Mini 1105: A Mafia Invasion! (Game Over)

[LlamaGod]

Hmm, rereading Guderian gave me less of a secure townread on him.
Oh well, I still find Zdenek easily scummiest.
May as well claim now, especially since we want the day moving a bit faster than normal so we have time to think after a possible vigshot.
It's not as if the replacee has his vote on Zdenek and may move it off when he replaced.

[Locke Lamora]

I have thought about it but nobody else seems to care that his behavior isn't helping town, and Zde is creating a weak case against Llama who I feel has been pro-town plus the whole thing about Tasky and the role PM comment gives him a credibility as a town player

Except one thing he did say, did strike me as odd, I don't think it's much to push right now and not enough to de-rail zde's wagon

So are scum more likely to make weak cases than townies? And if you think Tasky is town because of that comment, why do you keep suggesting he's scummy for not contributing?

Tasky: when I last played with you, you seemed much more inclined to make cases and scumhunt. Now you're sitting around posting one-liners. What happened?

[RobCapone]

1. yes I feel scum is more likely to make weak or even no cases
2. I feel tasky could be town from his comment but than the skeptical part of me thinks he could have just been throwing it out something about the role PM, something we can't even discuss, to earn town cred. Anyone who questions him he can easily attack as being scum.

tbh I have seen tasky play better than this, so while I am skeptical of his play I am not sure he is the lynch today.

[Tasky]

I usually make cases and scumhunt only when I feel like it.
When the game proceeds in a somehow smooth manner, I don't think adding my reasonings will do any good.
I usually tend to pick things up sometimes, and sometimes I really get drawn into it and start making huge cases and WoTs for some days. now is not one of that sometimes.

[Rain]

@Rob
No. Scummy or not, Pappums post constructive statements whereas Ellibereth posts things for the sake of posting things.

[RobCapone]

@Rob
No. Scummy or not, Pappums post constructive statements whereas Ellibereth posts things for the sake of posting things.

I'll give you today pappums is doing that, not as much day 1 because it seemed more like mimicking

Elli has been useless

I'd need to re-read though to see if it's worth looking into, I'm waiting to see what zde does next

I'm at work, I'll try and re-read elli tonight

[Empking]

Ellibereth may very well be scum (i'd put her third myself) but so is Zdenek and with Zdenek its not just the active lurking but the scum based misquotings.

[Zachrulez]

5th vote count of day 2:

Zdenek - 4 (Robcapone, Empking, Tasky, Pappums rat)
Robcapone - 1 (Locke Lamora)
Llamagod - 1 (Zdenek)
Ellibereth - 1 (Rain)
Rosswilliam - 1 (Ellibereth)

Not voting: 2 (Rosswilliam, Llamagod)

With 10 alive it's 6 to lynch

Looking for a Ross replacement.

Day 1 will end no later than Sunday Jan 30th at 5pm CST

[LlamaGod]

Huh, didn't realize how soon deadline is. Zdenek really needs to claim (he's essentially at L-1 with my vote off merely to prevent selfhammer) so we can vig him if we have vigshots and make a reasonable lynch today.

[Rain]

I would not depend on day vigs. We don't know if it's only one-shot, and I don't want vig to claim. We should act as if it didn't exist (or rather, yesterday was a one-shot vig). Something about hoping for the best while expecting the worst.

[LlamaGod]

It's not a matter of depending on a vig, it's a matter of giving ourselves an opportunity to make full use of one if they have more shots. Regardless of vig availability, Zdenek should claim. I guess I'll let him self-hammer if he's scum to avoid the vig; certainty is nice hehe.

VOTE: ZDENEK L - 1

[Tasky]

It's not a matter of depending on a vig, it's a matter of giving ourselves an opportunity to make full use of one if they have more shots. Regardless of vig availability, Zdenek should claim. I guess I'll let him self-hammer if he's scum to avoid the vig; certainty is nice hehe.

VOTE: ZDENEK L - 1

I think it is time for a

H_A_M_M_M_A_A_A_A_A_A...

Unvote,

VOTE ZDENEK

[LlamaGod]

A claimless hammer...
Oh well I guess we just wait and see if Zdenek is scum.

[Zdenek]

Tasky was already voting me, so that's not a hammer.

I'm a hider. I didn't hide behind anyone last night.

Ellibereth may very well be scum (i'd put her third myself) but so is Zdenek and with Zdenek its not just the active lurking but the scum based misquotings.

I don't think it's reasonable to characterize my play as active lurking, and the only thing you could possible call a misquoting is the thing about LlamaGod saying that Rob has a town feel, and frankly I don't think that's a misquoting even if you disagree that he was trying to change his opinions to match yours.

[Zachrulez]

6th vote count of day 2:

Zdenek - 5 (Robcapone, Empking, Pappums rat, Llamagod, Tasky)
Robcapone - 1 (Locke Lamora)
Llamagod - 1 (Zdenek)
Ellibereth - 1 (Rain)
Rosswilliam - 1 (Ellibereth)

Not voting: 2 (Rosswilliam)

With 10 alive it's 6 to lynch

Looking for a Ross replacement.

Day 1 will end no later than Sunday Jan 30th at 5pm CST

[Zachrulez]

Welcome GreyICE who replaces RossWilliam!

[Empking]

Hidfer is an ambigious name. I'd appreiate more details.

[RobCapone]

Hidfer is an ambigious name. I'd appreiate more details.

this

[Ellibereth]

I'm a hider. I didn't hide behind anyone last night.

What.
Hide behind noone?
Why>?

[GreyICE]

I'll just do my usual when replacing in and

Unvote

Hello everyone, glad to be here! Looks like a fun town. Lets lynch Elliberet for posting random giggles and unhelpful posts and shit. Is he the largest wagon yet? I see his name in the players list, I assume it's going to be moderately high on the lynch list. Then again, that's Elli's best talent as town or scum - staying scummy enough that he rarely rises to the top of the NK or Lynch list, making him the world's best home of lurking scum and power roles. Also a disturbingly good scumcatcher.

[RobCapone]

I think that is why we need him to explain more

[Ellibereth]

Goddamnit Grey stop predicting what I'm doing before reading...
AND REPLACING INTO EVERY GAME I'M IN.
You only have 1 more to go!

...

And i'm sad you might be scum this time.
Are you scum this time?

[Ellibereth]

I think that is why we need him to explain more

Hey robby, disregarding claim, do me a favor and 3 short sentences on why Zde = scumz plz.

[GreyICE]

Oh hells, I already know who I want to lynch, and I haven't read anything besides votecounts. Let me catch up here and post some solid analysis, but based on vote counts, unless something really, really, really surprising is contained in the in-thread posts, there's one person we HAVE to kill.

[Ellibereth]

WAITWAIT DON'T POST THE NAME
LET ME GUESS