Magician's Mafia: The Hypnotists, Game Over

[Ellibereth]

Wait, has ghost been cleared cleared or is Katsu just assuming.

[Katsuki]

Elli you are scum?

Also have you been reading anything? Ghost is a whole lot more cleared than tasky is. (coughdocprotectcough)

[Katsuki]

Also I thought I was onto something with Dana... = =
I actually didn't realize you thought it was guilty until I looked back.

I think you get the Sam thing in all honesty. It will come tomorrow.

[Katsuki]

Just a note.

Scum missed a NK N2. That's +1 hypnotized player. I doubt scum hypnotized MPR, but rather killed him due to claimed PR. This leaves +2 hypnotized players lying around.
If town does not mislynch, then scum will eventually run out of NKs.

Town should be ok. Hopefully.

List of suspects:
CES
Spy
Elli
DGB
Tasky (town if DGB town)

[Katsuki]

Elli:

I don't think DGB scum...just with my experience with her she wouldn't be the type to just make up that claim when she's busy with non-mafia stuff...she would have just tried to keep it simple.

Ok this is just terrible. Fake-claims do not happen over the course of only one day.


Sleeping now, vote accordingly guys.

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't think Katsuki is scum. CES is scum. Come on guys.

[petroleumjelly]

Day Five Vote Count #3

3 DrippingGoofball (Cogito Ergo Sum, Katsuki, Toogeloo)
2 Cogito Ergo Sum (DrippingGoofball, GhostWriter)
2 Katsuki (Tasky, Ellibereth)

With

8

alive it takes

5

to lynch, and

3

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is November 10, 10:30 p.m. CST.

Not Voting – 1 – SpyreX

@mod:

assume scum hypnotizes player A to kill player B. If A get's roleblocked, will B die?

If a player is hypnotized to kill, they will not successfully kill if they are successfully roleblocked that night. This will not prevent a hypothetical player B from dying in some other manner, obviously. Apologies for not answering this question sooner, I originally missed it.

[SpyreX]

God god god god GOD

I dont like this.

I don't think DGB is scum. Not after rereading over and over and over again.

I REALLY am having issues with how this setup balances against itself without scum in the PR's thus claimed though. A MASSCLAIM SURE WOULD HAVE BEEN NICE, NO.

Unvote, Vote: CES

[Tasky]

Damn. I guess we need this lynch.
I think we are doing this wrong, but as as deadline is today, we don't have any choice but to lynch. and since you don't seem to want to come and lynch Katsuki and I don't expect everybody to be online until then...

unvote, vote CES

still feel this is wrong, though.

@CES: CLAIM NOW!!

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

We only need 3 to lynch at deadline, Tasky.

And I don't feel like claiming.

[Tasky]

DO IT, NOW. and I may be voting someone else. had missed that deadline lynch thing

[SpyreX]

I'm up in the air. Even my read on DGB goes back and forth with the Anti-counterpush yesterday.

I could lynch Kat. Believe you me AND I'll be around for at least a few hours.

However, this bidness is fff

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Fine, Tasky. I'm just a Magician. (Oh hey, this doesn't change a thing. What a surprise!)

[Tasky]

I do not believe CES is scum.

unvote, vote Katsuki

. This is definitely the right thing to do.
CES has given me town-vibes all along and his last post feels town.

[Tasky]

oh, and

FoS: SpyreX

. his last reactions didn't seem town at all.

[SpyreX]

Ohh taskers WHAT about that seems town.

[Tasky]

Ohh taskers WHAT about that seems town.

don't know, just a feeling.
I am getting town-vibes all the whole day from CES.

[SpyreX]

Fair enough.

You're good people.

EVEN IF YOU QUOTED OHH NOES

Maybe I'm having issues pulling it together on DGB. What's your thoughts on the whole dealio?

[GhostWriter]

I'm on my phone, so I might be wrong, but if deadline rolls around, I think DGB dies. This shall not pass. She is town. Kats and CES are both far better candidates and way more appropriate targets. Toog, I cannot back you on this one. You seem so certain of DGB, but I ask you: are you so uncertain of Kats? Or of CES? UNVOTE: and VOTE: Kats

[Toogeloo]

I am not completely sold on any of them, though I do think it's either CES or DGB as scum. I like the DGB lynch better because of the confirmation we get from it in the end as it would assure either CES or Tasky as town and limit tomorrows actions. We lynch Katsuki and regardless of the result we are probably still in the same position tomorrow forced to choose between CES and DGB.

I'm not sure where this SpyreX suspicion has come from. I mean he is in no way confirmed, but seriously... would he bus Anti yesterday as a scumbuddy and ride it the entire way? If his goal was to get some takers on Anti, and then Anti counter those takers, then it's possible, but I kind of saw SpyreX as more or less town after the Anti flip for being the headline of it.


Today is kind of a coin flip I think, hopefully giving us all the info we need to close this out tomorrow, but this last minute scramble back and forth on Kat and CES does raise an eyebrow.

[Toogeloo]

@Mod: out of curiousity, what happens in the event of a tie with two people having a majority of a majority?

I won't sit on DGB stubbornly if we have to make a decision between the two. It's far better to lynch than to not do so. I will be watching the topic until deadline off and on and will move to Kat (or CES) in order to prevent a no lynch scenario if need be. There is still a little over 5 hours, so I want to hear someone make some better cases for a lynch today instead of "this doesn't feel right."

[Tasky]

I am not completely sold on any of them, though I do think it's either CES or DGB as scum. I like the DGB lynch better because of the confirmation we get from it in the end as it would assure either CES or Tasky as town and limit tomorrows actions. We lynch Katsuki and regardless of the result we are probably still in the same position tomorrow forced to choose between CES and DGB.

we will be in ALMOST the same position. the only differences will be:
1. having Katsuki's flip helping us to decide between CES and DGB
2. if DGB is town, she will be able to investigate one more time which could be crucial.

If you think that you are going to lynch Katsuki anyway tomorrow, you might as well lynch him today and have more information tomorrow to decide on how to proceed.

Today is kind of a coin flip I think, hopefully giving us all the info we need to close this out tomorrow, but this last minute scramble back and forth on Kat and CES does raise an eyebrow.

Why does it reais an eyebrow? Do you think scum is involved badly or something like that? Please elucidate your thought.

PS: Toogeloo, you better roleblock the mafiakiller or the one being hypnotized tonight. Tonight you should spend a while trying to figure out how scum acted up to now and how they'll act in the future.

[Katsuki]

^I like how tasky is trying to coax tooge into using his one-shot RB tonight.
It's posts like these that I am having a very hard time believing that tasky is town.

I want to hear why GW thinks I am scum, aside from "deadline". I think I asked of this from tasky too, but he never answered me.

Tasky interaction with coggy this page also gives me bad feelings. I will see if I can translate those feelings into words after I get out of class.

[Katsuki]

Also tasky, I'd love to hear your response to spy's inquiries on your thoughts on all this "dealio"

[Tasky]

"I like how tasky is trying to coax tooge into using his one-shot RB tonight.
It's posts like these that I am having a very hard time believing that tasky is town."

Well, yeah. I just told him that IMO tonight is the time to use it. Of course he will then decide on his own.
What problem do you have with that exactly?