Nope, not hypocritical.charter wrote:Oso, you're being extremely hypocritical here. Jailkeeper and Doctor are similar. As are Cop, Watcher, and Tracker. You're voting for Xvart because his role is similar to one that's died. Why should we not vote you for being a similar role to one that died? Or why shouldn't we vote for Vezo. Why aren't you voting for Vezo?
In addition, you're ignoring the overwhelming circumstantial evidence pointing towards Xvart being a doctor (and I'm not seeing scum doc in this game one bit). The biggest is that there was no NK night one, and it's unlikely Sotty made the kill (again, zero benefit from her doing it, and they lose the roleblock). Plus, there's Vezo's watching him visit HP. He wasn't killing HP, so he has some other role. I find two mafia roleblockers to be highly unlikely. At that point, you might as well not have any town power roles. It's possible he's some other kind of role, but frankly, him being a doctor makes the most sense.
Yes, I think I've talked myself in to one of Oso or Vezo being scum. I'll agree that Vezo has definitely been scummier, but something I just thought of was how Oso immediately brought up Kage being insane. I don't see that as very likely if he were town. I'll have to reread that as well.
unvote
I see it's clear we're not lynching q21 today, so I'll save that for after we get another scum. I'm not voting Xvart.
NO ONE SHOULD HAMMER XVART RIGHT NOW. Still need some time today to reread.
If vezo or I flipped town, then I would say those roles are similar enough to lynch the other off of that, as scum. Cop gives an alignment. Tracker and Watcher just determine if someone has a night action and who they perfoemwd that action on. There is virtually no similarity between a cop and Watcher/Tracker except that a Watcher/Tracker might be thought of as a 'nerfed' cop when used in tandem and using POE. Neither can definitively determine alignment like a Cop can.
Not so Doc and JailKeeper. They are identical in all respects except for the role blocking power of Jailkeeper. If you go to the wiki here, Jailkeeper=Paranoid Doctor but he is told of his role blocking ability. A Jailkeeper
As to the overwhelming evidence, someone had to make the kill N1 and was prevented. Just because you wouldn't take a pass on using a role block ability to be the person to make the kill on N1 (or any other given night) doesn't mean that someone else wouldn't do so. I still maintain that xvart's claim is false and that using his claim to explain the no kill on N1 is just wrong.