2 scum left with 3 townies or really just 2 scum left and Benmage is one/Benmage is a cop.Magua wrote:Tell me how it could come down to that situation.Bunnylover wrote:More of a gut feeling then actual logical reasoning.
The only reason I can see Benmage keeping the power is because he has an investigation role.
Its not on urgent were going to lose this game if Benmage doesn't use the power today, but it could come down to the situation.
If Benmage is one, he would use his hands on one of the VI that are still around knowing that he himself would be lynch.
We would then probably proceed to lynch Benmage who will flip scum, and our next action would be to lynch the person who he used the power on assuming that we don't play the WIFOM game. With 5 people left, he just gave his scum member a bigger chance of winning the game.
If Benmage is a cop and see that one of his innocent, who turns out to be the GF, is about to be lynched he uses the power. For some reason we don't lynch Benmage, probably because he comes out telling us he's the cop, and we lynch one of the other people. Benmage dies, flips cops, we would assume that the person Benmage protected is a confirmed townie because Benmage flipped cop and said he was confirmed innocent. The GF ends up winning the game.
All of this happening probably unlikely because people wouldn't just think straight forward and would consider the possibility of GF and using the power on a townie to throw off suspicion on their party and etc, but like I said earlier even if it has the smallest possibility of happening, shouldn't we avoid it?