Mafia 102: No-Frills Game Thread(Town wins!)

[crypto]

EC, seems REALLY scummy. His defenses suck, you would think he would be kind of upset that he is being attacked by pretty much everyone. Yet, EC tries to prove people wrong.

What? Proving people wrong is the whole point of Mafia.

At least the cop would have an idea if the scans are accurate or not.

Not after one day. Not necessarily after two or three days, either.

Are you scum trying to get an easy lynch on Cookie?

---------------------

Super Accurate* Vote Count(as of post 175):

CSL - 1(mask man)
crypto - 1(EtherealCookie)
mask man - 1(Sando)
No Lynch - 1(CSL)
hiphop - 1(charter)
SerialClergyman - 1(crypto)
EtherealCookie - 2(SerialClergyman, hiphop)
Staple - 1(le Chat)
muh316 - 1(X_~)

Not Voting:Staple, Team Aether, Kaiveran, bigmc109, Pomegranate, muh316

*Not guaranteed to be accurate.

[X_~]

the "I guess this all makes sense" + bandwagon is scumtell.

Prove it, please, i.e., link me two examples.

This is from past experiences, the scum wants to bandwagon and to not look scummy he would bandwagon and state an useless reason. Seeing that he hasn't been active after that only adds to the scummy-ness.

[crypto]

Link your past experiences.

[X_~]

EC, seems REALLY scummy. His defenses suck, you would think he would be kind of upset that he is being attacked by pretty much everyone. Yet, EC tries to prove people wrong.

What? Proving people wrong is the whole point of Mafia.

At least the cop would have an idea if the scans are accurate or not.

Not after one day. Not necessarily after two or three days, either.

Are you scum trying to get an easy lynch on Cookie?

muh316 and EC are by far the ones I suspect the most.

Wait, are you scum trying to attack everyone so that no one puts pressure on you?

FoS crypto

[crypto]

Link your past experiences

[X_~]

So if I link you to an event where a scum bandwagons with a dumb reason, and is later lynched, that will make my attacks against muh316 valid?

makes no sense really, I did not say muh16 is 100% mafia that I would need to provide proof for this. I said it's a scumtell, such as it's how a scum would think.


am I allowed to link you to a yugioh message board? xD

[crypto]

You said, "'I guess this all makes sense' + bandwagon is scumtell." I want you to support it with two (or more) examples, preferably grounded in experience. Not complicated.

You can link wherever the hell you want.

Your reason for FOSing Cookie is awful. You expect him not to try to prove his attackers wrong?

Your FOS of me is also awful (blatant OMGUS).

[X_~]

Your attacks make no sense but whatever, anything to spark activity.

If I was in EC's place I would at least have FoS'ed back or just called you guys stupid for concentration on me and not the real scum. But he hasn't. Everyone is scum until proven otherwise, EC hasn't done this.

I provided a list to let everyone know what is my stance on this game, you seem to want to discredit my thoughts. Perhaps I am right?

unvote
vote crypto

a lot can be learned from this.

[Kaiveran]

I will be V/LA from now until approximately 7:00 PM Tuesday, October 13th (GMT -6.)
Going on a college visit.

[Scigatt]

I will be V/LA from now until approximately 7:00 PM Tuesday, October 13th (GMT -6.)
Going on a college visit.

Good luck with that.

[crypto]

You still haven't linked examples.

But you have made really crappy accusations against EC, Muh, and Hiphop. So that's a plus (at least from my point of view).

Heck, even your OMGUS FOS and vote came sooner than expected. Even your reason for your Muh vote was better than this.

If I was in EC's place I would at least have FoS'ed back or just called you guys stupid for concentration on me and not the real scum.

So they deserve an FOS for being wrong or stupid? Are all stupid people scum?

[crypto]

Also, X_~, what year were you born in?

[X_~]

I ask myself, why is crypto logged in as hidden?
Crypto tries to attack everyone so that no one attacks him.

[bigmc109]

I question why anyone but mods would log in as unhidden.

I think crypto's attacks look pretty legit - I think you should address them instead of counter-BSing. The man simply will not stop til you answer him.

[X_~]

well I have nothing to hide, so why would I 'hide' myself?

[bigmc109]

So that the whole "he's online but not posting" argument goes out the window? It was a general statement. I often come to this site, stay on for awhile, and leave without ever going past the main forums page.

So, how bout those links? I think the definition of a bandwagon is "looks good, I agree VOTE".

