ThAdmiral wrote:smashbro_of_the_SSS wrote: Now that it turns out he was town, I definitely believe that at least one scum jumped on that wagon quickly, and likely stayed on it, hoping to lynch the power role anyway.
Who do you think this might have been then?
My two main suspects from the wagon were don and werewolf. Lew could also be thrown in, but he has seemed more town to me than scum. Werewolf was interested in self preservation, and now that he's flipped town, it obviously wasn't him. don has seemed to join many popular wagons, without much of an explanation of "i agree with the voter above me." I could definitely see him as scum trying to look townish.
As for why I hadn't started to look through the wagon, was just because I'd had little time. I've been focusing on NaNoWriMo, considering that it's near the end of the November, and I want to finish.
lewarcher82 wrote:Thank you. I now had a closer look at smash's switch (#198). Interesting timing.
At the time, only one other person had their vote on mallow, and I felt that my vote would be better used to pressure werewolf / still concentrate on one of my scum reads. When I say one, I mean the vote from PurpleOrange, although DJ had a vote on mallow also. DJ's votes go around so much, and with little justification that I tend to not put much stock in them.
--------------------------
now, as for the mallow wagon.
vote: mallowgeno
As for the case:
--- mallow follows DJ's vote, first saying that he agreed with DJ, and then taking it back, saying his vote was to humor him. I don't like the inconsistency, and backing down when people began to disagree with the vote and its seriousness.
--- his next few posts consist of saying that he thinks Consig is town, and not knowing about anyone else, despite having a bit of information to form opinions on. He buddies up with gonzoo in the post before, and agrees that Consig seems to be town, which seems to be as trying to get on the town's good side while providing little.
--- his next post asks if it was a lynch on consig, which I just find odd.
--- for a few pages, he says nothing, and when asked about explaining about Lew, he says:
mallowgeno wrote:lewarcher82 wrote:When did I question your votes mallow? I only questioned your vote on me, which was first made without giving any reasons, and I was not the only one to note that. As you gave reasons, I unvoted you and moved on. So I am not sure what are the "votes" you are referring to. Can you please explain?
I was referring to the one time I voted you. I did explain after I voted. Since it was rvs I figured I didn't need to explain.
--- when he votes werewolf (putting werewolf to L-1), he gives no reason at all:
mallowgeno wrote:purple orange wrote:Why should he care what Don thought? Was there any reason for him to follow/humor Don over someone else?
Is there a reason why I should/shouldn't follow someone in the RVS? Get over that. As for werewolf, prematurely claiming is quite scummy. Even so, if you are a VT you take it until you are lynched (unless lylo/mylo).
vote werewolf
--- he refuses to give even a cursory read on another player when asked, and still gives no reason for the werewolf vote.
mallowgeno wrote:Zhero wrote:Hmm, I smell a bus.
Vote: mallowgeno
Mallow, what do you think of Lew?
Apparently whatever I say won't be taken seriously, therefore I refuse to answer. (oooo scummy)
--- as to the point above, he later says that Lew "could be town" but he is not 100% sure.
------------
in conclusion, Mallow has been no help to the town at all, and has, at times, voted opportunistically and with no explanation. Scummy actions.
that's all for tonight, but for the record, right now I'm also suspicious of DJ, and slightly of the powerrox/chesskid slot, but I haven't looked into that one much at all. Will have to reread to see what I see.