Perfectionist Mafia - Resultas

[Santos]

Santos - Do you like the wagon on BloodCovenent? Do you think it is helping?

No, I like this:

Vote: Lowell

1) Not a random vote
2) I am picking on a quiet random voter
3) I have a gut feeling he's the quiet scum of the group

Its a little suspicious seeing Snow White go after Lowell as well. Scum partners? Its possible, but purely speculation atm. I won't forget her vote on him earlier.

[Santos]

Fvck, forgot about this game. I have two other mafias I am behind as well, since I went to Vegas and have been working non-stop after the trip, so I will catch up hopefully today (Thursday) and have a post for you all. Thank you for waiting on me.

[Santos]

I caught up in Lost mafia and began reading here. I will work on a post tomorrow, as well as, catching up in a newbie game.

[Santos]

Caught up.

Wow, Mufasa, if I could, I would daykill you for that post.

FoS: Mufasa

.

Welcome, RECKONER, it seems I don't play any game without you being in it :p

Also, I think this Snow White wagon is bullshit. There is nothing substantial upon it except bandwagon votes with crap reasons.

I'm going to reread BloodCovenent and Lowell. They are particularly scummy, imo.

[Santos]

Please do so. Very interested which one of the two posts that Lowell has is tipping you.

LOL, well, that solves that issue because when i played a game before with him it was much of the same thing we see here. I guess there is nothing to go on except my own personal bias towards his contributions in other games. Was he replaced?

Lowell has until Tues before I search for his replacement

gotcha.

You say the Snow White bandwagon is crap, yet you never say anything in regard to saberwolf. Trying to avoid interacting with other players maybe?

Not at all. But if you have no reason to vote Snow White, why should I?

Santos - Scum - Haven't been impressed by any of his posts.

You're impressionable? lol Would you like a cookie?

pretty sure it was santos who said that and not sanjay

I fosed mufasa.

Saying you need to do a Lowell reread seems a little strange to me, given that it is only two posts and nineteen words. I feel like you may be trying to inflate your pro-town contributions by calling it that.

What goes in to a Lowell reread?

Nothing. I was wrong when looking into others for their lack of contribution.

Sanjay: I have played one other game with Mufasa. He was town in that game and he's playing just like he was in that game. Posts votes haphazardly and doesn't care how scummy his posts look. Refusal to elaborate was also one of his things. So to see him doing it again bugs me, but He turned out town the last time he did that, so it was basically a choice of meta.

zwet, much?

I will always advocate a zwet lynch which is why I won't join another game with him, and that's not because of our inability to know whether he is scum or not, but how he makes the feeblest attempts to hunt scum regardless of his alignment [/rant]

I did the quick math.

Averages of emoticons/posts per alignment for Snow white.

Town : 0.51 e/p (ignoring outliers, it's 0.35 e/p)
Scum : 0.89 e/p
Third party : 1 e/p

In this game,
Before I noted her of her emoticon use : 1.80 e/p
After I noted it : 0.36 e/p

Am I going somewhere with this? I don't know. I should have counted words in each topic as well but that's a bridge (or five) too far. But judging from the data above, there's something off. To switch from an excessive use of emoticons to 1/6th of that after someone noted it and saying you're expressive doesn't add up to her emometa.


I'll sleep on it.
And yes, I was this bored.

Can this be mafia wiki'd, please?

I don't know... it did seem rather opportunistic. Did he ever clarify his reasons for suspecting BC? If he did, I don't recall. I know why I would have voted BC (though there are a few others I'd rather vote for now), but I don't want to speak for everyone.

Oh yeah, I need to read that fool in ISO...tbc'd.

Lowell. With a fourth vote on BloodCovenent i thought this was opportunistic.

Ah, there is the refresher why I wanted to look back at him. I saw this as a total bus/distancing.

Wow, reading Snow White's massive post just caught me back up with the game again. I hadn't realized how much I forgot about this game, it feels like DeJa Vu lol

Meh, I'll do BloodCovenent later. Football is on. I've been on mafia scum all damn day it seems.

[Santos]

Shit, I'm fine with either BloodCovenent or Mufasa at this point.

Vote: Mufasa

because my FoS won't suffice.

[Santos]

I am comfortable with my vote.

