Mini 1069 - Hospital Madness Mafia (Game Over!)

[Moospiker]

Exe: I say that you are going after everyone as you give a bad point about all the players mentioned in that post (even the ones that you don't think are scummy) and then have a thorough fail in justifying it well enough.

Misrep much? I mention 5 people in that post. 1 (Enigma) I say is playing badly.

3(Cooldog, you, NS) I suggest are probably scum,

though not likely all scum. That's only 3 people. 1 other person mentioned (Wingless) I don't even state a particular opinion on. I am in no way attacking "everyone" by attacking 3 players (the general number of scum in your average 12 man game) and calling 1 player foolish.

Also, your "fail in justifying it well enough" argument is crap. You can't just state that something is a certain way and have it be true. My justifications make perfect sense.

Uprising reads as town to me. I don't see any scum motivations in his actions.

Oh, okay, so now you have CoolDog down as probable scum?

Cooldog's claim + crappy vote are still suspicious, but I can't see him being scum with NS anymore after pushing it so hard when he's alone on the wagon. I'm reevaluating my Cooldog read based on the other players, and I'd say:

Scumteam: NS, Moospiker, ???

What has he done on this page that makes you change your mind so quickly?

[Wingless]

[rant]@wing, lets say I kill every night and I mis-kill all of those times, that would lead the town into a pretty bad mess wouldn't it. Killing every night is not an option, however confirming myself as town is very good for the town. It lowers the number of targets from 12 to 11, or after this night 11 to 10 (note: if I don't kill). I will only kill a scummy player, I won't take your attitude to just kill the first person on the player list because it’s good. In fact it isn't good and if anyone suggests that type of play again I will be obliged to vote him or her d-2 (NS should be lynch today).
@Exe, I agree about the ending of wingless' plan, or any plan it is now over I won't talk about it anymore due to the fact that it gives scum info. Also sorry for not catching the vote thing...[/rant]
@Up, other then moo's lack of content/lurking what is your reason for voting him (your vote atm looks very omgusy, moo is correct on that one). Also we understand you are new at this, try not to keep useing it as a semi defense if you mis-lynch...

Then explain me why the town does always lynch someone. It is terrible if the town mislynches, so why don't you complain about that? Why don't you vote for no lynch?
Have you ever tried to make this game's mathematical model?
If you had, you'd know it is worth to kill anybody at random. Anybody.

[CooLDoG]

@wing, I refuse to comment due to the things that I said before. Even telling the scum that I might kill is bad... (don't worry parinoied wingless dude, I'm gonna kill tonight)...

@moo, I like that you are posting content. (twon point you have gained.)

My vote stays on NS until he comes back and posts about himself.

[Enigma]

To clarify, I believed Chesskid had effectively pretty much claimed a doc and since people were talking about how many kills would occur etc, I thought him claiming his role would produce some good insight into the validity of CD's claim and possible night actions.

@moo, I like that you are posting content. (twon point you have gained.)

Posting content is no town tell, infact I think many people are even slightly more active as scum than town

Enigma is suspicious. Why have you voted Uprising? I see her a bit indefinite but nothing else. There were more scummy persons at all time in the game. Why didn't you vote them? Why did you tunnel *Uprising*

Scummy is defined on different perspective. I've posted why I think Uprising is scummy in all my posts (with actual reasons not some herpaderpa weak WIFOM stuff like yours).

You completely neglect the possibility of. A successful doc protect which is why it is necessary for chessscum to quote his role pm.

If you think chesskid is scum, why aren't you voting for him? And why do you think chesskid is scum? Previously you where saying that chesskid is town.

I see zero non circumstantial evidence as to why everyone is voting chesskid...

Vote: Enigma

His vote on me is horrific lawls. Way to take me completely out of context and quoting two posts several days apart with zero reference to anything that has happened in between. (And btw when I call someone scum it doesn't necessarily mean I'm dead certain on them being scum, I was merely trying to agitate him). Seems like he went through my ISO looking for a reason to find me scummy, not because he genuinely found me scummy. + major scum points here for you mate.

VOTE: Enigma


Now that I've reread, I'm feeling him scum moreso than before. The tunneling isn't too kind, either.

Her vote on me is just fail. I pity the clueless like Wingless who don't think you are scummy and laugh at his helplessness.

UNVOTE:

Oh, BTW, I'm a she, not a he.

VOTE: MooSpiker

You all don't want Enigma lynched SO I will go after a different scum.
MooSpiker is scum to me.

Uprising needs more votes, please help me out here!

Chesskid writing in other people's quote brackets makes me a sad panda. I nearly missed it. Please don't do it again.

Based on the past 2 pages, Zang has shot up my scum list from being an AFK that everyone ignored to probable scum. I also still find Uprising's play consistently scummy.

[Tasky]

VOTE: TheLonging

[Exe]

Moo either has serious reading comprehension issues, or intentionally misrepped. Take a look at the first quote in his post 325.

3(Cooldog, you, NS) I suggest are probably scum,

though not likely all scum.

You bold the first part of the sentence, and ignore the second part which would've answered your question.
In the second thing you quoted, you have shown my reasoning for Cooldog not being scum with NS. Hence, in the first quote I say they are

not likely all scum

. Because I suspect that either NS or Cooldog is scum, but not both.
Therefore, clearly nothing has changed, and I don't know how you didn't see the second part of the sentence you bolded. Ignoring it? Probably.

NS still needs to post. His lurking is not helping my suspicions on him.
Tasky, why vote TL? I don't find TL scummy at all.
Enigma, your case motivations seem town to me, but I don't find Uprising genuinely scummy. Your vote would be better placed on NS.

[Tasky]

Tasky, why vote TL? I don't find TL scummy at all.

for fun.

