I'm not doubting Socrates is town, but I am doubting weather he should be mayor.
Unsupport: Socrates
Sorry about not answering this earlier. The reason I've been asking primarily xReckonerx about his Kyle vote is because I don't recall seeing a vocally-stated reason (or if there was one it didn't stick out to me), so I've been inquiring xReck in order to try and see what he considers Kyle scummy for.Socrates wrote:SaintKerrigan, You have twice asked Reckoner why Kyle is scummy, but you have neither asked me why nor have you presented your own perspective on his play.
If a cop is investigating people that are likely NK targets they R DOIN IT RONG.MonkeyMan576 wrote:What happens if the person I investigate ends up dead? What should I do? Lie? Decline to report it? Resign to being lynched?
I'm not doubting Socrates is town, but I am doubting weather he should be mayor.
Unsupport: Socrates
What qualities do you think a mayor should have, and what reasons did you have for unsupporting Socrates? Who is your second choice for mayor?Socrates wrote:If a cop is investigating people that are likely NK targets they R DOIN IT RONG.MonkeyMan576 wrote:What happens if the person I investigate ends up dead? What should I do? Lie? Decline to report it? Resign to being lynched?
I'm not doubting Socrates is town, but I am doubting weather he should be mayor.
Unsupport: Socrates
I think the mayor should , be likely or obvtown, be a good scumhunter, and show good logic and decisionmaking skills.kyle99 wrote:What qualities do you think a mayor should have, and what reasons did you have for unsupporting Socrates? Who is your second choice for mayor?Socrates wrote:If a cop is investigating people that are likely NK targets they R DOIN IT RONG.MonkeyMan576 wrote:What happens if the person I investigate ends up dead? What should I do? Lie? Decline to report it? Resign to being lynched?
I'm not doubting Socrates is town, but I am doubting weather he should be mayor.
Unsupport: Socrates
I already outlined my reasons for voting SC. I had two posts about it.charter wrote:Why is Hoopla voting for Serial?
Hoopla has pulled a giant 360, from initially thinking Monkeyman is more likely to claim cop as cop than scum, to disagreeing with lynching him day one, then self preservation voting him, to now arguing about how his role is useless and we should lynch him anyway.
No, not really. Roleblocker IS making his role perfectly in this case (stopping the town aligned power role), while cop not. And that's the point.SerialClergyman wrote:If you say the cop is only as good as a vanilla townie, then the roleblocker is only as good as a goon.
The argument against Hoopla is that his arguments are crap.MonkeyMan576 wrote:You can see his arguments? You guess? Do you think the Kyle argument is stronger than the hoopla argument?
Explain. I was just commenting that if when the game ends, it turns out that Hoopla is scum, then I'll be mightily pissed that I allowed myself to be convinced by this. Also, what's with the IF THEN? That looks like trying to set up a quicklynch.SerialClergyman wrote:YUK. Scummy.
IF Hoopla THEN nhammen.
No, I was saying that if there's a roleblocker, we can find this out. That's not the reason we keep him alive. We keep him alive to absorb the Mafia kill or block and to possibly get a result. He absorbs what the Mafia throw at us. THAT's why we keep him alive.charter wrote:nhammen, letting Monkeyman live to "find out if we have a roleblocker" is such a horrible idea.
Yeah, I want an answer from him about this. Oh, looks like we got one. Yeah, I think kyle is scummier.charter wrote:Hoopla has pulled a giant 360, from initially thinking Monkeyman is more likely to claim cop as cop than scum, to disagreeing with lynching him day one, then self preservation voting him, to now arguing about how his role is useless and we should lynch him anyway.
Couldn't be more irrelevent. If there's a cop that the blocker is blocking - they both cancel each other out. If there's no cop, then the blocker is free to try to disrupt any other PRs.No, not really. Roleblocker IS making his role perfectly in this case (stopping the town aligned power role), while cop not. And that's the point.
IF Hoopla flips scum, THEN you're next up for the lynch. That's how I interpreted it. There's no way Serial's setting up a quicklynch, because then Serial has to be scum, Hoopla has to be NOT scum, and the IF/THEN argument on you dissolves into pretty little butterflies. Or do you know that Hoopla will flip scum?nhammen wrote:Also, what's with the IF THEN? That looks like trying to set up a quicklynch.
No not really. Now join the Hoopla wagon please?charter wrote:Moai Interceptor Cannons: are any of you going to vote Monkey today?