[crypto]

I ask myself, why is crypto logged in as hidden?

In total there are

68

users online :: 22 Registered, 23 Hidden and 23 Guests

So, yeah, obviously all twenty-two hidden users are scum. Wait, no, that can't be right. BMC is also hidden. So he's scum. Same goes for all the other hidden accounts in this game.

Wait, no, that can't be right.

I've hidden my online status since the day I joined MS. This is my fifth game. I have yet to receive an anti-town role PM. Therefore . . .

Crypto tries to attack everyone so that no one attacks him.

Precisely.

The man simply will not stop til you answer him.

True story.

Actually, I'm holding off on the vote because he's new. Which is always a bewildering pain in the ass to factor in.

Waiting on the links.

[hiphop]

I know this is a bit hypocritical coming from me since this is my first post, but the rest of the issues in this thread have been debated by others and each time I log in they are already addressed, no lynching is a stupid idea and will always be imo. Does not help the town at all and information is what the town wants. Anyone who supported no lynching seems suspicious to me, its just not a smart way of going about things.

Proof that town doesn't comment on everything. This is different from me how?

@crypto- Did I say pros of the follow the cop plan? Listing the cons would ruin it. If it was the pros than it was the pros of the plan against it.

mod:please prod Team Aether

@X_~Directed at your reason for voting muh. Have you ever heard of voting someone for pressure?

If I was in EC's place I would at least have FoS'ed back or just called you guys stupid for concentration on me and not the real scum. But he hasn't. Everyone is scum until proven otherwise, EC hasn't done this.

This does not make sense. First of all you are asking him to OMGUSing Second of all nobody can be proven innocent unless the cop say so. A little pressure never hurt anyone.

[Scigatt]

mod:please prod Team Aether

Done

[X_~]

@X_~Directed at your reason for voting muh. Have you ever heard of voting someone for pressure?

..muh voted no lynch...

[crypto]

X, why are you ignoring the request for linky links?

[EtherealCookie]

Okay, finished reading the thread, the above post was based on up to page 4.

EC, seems REALLY scummy. His defenses suck, you would think he would be kind of upset that he is being attacked by pretty much everyone. Yet, EC tries to prove people wrong. FoS Etherealcookie

Also not buying the No lynch idea one bit. We gain far more information by lynching someone.
I also want to suggest the following, but it means going no lynch today.
We go no lynch
Cop scans EC
Lynch EC day 2

At least the cop would have an idea if the scans are accurate or not. The cop doesn't have to reveal himself, it's just to help him see if his scans are accurate.

Yes, if my defenses suck, I must be scum. Because, y'know, Townies can't defend themselves and be bad at it.

Oh, I'm not supposed to prove people wrong on their false accusations and their voting on me? I'm sorry, I'll sit there crying instead. Waaaaaaaaaaah, they're all voting for me.
/end sarcasm

Crypto tries to attack everyone so that no one attacks him.

That's a good point. He also randomly accuses people of being scum to throw pressure around. Both of these do not mean anything, though, in terms of being scummy. Scum is more likely to sit quiet, especially in a crowded game at Day 1.

EtherealCookie - I think people are mistaking newbieness with scumminess here. Can you post some thoughts on other players, at least your top suspects?

X_~ takes the cake for most scummy. Terrible reasoning to FoS me, and he suggests a lynching plan that kills me Day II.

We go no lynch
Cop scans EC
Lynch EC day 2

Holy shit, he's ready to sacrifice me. A bit aggressive, hm? Let me come up with a revised plan.

We go no lynch
Cop scans X_~
Lynch X_~ day II

Second on the list would be Serialclergyman. Terrible points, twists what I'm saying, and has poor reasoning skills. If I understood that the No Lynch plan would make it harder for scum, then why would I

say that

and then not support it? Oh right. I didn't say it.


Last one on the EtherealCookie bandwagon is hiphop. Don't have much to say about him. Poor reasoning skills, I don't think he reads what he types, nor pays attention to what he reads. He isn't scummy, though.

[muh316]

So X_~ you seem to be suspecting me for the reason that I agreed with others. Let me ask you this what is the point in telling others a reason if it has already been posted. It would be a waste of time. What was the whole thing about linking us to Yu-Gi-Oh message board.

[muh316]

Also staple, you stole my sig from the gamefaqs message boards.

[crypto]

EC, none of my attacks have been random.