[Santos]

Starbuck wants to see some heads roll.

[Santos]

I thought I made it clear about my thoughts on Lowell, BloodCovenent, Mufasa and Snow White.

Are you confused?

[Santos]

Two cops!!?!?!?!?!?!1111!111!! *does the no pants dance*

[Santos]

BloodCovenent, while saving yourself from catching up with that claim, who do you want to lynch today BESIDES Snow White or Mufasa?

[Santos]

Well, if we lynch BC today and he turns out to be the cop then Snow White was lying...and vice versa. What terrifies me is that they're possibly both cops until a flip.

[Santos]

I will vote for BC because I agree Snow White's seems more legit. If BC wanted to be a true mafia player, then he would tear Snow White up in an unprecedented defense where we will all look in awe that we'll have to change votes to SW and save BC.

*crickets*

[Santos]

Unvote

Vote: BloodCovenent

Bet ya I can get lynched faster than you :p

[Santos]

wicked, it was directed at the person before I posted I assume if I didn't provide a quote beforehand.

Also, the

mod

is getting pwned in vote counts lol.

[Santos]

Hurry, unvote and vote 15 times, every player!

[Santos]

RECKONER, can we stop joining games where our mods disappear

and then blame alcohol as the reason for their absence?

[Santos]

Did anyone PM the mod?

[Santos]

I remember our mod saying this regarding this game

After being placed on hold for a month I have reopened the game. If you are in, do nothing, if you are out please message me. I expect the game will be up later this week

And then we started playing. I'm not sure why it was delayed in the first place. Maybe that reason is why he's gone now...[/end speculation]

[Santos]

Vote: Mufasa

[Santos]

I need to be replaced? wtf

[Santos]

oooooo, nice catch, RECKONER. That was a good 'zinger'!

[Santos]

I am three pacificos deep my friend. shuddup and take it.

[Santos]

get to the outerbanks, the lot of you!

[Santos]

No, I just did my state report on NC and visited the lighthouses...I have family in Highpoint as well. so that is the creepy relevance of my demand.

[Santos]

I will post during football games tomorrow. I don't want to post anything right now that's game relevant until I am at home on my PC.

[Santos]

Am I still voting Mufasa?

Unvote

.

I want to hear what FaerieLord has to say.

[Santos]

I may be an ignorant, blind bastard, but did Snow White produce an investigation result on anyone?

@Fraeirie, I was waiting for you to answer the question posed to you which you sort of answered. But that would require Sposh to answer post 807 of course.

[Santos]

What if I claimed that? lol

[Santos]

Crap, I cannot unvote; I forgot about that.

[Santos]

I'm still questioning Snow White's cop claim. Whoever posted that smiley to post ratio about her has just been nagging me. The fact that we already had a cop flip, I really want to call bs on her cop claim, but I really don't want to make another mistake lynching a cop...

but a cop that doesn't produce investigations; I'm skeptical.

RECKONER, given what you knew from my play as cop in Lost mafia, what are your feelings towards Snow White's claim here? I had one successful investigation, then I was roleblocked the rest of the game and ended up getting lynched for not being believed.

Snow White claims cop, someone else counter-claims, and she produces no results.

Why is she not today's lynch?

[Santos]

Unvote

Vote: Snow White

I didn't see it much yesterday, but a cop claim and a loss of a cop is screaming at me to go with what is simple: Lynch the person who was counter-claimed.

[Santos]

..except the person who counter-claimed was scum?

Right. But as a cop, why would someone not bother with their ability or die during the night?

[Santos]

Snow White, can you claim again, please? Preferably with flavor and your exact ability name?

[Santos]

This is pointless. All the PMs are on the first page. If you want to know what she would reply to this, read that.

You're an idiot. My ulterior motive was to get an exact claim from here, dumbass. Way to ruin it.

[Santos]

Apologies for my hasty reply, but since she was so abashed with emoticons I was hoping she would slip up if she was scum-Snow White.

Either way, we don't know the validity of her role unless she says 'I am _______' besides just saying I'm a cop. I'm resting my hopes on a gambit that she is not a cop, but possibly one of the backup roles described.

If that is the case, then i won't push it any further. I was disappointed that an investigation attempt wasn't even tried, so naturally, I was pissed.

