MacavityLock, Post 717 wrote:Also, Confucius, are you interested in making a case on Buttonmen?
I have already made my reasons for voting him rather clear.
Confucius, Post 577 wrote:When deciding whether to vote a claimed Cop, the question is: Would you follow them if they claimed a guilty result? Even before reading my role, my answer was “no.” Everything about TheButtonMen's claim – and even his N1 result – is convenient. That said, I would like to give him another night just in case I change my mind overnight.
Confucius, Post 622 wrote:On the subject of TheButtonMen, I would like to refer to my original stance. Please contemplate:
If TheButtonMen were to say tomorrow that he had a guilty result on somebody, would you follow him?
My answer is still "no." If TheButtonMen is Town, the only thing he is doing for us is soaking up a role-blocking. If TheButtonMen is scum, then I would rather him lynched now.
His play makes me believe that he is scum who has been getting by on a convenient claim, while hoping to draw out our real investigative role(s) on his way down. Now that he doesn't think he will be lynched today, he is more content to make cases against people. I would not be surprised to learn that he was directed to play more forcefully overnight by scumpartners, if he has any.
Confucius, Post 626 wrote:I am an investigative role, but I am not a Cop.
ConfuciDOS, Post 674 wrote:I have to say I do not like the feel of this counterwagon. It feels like I am watching the last-minute Heilograph lynch a second time.
Summary
:
1.)
I am an investigative role.
2.)
He avoided being lynched Day One solely for claiming Cop. His claim was made at a convenient time, and was itself a convenient claim.
3.)
The counterwagon on him Day One was last minute, and on Town.
4.)
His play changes from Day One to Day Two. My guess is this is the result of having a conversation with scum-partners.
5.)
The counterwagon on him Day Two was last minute, and on Town.
Additional factors
:
6.)
He still has not clarified his restriction despite being asked to do so multiple times.
7.)
He attacked me without actually voting me yesterday after I claimed.
8.)
There is now a smaller chance of there being a Serial Killer, which would make two separate investigative roles less appropriate.
Holistically, it is difficult to imagine a case for him being Town. Still, (and this is obvious) he should claim his result before we lynch him.