That's a nice script, but one thing I don't understand is why person 1 waited until the end to start (questionably) scum hunting instead of wasting person 2's time by speaking in twisted analogies and parables.bgg1996 wrote:Cute dialogue
Why on earth does it matter at this point? I know you're trying to use this information to confirm the existence of an SK, but knowing the specifics of Magnetic's role is not going to do that. If you want 95% confirmation, all you have to do is look at the night kills. Tclawren makes absolutely no sense as a vig kill, so it must have been an SK. There, question answered. On the off chance I'm wrong, hooray, I have a pleasant surprise.bgg1996 wrote:You expect me to believe that it's a coincidence that Magnetic guessed that there were two killing sources?
Vig or SK is completely irrelevant at this point, particularly because if we mislynch today, an SK would have nearly as much motivation to try to NK a mafia member as a vig would. Even if there is a vig, how is it going to change your play? It shouldn't at all. If you're town, either way you should be hunting scum.
The question of SK or vig concerns mafia more than it concerns town, and I'm pretty worried by the fact that you're still hung up on this issue. I consider it a scum tell both because I feel that it has become a substitute for meaningful scum hunting and because the information you're digging for is more important to mafia than it is to town.