Okay, finished reading the thread, the above post was based on up to page 4.
EC, seems REALLY scummy. His defenses suck, you would think he would be kind of upset that he is being attacked by pretty much everyone. Yet, EC tries to prove people wrong. FoS Etherealcookie
Also not buying the No lynch idea one bit. We gain far more information by lynching someone.
I also want to suggest the following, but it means going no lynch today.
We go no lynch
Cop scans EC
Lynch EC day 2
At least the cop would have an idea if the scans are accurate or not. The cop doesn't have to reveal himself, it's just to help him see if his scans are accurate.
Yes, if my defenses suck, I must be scum. Because, y'know, Townies can't defend themselves and be bad at it.
Oh, I'm not supposed to prove people wrong on their false accusations and their voting on me? I'm sorry, I'll sit there crying instead. Waaaaaaaaaaah, they're all voting for me.
/end sarcasm
Crypto tries to attack everyone so that no one attacks him.
That's a good point. He also randomly accuses people of being scum to throw pressure around. Both of these do not mean anything, though, in terms of being scummy. Scum is more likely to sit quiet, especially in a crowded game at Day 1.
EtherealCookie - I think people are mistaking newbieness with scumminess here. Can you post some thoughts on other players, at least your top suspects?
X_~ takes the cake for most scummy. Terrible reasoning to FoS me, and he suggests a lynching plan that kills me Day II.
We go no lynch
Cop scans EC
Lynch EC day 2
Holy shit, he's ready to sacrifice me. A bit aggressive, hm? Let me come up with a revised plan.
We go no lynch
Cop scans X_~
Lynch X_~ day II
Second on the list would be Serialclergyman. Terrible points, twists what I'm saying, and has poor reasoning skills. If I understood that the No Lynch plan would make it harder for scum, then why would I
say that
and then not support it? Oh right. I didn't say it.
Last one on the EtherealCookie bandwagon is hiphop. Don't have much to say about him. Poor reasoning skills, I don't think he reads what he types, nor pays attention to what he reads. He isn't scummy, though.