Newbie 939 - Game Over

[Pmac]

/confirm

[Pmac]

Vote:gandalf5166

- because he says that he's Gandalf, but by the avatar he looks like a orc, or something. Very suspect.

I've played other game on this site, and two theme based games on an anime site. So, 4th game overall.

[Pmac]

True, but i think that two votes on random mode its not something to worry about.
But, yeah, if he gets more votes on random mode i'll take mine.


PS: My spacebar is a little screwd up, so if you see some words attached to each other, please bear with it.

[Pmac]

Gandalf, that is called scumhunting, and it has to start sooner or later, we cant only be randomvoting till the end of the day, and you are making everyone suspicious of you because you are making such a bid deal out of it.
I already had a vote on you, and just because of your latest actions i think im going to keep it till there's enough reason for me to unvote.

[Pmac]

No, its just because you're reacting really stupidly to this... Get used to it, every single one of us will be accused of being mafia till the end of the game. I also check this every 5 minutes, and yeah, it caused a big discussion on my last game.

[Pmac]

I think good mafia can also be someone who talks a lot, but knows what to say.
I dont think activity is an indicator of scum.

[Pmac]

Did you mean:
Unless everyone else is just in a different time zone?

Anyway, we are from a lot of different places, so, its not hard to have people from different time zones.
Were are you from?

[Pmac]

LOL
Then, even we have different time zones. I'm from Portugal.
All hail Europe!

[Pmac]

XD. Yeah, its almost 8 pm. Im 17, i cant really go here when im in the school.

[Pmac]

Lucky...

Anyway, this is not msn...
Im waiting to know why did Pulindar vote on me. But if its because of what FC said then, i already had a vote on Gandalf (the random one) and if he is a suspect then i dont see why do i need to unvote right now to not vote on anyone.

[Pmac]

Questions
1.) Who do you find Scummy?
Actually, i dont think anyone as shown really scummy actions till now.

2.) Your vote is still on Gandalf, yet you said his mistakes seemed more newb than scum, why is it still there?
Because i dont have anyone to vote, it is my random vote, if people start to vote a lot on Gandalf or if someone starts to look scummy for me

3.) Do you believe that posting often makes others feel something is scummy?
No, like i said earlier, the number of posts as nothing to do with it, and i have this opinion because in the first game the mafias where the second most active and the less active of the players.

4.) Do you think it annoys people to have many posts of others to read?
I dont know about other people, but it doesn't annoy me

5.) What about long posts like this one?
No prob, shows that they are working, but sometimes i lose some information in the middle.

6.) Do you have any questions to ask people?
We are in the begging of the game and i haven't seen anything suspect to point or ask

7.) Do you think you have provided real content, how so?
Honestly, no. And for the reasons of 6

8.) Do you have anyone you think is town (not asking whom)
For what i have seen, i have one, but im not sure.



Good post Pulindar, some good analysis all in the begging of the game. I still haven't read everything, so im going to finish that now.

[Pmac]

Last game i was doc, i was put in a situation where i had to claim on Day 1, i was NK in night 4 or 5. And i was the real doc, but one of the mafia claimed cop,also on Day 1, so, maybe it had something to do with that.

[Pmac]

what is prodded?

[Pmac]

Thanks for the wiki, im going to had my first game (the 3rd longest newbie game of the forum).

Anyway, i re-read all the game and all the questions i have i think they have been questioned.
What i the reason behind Actingup's vote, and also a question made by the same that Pulindar never answered, the guy that put the last vote on the quick lynch was mafia or town?

Also, Kingdavid isn't posting that often for a IC, i suggest you'd be more active. The same for D'man

[Pmac]

stupid small edit:
Its not the longest newbie game, its the biggest XD

[Pmac]

Oh, sorry. I forgot

[Pmac]

I got myself in another mafia game, so i may post less. But, with the activity of this game that probably wont happen. Just to let you know though.

Anyway,

Unvote

, i dont think i need to keep my random vote in this stage of the day.

And Gandalf, what you're saying now that mafias do ins't what you wanted just a couple of posts earlier?

To be honest, this day needs to end. We've gotten about all the evidence we're gonna get today. Tomorrow, we'll have more to talk about. The cop(if he's in this game) will have some info, and we can discuss the NK.

