Mad World: Time Travel Mafia (Game Over)

[Tasky]

Well, I was right about Gandalf (well mostly a 3rd party isn’t town), interested in Tasky thoughts about me now that Gandalf didn’t flip town.

the fact that you were right about gandalf is neither a scum-tell nor a town-tell for me, since both town and scum would have attacked gandalf more or less the same way...
I stay with my opinion that I'd like to hear from you how sure you were that gandalf was scum...

really? That is what that means? You think scum submitted a kill and didn’t bother to check to see what they might or might not of hit? This is bad reasoning.

yeah, you are right...

Dear tasky, please tell me who you think is scum and why?...feel free to OMGUS vote if you need to, hope you have better reasoning than all of your votes thus far in the game. or maybe you just dont care about good reasoning.

as I said, ReaperCharlie...
maybe it's you not reading, since I already posted my reasons clearly...
I reassume:
he posts a lot, but posts a lot of useless stuff... this makes him look like he was doing something when he actually does nothing... I read through his iso and could find exactly one post which was a slight attempt to do something useful...

I should have done this earlier:
UNVOTE: SharkFinn
VOTE: ReaperCharlie

[ooba]

“There was this guy, and he was always requesting shows that had already played. Yes. No. You have to tell her before. He couldn't quite grasp the idea that the charge nurse couldn't make it be yesterday. She couldn't turn back time, thank you, Einstein!”

---

..] Vote Count [..

Zang (0)

AlphaWerewolf (0)

ReaperCharlie (2)

- CallMeLiam, Tasky

curiouskarmadog (0)

Seraphim (0)

SharkFinn (2)

- Karma, Empking

KageLord (0)

CallMeLiam (0)

Anon (0)

Karma (0)

Tasky (2)

- curiouskarmadog, Seraphim

diginova (0)

Empking (0)

I doubt it (0)

Not voting (8)

- Zang, AlphaWerewolf, ReaperCharlie, SharkFinn, KageLord, Anon, diginova, I doubt it

With 14 alive, its 8 to lynch!

---

I'm sorry for not posting your V\LA status ckd - my bad.

[ReaperCharlie]

Hmmm, not seeing a case against RC and the wagon on Shark is lame.

There

is

no case against me (at least as far as I can tell), except for that I've been slim on content. Also, CallMeLiam's vote is just OMGUS from another game. lol

Anyways, since I haven't read the thread yet, a random vote is as good as any. And sheeping ckd doesn't seem like a bad idea at this point. Also, Tasky is voting me, so why not?

Unvote; Vote: Tasky

(blatant omgus)

Anyways, I still haven't been able to read the thread; I'll re-read EVENTUALLY, how about that.

*cue someone saying "omfg! look! Reaper

still

hasn't read the thread! and now he's thrown down a vote? an omgus one at that? obvscum!!! lynchlynchlynch!!!"

[Alpha Werewolf]

I've been busy for the last few days, rereading the thread now - I have a couple of suspects whom I'd like to read in-depth.

[curiouskarmadog]

RC, you can keep poking fun that might not like the fact that you are voting and keep not reading the thread ( I mean I get being busy), but how long is too long in your opinion to keep doing that?

[curiouskarmadog]

RC, you can keep poking fun that might not like the fact that you are voting and keep not reading the thread ( I mean I get being busy), but how long is too long in your opinion to keep doing that?

fucking proofreading.

it is suppose to read.

....you can keep poking fun AT THOSE that might not....

[Zang]

V/LA for a few days

[ReaperCharlie]

RC, you can keep poking fun AT THOSE that might not like the fact that you are voting and keep not reading the thread ( I mean I get being busy), but how long is too long in your opinion to keep doing that?

Usually I do it until people start a wagon on me, but it's already started so I'll have to read some time today I guess =\

Hecka busy... ugh

[diginova]

RC, you can keep poking fun AT THOSE that might not like the fact that you are voting and keep not reading the thread ( I mean I get being busy), but how long is too long in your opinion to keep doing that?

Usually I do it until people start a wagon on me, but it's already started so I'll have to read some time today I guess =\

Hecka busy... ugh

That is not useful for the town. At all.

Also,

Anyways, since I haven't read the thread yet, a random vote is as good as any.

It's day 2. There have been 12 pages of discussion. This is not the RVS.

VOTE: ReaperCharlie

[CallMeLiam]

So RC is sure all the votes on him are OMGUS ones despite him :
A Not voting for any of us and
B Not reading the thread apart from posts about him

He has no interest in scum hunting, only self preservation and keeping up the appearance of being a joky friendly townie. He is pretty obviously scum.

[CallMeLiam]

Bleurgh tired.

A was unclear. I meant to say it can't be a retaliatory OMGUS vote if we're voting him before he votes us. Unless OMGUS changed lately.

[KageLord]

Hey all, sorry it took so long for me to post after replacing in! Anyway, now I'm all caught up on the thread so far, but I have to say, it's a bit of a doosy. There are so many reads being noted that look just wrong to me. Plus the wagon on TheLonging and RC is a bit disconcerting. Just from having played with RC and seen some of his other games, I can't call anything he has done so far a tell either way (so I give him a null read right now). ckd, gandalf, and Magna all drew my attention as well, but not because they looked scummy. It might be a blessing in disguise for town that 2 of the angry or insulting players that I think were most likely to be mislynched (along with RC) have taken an NK for us.

Actually, what drew my attention in the "maybe scumtell" sort of way was Tasky's voting. He doesn't seem very confident with some of his votes (and he usually does in other games I've seen) and the reasons he gives are sometimes completely shallow. But, just this one thing isn't enough to get a vote or even FoS from me.

