1. Gamma: Actually I wanted Vezok to be specific. I find it
more odd that he originally said that his skill didn't work
and changed it to
he made a thread with FATE
but he's alone.
To me this actually reads as scummy just based on psychology. Since I brought up out of game meta about neighbors (different mods, etc), the story changed. Since the story changed: it reads as scum trying his best to answer the question or change it from the original statement.
Vezok claimed his neighbouring powers didn't work. He didn't claim that he targeted Fate nor that he made a thread until I made the out of game meta. He claimed without claiming any information in the original statement.
To me this change reads as a scum slip. Nice trap eh? :3
2. Jahudo: A neighbourizer should just be treated as null in any case. Even though he's been bread crumbing his role, and sheeping his town/neighbour pick, that doesn't excuse him from scummy play. And trust me, after a ton of Reck and Ythill games I'm tired of scum sheeps. When someone sheeps they put all the responsibility (eg whether they look scummy going in/coming out of the lynch or wagon). Rather then focus on those case leaders, I'd be more worried about the sheeps that didn't contribute to the case/game.
3. SK Case: I'm not saying Spy is an SK. I'm saying that if Spy was determined in game via normal scum hunting or role actions to BE AN SK, we should keep him around to be our chained puppy. Otherwise Spy is just spy and just reads normally (aka I have a feeling he's town). If people really, really, really, want to press on this issue they would do so because they think Spy is SK scum.
4. Jahudo again: I dislike how you and many other people are excusing Vezok for
changing his story in a role action claim
. To me this is fishy.
5. UK: Just the hammer post gives me bad vibes (I've been there and done that as lulzy scum). I know different meta argument, sue me. I'm cranking up the dial on my empathy powerz (powers in training :[)