely find CooLDoG more suspicious from a rational point of view, whereas Spyre is only suspicious because of what Neto said.

This has all turned into a WIFOM, but when you come to think of it, why in the world would a mafia member try to take down his partner. It makes sense into what SpyrX is saying.

Basically, regardless of who I left alive with SpyreX, I saw that they wouldn't be likely inclined to vote for him in lylo.

A sort of contributing side factor was that I knew killing SpyreX would be very disorienting for the town since it appeared that the scum strategy was clearly to set him. Killing him basically set things off balance.

Anyway, really fun game! The speed was shocking at times. Seriously, I literally felt a cold shiver run down my body when I got done eating lunch and saw that my scum partner had been lynched without me getting a chance to hop on that wagon. I would have bussed him if I'd actually had the chance time wise to do so.

Finally, an obligatory: GO SCUM TEAM!

[Netopalis]

W00t! Thanks for a good game, guys! Any suggestions for improvement to my play?

[geekalicious]

I think calling Snow_Bunny "nobody" may have been part of what did you in, Netopalis.

[Netopalis]

lol, it was a pun! Come on, people!

[geekalicious]

Haha, yeah, but I love puns, and it took me FOREVER to figure out. Seriously, it was like 3 days later in class when I finally went "Ooooooh...."

[CooLDoG]

good game all! (should not have lynched me )

[Netopalis]

CD....Your play was scummy, even though you were town. Lynching you wasn't entirely the incorrect play....

[muh316]

The ending was there because I got bored. You know that hahahaha thing. But my god I have a really smart gut.

[SpyreX]

Net - you played a great game. I wouldn't have suspected you without the cop investigation. Double kudos for implicating me AGAIN on the way down.

I don't think the pun had anything to do with it.

---

As soon as I was NK'd, I was absolutely positive that it was geek.

Considering what I said the day before, there was only one of you that I was really suspicious of. So, me being the NK really only helped one of you - geek.

Either of the others should have left me, if they were scum, for the mislynch.

Couple that with the early no-fear lylo vote. Yea.

Especially when muh didn't even crossvote.

[Snow_Bunny]

Great game. Good gambit you tried to pull on town on D2, Neto.