Yes (to just about all of this). But IMO, meta isn't quite as weak as some see it. Still, I see what you mean with all the meta votes one after another... and yes, Chrono is the worst of them. But I think my BV vote still stands as he hasn't posted since my vote IIRC. However, I'll give a big ol'Jarti wrote:The rest of the wagon didn't though.Pomegranate wrote:Actually, I'm voting him because he lurked, posted a terrible catchup post mentioning only Kitoari, and talked about weird one-sided OMGUS. Someone asked about his meta and I gave what I know, but that's not why I voted him in the first place.
FakeGod wrote:Alright, so BV lurks when he's scum.
Let's lynch him then, especially since he's not being active anyways. (at this rate, I can't get a read on him at all)
Unvote
Vote: bv310
Anyone support/oppose this?dramonic wrote:I support this <<
Unvote
Vote: bv
inb4AlmasteryellsAll in succession. So yeah, your vote may have been founded, but what got people to hop onto the wagon was meta garbage. At least the way I see it.Chronopie wrote:So no-one has Bv-town/lurker meta?
VOTE: BV310
You hop on and off the BV wagon very easily with a "meta says this; vote him"; "meta says that; unvote him" series of events. I'm fairly sure that makes your vote on him flimsy as there isn't much substance to your backing and it shows.Chronopie wrote:1) Gut reads, and past meta, are valuable tools in any scummers arsenal.Jarti wrote:Willing to throw out lists & then most of the explanations for reads are gut but no effort to vote the people he felt were slightly scummy. But then willing to jump on a flimsy meta-wagon. Screaming scum here.
2) I know of past (completed) Bv310 games, which has him as lurker-scum.
3) Not screaming. I'M NOTICEABLY AGAINST THIS KIND OF POSTING. Irritating to read.
4) Semi-confirmable town role. Don't need to say any more.
--
Since Bv310 provided some town-lurker meta, which I briefly skimmed, I am forced to conclude that lurking is a null-tell for him. Seeing as that was my basis for voting him. UNVOTE: Bv310
Nice to see you trying to call me out with weaksauce reasoning, calling my vote flimsy, then making a flimsy vote yourself. VOTE: Jarti <- Not an OMGUS.
You also neglect to respond to why you didn't feel the need to vote the people you were getting 'slightly scummy' reads on, but were able to easily hop on a meta-case wagon. Gut reads and meta are an important part of your arsenal you say in your #1, but I sense a disconnect between when you are and are not voting.
Let's kill chronopie.
MY HAIR WOULD LIKE TO ANNOUNCE THE VOTECOUNT!
AlmasterGM
Beloved Princess (0) -
Brandi (0) -
bv310 (3) - Pomegranate FakeGod dramonic
charter (0) -
Chronopie (2) - Jarti MaxMouse
dramonic (1) - AlmasterGM
FakeGod (0) -
Jarti (1) - Chronopie
Kitoari (3) - Beloved Princess Charter bv310
MaxMouse (0) -
Pomegranate (0) -
12 alive, 7 to lynch