[Enigma]

Enigma, your case motivations seem town to me, but I don't find Uprising genuinely scummy. Your vote would be better placed on NS.

No ty, I think I shall decide where I want to put my vote myself. But I would happily settle on Zang though, it's like everyone has forgotten he exists!

[CooLDoG]

Tasky, why vote TL? I don't find TL scummy at all.

for fun.

That is not a valid reason...

@en, valid content I find to be pro-town... (That’s just my tell feel free to disagree) One thing that has bothered me is the fact that he switched from being an active lurker to an avid poster... I need to keep tabs on him anyway...

[CooLDoG]

@exe, why do you always happen to be online when I am?

[Uprising]

[rant]@wing, lets say I kill every night and I mis-kill all of those times, that would lead the town into a pretty bad mess wouldn't it. Killing every night is not an option, however confirming myself as town is very good for the town. It lowers the number of targets from 12 to 11, or after this night 11 to 10 (note: if I don't kill). I will only kill a scummy player, I won't take your attitude to just kill the first person on the player list because it’s good. In fact it isn't good and if anyone suggests that type of play again I will be obliged to vote him or her d-2 (NS should be lynch today).
@Exe, I agree about the ending of wingless' plan, or any plan it is now over I won't talk about it anymore due to the fact that it gives scum info. Also sorry for not catching the vote thing...[/rant]
@Up, other then moo's lack of content/lurking what is your reason for voting him (your vote atm looks very omgusy, moo is correct on that one). Also we understand you are new at this, try not to keep useing it as a semi defense if you mis-lynch...

Then explain me why the town does always lynch someone. It is terrible if the town mislynches, so why don't you complain about that? Why don't you vote for no lynch?
Have you ever tried to make this game's mathematical model?
If you had, you'd know it is worth to kill anybody at random. Anybody.

He is quite right. Kill, CooLDoG, kill!

[Uprising]

However, if I'm not lynched today, I'm sure I'll die tonight.

Also, I haven't seen much of Zang and/or I've a null read on him.


I'll post more of my beliefs after my accounting class.

[TheLonging]

Maybe my scumreads are off or completely inaccurate.

Oh, there's the n00b card again.

Except it's not

I don't know who I was voting, but fuck this, Moospiker is awesome at being scum. Misrepping is very good as well as disguising fluff as content that seems useful.

unvote
Vote: Moospiker

[TheLonging]

VOTE: TheLonging

cool story bro

[Wingless]

However, if I'm not lynched today, I'm sure I'll die tonight.

Also, I haven't seen much of Zang and/or I've a null read on him.


I'll post more of my beliefs after my accounting class.

Why are you sure?

I didn't forget Zang.
I think it is very strange that he has only 7 votes here with a 3 post/day number. I found Enigma scummier. Zang, when he wrote, wrote content. Mainly about Tasky and a bit about chesskid.

[chesskid3]

Enigma is deftown, Moospiker is probscum, NS is probVI.
Tasky is a nullread.
Exe is probtown but he's really good so :/
TL is probscum
Cooldog is probtown
Slaxx is definactive
Zang is a nullread
Parama is defmod
Uprising is probtown

[chesskid3]

and Wingless is a nullread

[Moospiker]

Maybe my scumreads are off or completely inaccurate.

Oh, there's the n00b card again.

Except it's not

I don't know who I was voting, but fuck this, Moospiker is awesome at being scum. Misrepping is very good as well as disguising fluff as content that seems useful.

unvote
Vote: Moospiker

'Except it's not'? - how is that any kind of argument? Uprising is, in that quote, playing the noob card, explaining why he CONVENIENTLY WISHY WASHES AND OMGUSs as his scum reads might be 'completely inaccurate.' He keeps saying stuff like this. He's trying to stay under the radar and I have no idea why people are completely ignoring him.

There's a difference between a misrep and a honest mistake. I

misread

Exe's post saying that he found three of us scummy to mean that he didn't find CoolDog scummy. If he makes his posts hard to understand and I get it wrong, I fail to see how that's my fault. He lists me and NS as scum, then in a later post, rephrases 'Moo, NS, ???' to 'two of Moo, NS, CoolDog'.

An example of a

misrep

is your post here which states I am

disguising fluff as content that seems useful.

Since when? This is complete trash.

[TheLonging]

It's not playing the noob card though. You must also misread posts a lot. It's not just Exe.

Hold on, let me dig up examples, maybe I can get one or two before I go off to an appointment.

[TheLonging]

As in, show me how Uprising plays the noob card. She's not a noob to mafia at all, and that post isn't using the noob card.

[Nobody Special]

Okay,

unvote

And then, because he's largely pain in my ass,

Vote: Exe

[Uprising]

However, if I'm not lynched today, I'm sure I'll die tonight.

Also, I haven't seen much of Zang and/or I've a null read on him.


I'll post more of my beliefs after my accounting class.

Why are you sure?

I didn't forget Zang.
I think it is very strange that he has only 7 votes here with a 3 post/day number. I found Enigma scummier. Zang, when he wrote, wrote content. Mainly about Tasky and a bit about chesskid.

Oh, I just figured that a lot of people will want town to kill me, because apparently I'm clearly scum.

[Slaxx]

unvote

then, because he is scum,

vote : Nobody Special

[Uprising]

Parama is defmod

Agreed.

Wingless is town.
Slaxx is town.
Exe is town.
TL is probably town.
ChessKid3 is town.
Unsure about NS.
Unsure about Tasky.
Unsure about Zang.
Moospiker is likely scum.
CooLDoG apparently isn't scum, but I'm still feeling he is.
Enigma may be scum, but apparently isn't. But I still think so.

Fixed tag.

[Uprising]

Agh, I fail.