Anon also perked up my antennas a bit. He seemed to tunnel TheLonging for a good amount of his (Anon's) 8 posts. He kind of went off the radar for a bit then just posted one-liners about TheLonging with what seemed like certainty that TheLonging was scum (also the addition of gandalf to scum list for similar reasoning to the "town tell" from ckd). All of this isn't overtly scummy though, so I wait to see what Anon thinks now that TheLonging (and gandalf) has flipped town. I also want to see what Alpha Werewolf is thinking since he has posted even less, but says he is rereading and has suspects. I want to know who those suspects are and why.

The following are people that I have a null read on and want to see content from (including top suspects and why):

Alpha Werewolf
Anon
EMPKING (all caps because this one reaaaally should do this, haven't seen one ounce of reasoning yet)
I doubt it (was V/LA for a week, ending today, and I liked most of his posts so far, so I want to know his reads though I have more of a town read on him than null)
Zang (apparently V/LA for a few days (again) but still want to know this when he comes back)

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: RC

I thought I was. From what I've seen of his play on the site, I have no doubt that running him up will be good for him.

[curiouskarmadog]

RC wagon is a bad one. Emp's vote is an example of that. Not that I expect you to answer this...

Emp, you think we should lynch RC to improve him as a player, but nothing to do with his game? I have seen you lynched because of your crappy play, it hasnt helped you in the least, why do you feel it will help RC?

Off the game question (but not really), what is RC doing wrong in your opinion as a player? Why would lynching do him good?

Kage, you sure gandalf flipped town?

also, other than being "angry and insulting" any other reads from me, I was confused by your post.

[KageLord]

Kage, you sure gandalf flipped town?

also, other than being "angry and insulting" any other reads from me, I was confused by your post.

You got me there. I should have said he flipped not mafia.

And nope, I have a null read on you so far. Normally I would think something of the aggressiveness, but since it appears that is your usual playstyle, I can't really consider it a tell either way.

[Seraphim]

Mod: will be V/LA from today until the 24th

[ReaperCharlie]

help me improve as a player?

lol! are you joking?

[Anon]

Reads by page 12:

Prob Town:

Karma
Seraphim
youngminni (the meta accusations are very likely to come from a townie entity)

These havent changed, Im now adding:

CKD (agressive stance is towntell from him)
sharkfin (very likely a scumbag would not know who died in the night)
ReaperCharile (quickly losing town points due to not doing anything and constant sheeping)

Prob scum

Longing

diginova
Zang (even though he is looking more and more like VI, still dont want him in endgame)

Im now adding:

gandalf (overall reaction to ckd reeks, his vote for the longing also reeks with the excess of emoticons)

And NOW Im adding this people:
Tasky
Im also disliking Idoubtit posts when I reread them. And Empking's ones too. Also where is Alphawerewolf?

MOD, PLEASE PROD/REPLACE.

I was going to push a diginova wagon (iso looks terrible with few strong positions and some InformationInsteadOfAnalysis but the "bah go town? or bah go scum?" (post 245) gives me some kind of pause.

Tasky is the next good wagon.

Vote: Tasky.

[KageLord]

Also where is Alphawerewolf?

MOD, PLEASE PROD/REPLACE.

AW seems to be somewhat prod dodging. He posted this earlier today (same page):

I've been busy for the last few days, rereading the thread now - I have a couple of suspects whom I'd like to read in-depth.

Unfortunately, he didn't mention who his suspects were or anything like that. Let's hope for some good input from him soon.

[Alpha Werewolf]

Also where is Alphawerewolf?

MOD, PLEASE PROD/REPLACE.

AW seems to be somewhat prod dodging. He posted this earlier today (same page):

I've been busy for the last few days, rereading the thread now - I have a couple of suspects whom I'd like to read in-depth.

Unfortunately, he didn't mention who his suspects were or anything like that. Let's hope for some good input from him soon.

I'm suspicious of Seraphim mainly, that's why I want to reread - at the moment it's just a gut feeling. I also want to reread Tasky and ReaperCharlie, so that I can make my own opinion about the them.

[Alpha Werewolf]

On ReaperCharlie: The case looks good, and I've seen similar play by Fate(as scum) in Square Enix II. Imitating that playstyle are we?

Vote ReaperCharlie

On Tasky: No real read.


I'm going to have to

request replacement

. I don't have as much time as I'd like to dedicate to the game.

[Empking]

RC wagon is a bad one. Emp's vote is an example of that. Not that I expect you to answer this...

Emp, you think we should lynch RC

Quotes please.

Off the game question (but not really), what is RC doing wrong in your opinion as a player? post.

He's ignoring the game when it comes to scumhunting and I'm pretty sure that he could do better as town.

[Tasky]

Prob Town:

sharkfin (very likely a scumbag would not know who died in the night)

could you explain this argument a little better? I don't understand it

ReaperCharile (quickly losing town points due to not doing anything and constant sheeping)

if he is losing town points in your opinion, why are you putting him on the prob-town list?

I was going to push a diginova wagon (iso looks terrible with few strong positions and some InformationInsteadOfAnalysis but the "bah go town? or bah go scum?" (post 245) gives me some kind of pause.

why is that post inherently townish, townish enough to make you ignore what you call a terrible looking iso?

Tasky is the next good wagon.

Vote: Tasky.

I don't see any reason for that in your whole post. Could you please show the arguments behind your vote?

[ReaperCharlie]

[REDACTED]

- ongoing is a no-no

[curiouskarmadog]

there is no point in talking about an ongoing game..in the end it will just get everyone mod killed.

Emp, you want quotes in reference to what?