Mini 957 - Everyone's a Hero Mafia - Game Over

[rewq455]

SOG + Bunny scumteam? I dont know. Or is it Bunny or SOG? Ffffff

Thor, this is where you show your true colors. REWQ EASY WITH THE TRIGGER FINGER THERE

I dont understand. If soak costs 1 point and plague costs 10, shouldn't you have like 8+ or something?

I started off w/ 2 points. I used soak twice.

So scumpairs are;

Timeater/rewq
Snow Bunny/SOG
SB/Timeater

I think i need to consider this a bit, but we are near a lynch now.

rewq - any thoughts?

I am thinking that Timeater is scum, because he has not been hammered yet. If there were 2 heroes, and one of them was not him, one would have hammered already because we would need another day to lynch the hammerer, and then more time to find the last hero. However, if Timeater is a hero, the other one will not hammer because we would lynch him the next day, causing a villain victory.

[rewq455]

I dont understand. If soak costs 1 point and plague costs 10, shouldn't you have like 8+ or something?

Also, plague does not cost 10. I just need to have at least 10 points to use it. It apparently has no cost

[Thor665]

I am assuming a Bunny + SOG scumteam, I think its prudent SOG be lynched over Bunny. If they are together and we go Bunny over SOG and she has some ability that saves her, ouchietime.

I can't believe Snow_Bunny, if scum, has the ability she said *and* yet another partner.

So if SB is scum SB is alone *or* is lying about her powers (or I hate the mod ).

So lying SB plus SOG is a possibility, and so is lying SB plus Timeater.

Timeater could be scum with rewq.
SOG cannot be scum with rewq.

Consequently either Timeater or SB are indeed the most likely scum which does make me start to like SOG's thoughts in this regard.

I think I might have to dwell on this a little but I think the smart play is to lynch either SB or Timeater at this point. I'd love to hear thoughts.

[rewq455]

Should I hammer Timeater?

[Timeater]

Single scum scenario - why cant it be Snow Bunny?

[Thor665]

I am thinking that Timeater is scum, because he has not been hammered yet. If there were 2 heroes, and one of them was not him, one would have hammered already because we would need another day to lynch the hammerer, and then more time to find the last hero. However, if Timeater is a hero, the other one will not hammer because we would lynch him the next day, causing a villain victory.

People who hammer do not equate to absolute next lynch.

But you are correct that a lack of hammer on Timeater does indeed make him look like a more likely hero (unless the scum are SB and SOG)

What do you think is more likely? SB/SOG as scum trying to entrap Timeater, or SB/Timeater as scum with SB trying to distance from her partner (perhaps hinted at by Timeater's quick shift from voting SB to voting SOG)

[Timeater]

Should I hammer Timeater?

MEGA NO. I AM NOT SCUM I AM NOT SCUM. LET THOR COME TO THE DECISION PLEASE

POSTING IN A SEC

[Thor665]

Single scum scenario - why cant it be Snow Bunny?

It could be only one scum left and have it be Snow_Bunny. The big danger there is, if this is true and her power claim is true, that equates to a town lose if we don't start trying to lynch her now.

On that note;

Vote: Snow_Bunny

I think she has to be part of the scum team if there is a scum team, and if she's telling the truth about her powers and is scum she would be the lone scum and should be targetted immediately as it's the only way we'd have a chance of killing her in time (also, she and Justice Joe are both of the made up names revealed thus far, which seems an odd coincidence but one I'm willing to note as worthwhile for picking her as well)

[Thor665]

MEGA NO. I AM NOT SCUM I AM NOT SCUM. LET THOR COME TO THE DECISION PLEASE

If you are scum then you win my Oscar of awesome.

[Timeater]

UNVOTE
VOTE: SNOWBUNNY

SNOW BUNNY IT IS

[iLord]

Vote Count the Fourth

Timeater (2): Snow_Bunny, semioldguy
Snow_Bunny (2): Thor665, Timeater
Not Voting (2):, Snow_Bunny_Is_Awesome, rewq455,

With six alive, it's three to lynch.

Deadline at June 14th 8:00 PM EST.

[rewq455]

I am thinking that Timeater is scum, because he has not been hammered yet. If there were 2 heroes, and one of them was not him, one would have hammered already because we would need another day to lynch the hammerer, and then more time to find the last hero. However, if Timeater is a hero, the other one will not hammer because we would lynch him the next day, causing a villain victory.

People who hammer do not equate to absolute next lynch.

But you are correct that a lack of hammer on Timeater does indeed make him look like a more likely hero (unless the scum are SB and SOG)

What do you think is more likely? SB/SOG as scum trying to entrap Timeater, or SB/Timeater as scum with SB trying to distance from her partner (perhaps hinted at by Timeater's quick shift from voting SB to voting SOG)

I am thinking it is more likely for SB and Timeater to be scum, because if it were SB and SOG I think SB would have hammered by now, because she is already under a lot of suspicion, to guarantee another villain death.

[Timeater]

Consequently either Timeater or SB are indeed the most likely scum which does make me start to like SOG's thoughts in this regard.

Its not me. Its the lurker.

I was making a post when I saw Thor's new post. Your logic about Bunny is sound. Combine that with the already dubiousness of her claim (the overpoweredness of it, the fact that it isn't on the wikia, the fact that the action of having a double is a little scummy in the first place)

BRB I need to take a valium or something.

[semioldguy]

If Snow Bunny is scum alone I can always use my ability.

rewq455 posting and not hammering Snow_Bunny would ensure his innocence.

I have to give a coworker a ride to the airport real quick, be back in about an hour.

[semioldguy]

rewq455 is henceforth innocnent to all. Can't be scum.

@rewq455
Snow_Bunny can't hammer Timeater since her vote is already on Timeater.

[rewq455]

Yeah... I messed up my last post. Didn't realize that SOG and SB were already voting Timeater....

Will rethink the question and post in a minute.

[Timeater]

Also I'd like to note that iLord said no, I cannot use my power on dead people.

[rewq455]

I am not sure if SOG is scum, but I agree the SB is probably scum and needs to be lynched.

[Timeater]

You're the last vote, rewq.

We await your decision.

[rewq455]

Vote Snow_Bunny

[Thor665]

Yeah, I still think it's either SB/SOG, SB/Timeater or maybe SB alone.

I've had town reads on Timeater pretty much the whole game so I'm thinking SB/SOG or SB alone - and that may very well depend on whether or not we are able to lynch her.

[Snow_Bunny]

Bah, another game lost as town.

Way to go, town. You really, really disappoint me.

Timeater is scum, I can bet on that.

Ugh, there are no words that can describe this fail.

WAY TO FAIL TOWN. Why is it that I can never be on the side of good town players?

ARRRGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Snow_Bunny]

You really think I would fakeclaim such a convoluted role? Unlynchable unkillable? Really? What scum is that stupid?

Pfft, I'm filled with shame from your fail. FAIL FAIL FAIL!

[Snow_Bunny]

Timeater + rewq. I'm leaning towards that if there's more than one scum left. Or who knows, in this last page I felt a good buddying between Thor and Timeater. Well, one way or another, unless something miraculous happens tonight, I think we lost.

WELL PLAYED TOWN! /sarcasm.

[Thor665]

You really think I would fakeclaim such a convoluted role? Unlynchable unkillable?

Really, in many ways, your role is less convoluted then the rest of ours. Plus, you don't think a NK immune claim is ever made by scum?

Interesting that the only player not on your suspect list is SOG, who was calling you town. If you flip scum and that doesn't end the game I know where I'm looking tomorrow.

rewq is town, by the way, that's pretty darn obvious at this stage.