[Pmac]

In my last game there was 7 replacements if i count them right...

[Pmac]

Jelly:
Every vote has a consequence.
Why are you voting for FC?

[Pmac]

Oh, and Happy Birthday KingDavid!

[Pmac]

Sorry, i couldn't post yesterday.
It seems that the game advanced a little bit since the last time i was here.
I just made a quick read of that. So...
First:
The two new members of the game Jelly and Razor are really interesting, especially Razor, and that's what i like in a game... Both of them seem to be really scummy, most Jelly, but this new Razor's posts was really weird, knowing that this is Gandalf's first game.
Secondly:
@FC
It's not easy to answer your question (What can i do to had more information to the game). But ill try to make ISO's on everyone in the near future, make some questions, stuff like that.
Third:
IT'S MY PERSONAL PARANOID THEORY TIME!!
Ok, it's the first time im going to do this in this game, and im going to do this from time to time, but don't think that it's going to be frequently. (Last game i've done it only once)
Basically, i think about the game a lot, and sometimes i come up with some theories that i don't have proof and that probably aren't going to be true. But it can add some discussion to the game, and so i post it.
This time theory is:
Jelly and Gandalf, The Scum Buddies
Ok, we have all noticed that Jelly was defending Gandalf, but Gandalf started attacking him (he's a good friend XD), so, why?
I was going to post a quote here but i can't find the post...But, anyway, im preety sure that someone posted a post saying that when they were mafia they wouldn't mind getting they're scum buddy killed, if they were making any trouble for them. (If im wrong please tell me, since im playing two mafia games sometimes i can mix both games...). And even if that post was from the other game, think about it, Gandalf can try to take out any connections with Jelly if he is caught.
Again, i called this paranoid theories for a reason...
Fourth:
Im going to wait for Razor to explain that last post of him, if he can't ill probably vote for him. But if he can i'll probably will vote on Jelly.

[Pmac]

For obvious reasons....

Vote:Razorback

[Pmac]

actually you did just what i wanted gandalf so thank you for walking blindly into trap. you see i'm not acting scummy just trying to get you to show your scum tells.

you see i'm for anyone with a bad temper or is over defensive towards others. your a newbie you wouldn't know this razorback. hell none of them do.

Razor...You're right, we don't know you, but tell me...
How can a person that defends himself when someone attacks him is suspicious, but a person who tell lies to try to trick us isn't?
And please respond in english, not in gibberish.

To everyone else:
Gandalf may have a bunch of newbie behaviors, but Razor is a liar and confusing, even if he's not mafia, he will be a problem in the future, so i suggest for us to take this day chance on him.

[Pmac]

@Lager-
Yes, we still have time, we don't need to rush to the lynch, but i don't think it will be good to have Razor in the game for many days, so he has my vote. And, yes, i think he is mafia.
Regarding my theory, no, being friends in RL would be too much of a coincidence, i was just saying that they could be scumbuddies

[Pmac]

v.t. you need to open your eyes and see what i'm trying to tell the town not to do for there own good. if you people

KILL ME

you give the a fee kill how many time do have to say.

i think the reason you want me gone gandalf is i may be right you are indeed scum. and now that i figured it out you have to kill to make sure i can't prove it later.

Ok, and prove that you're town?
I can say im town, that doens't automaticly proves i am, right?

[Pmac]

A little bit off-topic here, but...if it means Lynch or lose, shouldn't it be Lyol not Lylo? Because that's "Lynch lose or".

[Pmac]

well, im here...
Anyway, it seems this week isn't going to advance too much...

[Pmac]

Sorry i had biology exam today, so i was studying.
Anyway, im here now!

[Pmac]

Yes, it is.

Hi, sucrose, you remind me of my biology test...
Im wainting for your analisis, maybe its a way to get this game moving on!

[Pmac]

im here, i just dont have much to say, and this is the exams month

[Pmac]

You mean this: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12495

Anyway, the other game im in i must have done like 5 posts and we are on day 2...

About the isos... Working on it...

[Pmac]

And about the typo on post 10...
English is not my main language, so i still give some errors. Im not the best of my English class either...

[Pmac]

My ISOs...
Im not going to do a post by post analysis, im just going to say what i think of each of them...

