Warning, TL;DR post ahead!
MeMe wrote:1) Why do you think Phoebus is mafia?
Reasons posted below. I've quoted all of his posts. It's also worth noting that he really hasn't contributed anything constructive towards finding scum.
Phoebus wrote:I'll raise a toast to MeMe and vote: mlaker
Nai has been acting more jumpy than a rabbit on crack but for now, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt. Think it's his first big game here? He seems eager to please.
That might account for his behaviour.
I'll still be keeping an eye on him though.
Joins the mlaker bandwagon, defends Nai, but still claims to keep an eye on him. Wishy-washy, wants both sides of the fence.
Phoebus, re: TradaPIB's post about watching rather than participating wrote:Hmm.
It just sounds extremely out of place when no one was talking about you, nor demanding you post or whatever.
Also, you say you'll try to be around more.
That talks to me as you being unavailable/not able to get on scum much.
That's a valid excuse if you called on posting less.
However, you come out of nowhere and claim a "waiting game" with especial emphasis with the quotes?
It just looks fishy and pre-emptive.
Setting up a scapegoat. I personally didn't see the big deal TradaPIB's comment, and found it less likely something scum would have said at the time.
Phoebus, re: TradaPIB's self-defeatist attitude wrote:Stam's attitude does not help...
he seems resigned to a fate he seems to have decided/accepted for himself.
It's so easy to get circular on this...is the frustration because he's town? or because he's scum caught?
Can we have a vote count on this page please?
Wishy-washy again, wants both sides of the fence.
Phoebus wrote:*sigh* Yes.
That's what I get for keeping multiple games open in multiple tabs.
Phoesbus??
That should really count towards your three word limit!
Tries to get another player in trouble.
Phoebus wrote:I've been dwelling on this for all of yesterday now and this is poor my play.
I dither on calling the poor play deserves to lose card but i might just do it.
It's so circular! *sigh*
And crola, I was kidding, hence the
Wishy-washy again. Stalling.
Most of his posts are without substantive comment. The ones that are have scummy content.
MeMe wrote:2) Why do you think my points claiming idea is a bad one?
I'm beginning to think that the scum may also have their own list of abilities they can buy from, separate from our list. Notice how the ability SpeedyKQ had, which was slightly tweaked to stop
most
kills didn't save him. What sort of kill would kill him? It makes sense to me to think that scum may be able to purchase an unstoppable kill. It also makes sense to me that scum would want to hide that under the guise of "just claiming points". If we do claims, I personally would prefer if MeMe claimed first, abilities, points, and everything (as I think if she's scum, this would most likely catch her, and if she's town, she's most likely exonerated through this), and go from there. I would be willing to do the same afterwards.
MeMe wrote:3) Why do you think "swaying" people to mlaker was a bad idea? He sure looked scummy to me and, apparently, to several others (including you, as you ended day one with your vote on him).
This is a good one. What's notable is the timing of it, that it happened while there was still significant pressure on Nai, whom we know to be scum. My vote was placed for two reasons: because of how he claimed and appeared to stall, and because if he wasn't scum, at the time my not voting him wouldn't stop him from being deadlined lynched and if he was scum, I'd get a point. I acknowledge that it could just as easily appear that I hopped on to get the point were I scum.
MeMe wrote:4) Why have you abandoned your "mass claim time" idea in favor of a vote with very little discussion -- before half the town has even posted this day?
Actually, half the town has posted, aside from myself, this is misrepresentation. It also appears that Yggdrasil is inclined to use mass claim as a last resort to today, MeMe believes a different method of claiming is preferable, and Phoebus appears to be trying to skirt addressing the issue alltogether. I'm still weighing the worthiness of mass-claim to out the rest of the mafia, but at this point I'm pretty convinced Phoebus is one of them.