[Santos]

Makes no sense looking at her explanation a second time.

Snow White, have you played town cop before, and if so, link please?

[Santos]

Unvote

Vote: manho

What are your thoughts on who is the best lynch today?

[Santos]

That was great how Snow White didn't show up at all yesterday...NOT

Vote: Snow White

Whoever posted her smiley emoticon analysis on her earlier...genius because I believe it is indicative of her alignment = anti-town.

Also,

mod, I believe manho needs to be present, along with that of Snow White?

And yes, Snow White, L-1.

[Santos]

Vote: manho

Need moar manho.

[Santos]

I am not in a masonry.

FoS: zwet

, for his predecessor's lies.

FoS: FaerieLord

for being at the end of every lynch; its not scummy, but I see it as suspicious and a very good point that manho brought up. However, FaerieLord, do you think manho is scum? If so, what examples do you have? If not, then do you think manho's lists of common voters are legitimate enough of reasons to think people are mafia for being on so many wagons?

[Santos]

I don't get it.

[Santos]

No matter, FaerieLord, who do you think is scum?

[Santos]

[-_-]

[Santos]

Vote: FaerieLord

[Santos]

Left over turkey is so good.

[Santos]

I need content from replacements.

[Santos]

yaaay, I'm not the only one who thought there was really no information to be found since last time. btw, the math that FL did made a lot of sense. I think I might vote Santos just because he hammered me when I had obv. claimed doc (which I was). =p

lolwut?

[Santos]

Ah, okay. I thought that but was morbidly confused thinking you were confusing the games.

[Santos]

Santos:

1) You said here that you were worried that both Snow White and BC might be cops, but then two posts later you say that you are down to vote BC. What happened here?

2) What was your rationale for voting Mufasa here?

3) What the heck happened here? I'm inclined to believe that scum wouldn't forget their own godfather was lynched and not a cop, but the tiniest part of me thinks that the mistake was too ridiculous to be believed.

4) What's up with your zwet FoS today? Isn't that role confirmed town?

1) Well, we all know ts a heavily themed game and the possibility of many power roles made me think we had certainly outed a power role (Snow White) too soon. But when BloodCovenent claimed cop as well, I reassessed my initial reason in post 511 because if BloodCovenent was really a cop counter claiming, it was a horrible counter claim.
2) I voted him because I thought the game needed to move along, as well as, get Mufasa participating more.
3) I was having trouble believing Snow White's claim.
4) My finger is in zwet? WAHT?

I felt that when BC counterclaimed, his claim was more remnant of the one on the first page. Also, CCing as scum on day 1 is not wise, so I expected the scum to be SW.

Weird, I thought the opposite except BloodCovenent could have made a better counter claim which probably would have sent Snow White to the gallows Day 1. So the BC counter-claim was pretty smart, imo because he could have potentially lasted a few more days with fake cop investigations...but I digress.

manho, zwet replaces, finds one reason to vote you and you have nothing to say? Are you just ignoring him?

[Santos]

Well, so far, I see manho is scum for ignoring zwet :p

[Santos]

^Sounds good to me.

*blatant hop on bandwagon*

Unvote

Vote: manho

[Santos]

No, that's typical of zwet.

[Santos]

Unvote

I was voting to incite moar posts from manho. Does that answer your assumed question of why I voted manho, Sanjay?

I'm agreeing with the how suspicious dramonic is playing, but his play in Out in the Wilde has me a little skeptical of dramonic-scum.

No matter, I have another target:

Vote: EtherealCookie

Gut.

[Santos]

FL, did you miss my question about why you decided to use Santos as a placeholder vote?

...he gave a reason why he changed his vote to me. But if you're looking for something else...

And once again, terrible reasoning. "Gut." Yes, gut instincts are so reliable. Let me know when someone actually has a reason to vote for someone, that goes further than "scum."

Well,

Unvote

because I have a better reason than a gut feeling:

Vote: zwet

because I've never seen him relinquish a vote like that before. Its erratic play on his part and is entirely a plausible reason to vote for him.

[Santos]

FraerieLord wagon for the win?

[Santos]

Unvote

Vote: FraerieLord

, ftw

[Santos]

Whatever it is, its better than how slow this game got. But now we're on votecrack!

[Santos]

Cookie, why did you target me the other day?