charter is probably town but was quick to confirm sando for no real reason, and that guy is sneaky (and quiet).
crypto is probably town, but either way we'll be almost certain to be able to tell later, so certainly not lynchworthy.
There's been some rubbish statements put forward, like 'scum are more likely to attack with good reason' and 'she seems scummy because she's tryign to defend herself properly'. Ugh. I'd hate to think what you guys assume town do - OMGUS and scratch themselves by the sound of it.
If the cop is sane, no lynch is demonstrably better. If you lynch someone, you either get dead townie or dead scum. If you investigate someone, you either get confirmed innocent townie or effectively dead scum. As i said- demonstrably better. Plus - confirmed town is how you win games. If we have 4 confirmed town to endgame, it doesn't matter if we lose every other town player wihtout hitting a single scum - that's a garunteed win.
But - as has been said, sanity issues (especially in the light of the balance of the game) makes this strategy a no-go, I think.
As for EC, my suggestion to you if you feel as you wrote at one point that I'm using bad reason and manipulating your words, is that if you don't agree with a no lynch, you shouldn't take a paragraph written about how powerful a no lynch is and quote it with the words 'I agree' underneath
.
Haven't been impressed by Pomegranite. Seems to both see No Lynch as a valid strategy (lets discuss, get to near lynch then see if we want to no lynch) then say that the no lynch idea was extremely scummy.
More CSL posts please.
unvote, vote hiphop
Seems most likely atm, but I'm prepared to lynch most people. Some highlights not mentioned by others:
When asked if happy about his vote,
At the moment yes. Will I push for his lynch no.
I would comment on your case, but crypto said some people, referring to me I believe, are quoting more than they should, and I really value the guy's opinion.
meta me if you think I am scum.
Joins me on the EC bandwagon on Oct 10th, saying somebody give this guy (me) some cake.
Gives a scum list with 4 players on Oct 11th, including me at number 1 on the list and the person he's voting (EC) down at 3.
Votes staple, not one of the 4 he listed previously, on Oct 12th.
I'm old now.