Gandalf:
Causes a lot of controversy in the beginning, first he follows the IC, and then he starts OMGUS, that last part is highly suspicious.
But during the rest of the game he doesn't do much more that is considered suspicious, so he most probably is a newb town.
He gets really angry with Razor but, even though Razor ended up being town, i don't think that that is a scumtell because Razor was lying and stuff.
I didn't think his reasons to vote Sucrose were really that valid, sure, Sucrose talked more about Jelly, but that's because Jelly is the most suspect now that Razor is gone.

Jelly:
Jelly likes to vote and FOS a lot, i didn't like his response to my question on post 8:

Jelly:
Every vote has a consequence.
Why are you voting for FC?

If hes a mafia then there won't be a problem. I'l explain when I get home.

His question on post 14 is REAAAAALLY suspicious:
"Are mafia allowed to talk outside of the game?"

He plays at the defensive a lot, and OMGUS too, although he tries to give reasons.




Ok...thats it for now, tomorrow ill post another two.
By the way, i did this two first because they are the ones i think are more suspicious.

[Pmac]

Sorry, my internet connection failed, and we had to wait a couple of days till it returned.

First, welcome Locke!

Im going to do an ISO on IKD, since hes been replaced.
And about not giving new information, truth is, i suck at finding things like that, especially when everything has been said. I like this game, its intresting, but i'm really bad at playing this, and maybe thats why i play it.
About the post, hell, that game was almost a year ago, i dont remember, so i have go check everything again...Then i'll say something...

To be honest, i didn't find anything suspiscious at all on David, he seemed completely town to me...Just a bit inactive wich eventually let to his replacement. Locke also doen't seem scummy, but since he's only in the game for a day or two, i ate to admit it, but even his reasons to vote me make sense.

On Pulindar: He seems more suspicious than the last, right in the beggining he seems worried because Gandalf is on L-3, but he isn't worried to vote for him and put him on L-2, weird.
There's a post that i find funny, nº5 since he says that he completely agrees with me, but then he votes me.
On the other hand he did the ISOs on everyone, that it was the most pro-town action on the game, in my opinion.
And then, the most suspicious post this far, the blank post.
After reading it, he is scummy, but most because of his last post, since on the rest of his posts he seems one of the most pro-town persons in the game.
On Sucrose, his replacement: She seems town too. But, and like Locke, too soon to actually be sure.

[Pmac]

oh, and i forgot

Vote:Jelly Jiggler

Reasons stated on my Iso on him!

[Pmac]

Im going to be on V/LA till tuesday due to exams...
And i will probably will go for a longer time next month.

To Ycz6: Wellcome and no, im not that guy, i suck at playing Super Smash Bros.

[Pmac]

Hi, im finally back.
And i don't understand why the prod. Since i was on V/L yesterday i wouldnt be able to post on the day, and i wouldnt be able to post at midnight.
Anyway, to the question about who i think is suspicious.
The awnser is Gandalf, hes been suspicious since basically is first post.

[Pmac]

I think i already did an Iso on you, but...
Your first posts, and im not talking about the vote on Actingup, but instead of your OMGUS votes.
During the rest of the, well i can't explain it, since its more of a gut feeling, but i think you're suspicious.
And...well, thats preety much it, seriously, compared to Jelly, i think you're probably Newb townie, but of all other members i think of you as the most probable of being scum.

Oh, and i forgot to mention, i also suspect of pulindar because of his blank post, but since i didn't saw anything suspicious in Sucrose i can't really say if he is or not scum...

[Pmac]

About Pulindar's blank post:

The suspicious fact it's just that if he coulnd't have the time to post why did he even bothered to post a blank post?
One hipotesis is that he is mafia, and that he made that to stay in game while not playing and don't cal much of attention to him...



Anyway, im going to ask to get replaced, and i know this can be suspicious too, but whatever, you're right, this is just another game that i suck at...
And this is a time where i can't really bother to read the game word by word, letter by letter, since it's my final year at secondary school (i don't what you call it, but whatever...) and the final exams are coming, and when that happens i will not have time to play at all.

[Pmac]

But before i leave...
Any last questions you have to me?
Maybe i can still prove myself town, i don't want for my replacement to get linched right away just because of me...