Zdenek wrote:I agree with DGB that Setael is scummy for reasons in addition to Mikujin's lack of activity
and his vote on DGB, which reads like he's appeasing the town.
DGB hasn't said anything like this. The only reason she's given for suspecting my slot is "wagon analysis" (of one of Miku's votes). If you're going to hide behind someone else's suspicions, at least get your facts straight.
zdenek wrote:Set wrote:
I don't see the suspicion on Twilight. I disagree with what MoI said about the ISO posts not containing scumhunting. I can see the V/LA of 2 of the heads being the reason for the low activity D1 (especially if they're wanting to all weigh in before posting - I for one would find it annoying if they were constantly coming in and contradicting themselves because they didn't all agree with what was posted in the first place.)
Here Setael says that she doesn't understand the case on Twilight, but goes on to excuse Twilight for their low activity, which actually suggests that she did understand the suspicion on Twilight and chose to defend them.
I never said I didn't "understand" the case on Twilight. "I don't see the suspicion on Twilight" means it's baseless. I then explained that it was baseless because there was a perfectly good reason for the low activity D1. You're really stretching to try to find reasons to think I'm scummy.
zed wrote:Setael wrote:
Where's nexus? He's plenty active in the game he's modding that I'm in.
I really hate these sorts of attacks; they are lazy and draw attention to a player for something that isn't really scummy.
A) If he was lurking and posting elsewhere but not here, which is what I thought when I posted this, how would that not be scummy?
B) This has already been brought up and I have already responded. Do you have a problem with my explanation?
@Andrius - Can you answer B as well because this is the only reason I saw you bring up for listing me as scummier than a leprechaun. (Let me know if I missed something).
zed wrote:Set wrote:
I haven't changed my mind. He's still my #1 scum read, but something I read in his post made me decide to put him in my pocket until tomorrow.
Maybe you already answered it, but what was the thing in his post that made you want to delay his lynch?
He soft claimed PR.
zed wrote:Setael wrote:
LMP, are you claiming SK?
A pointless rhetorical question.
It wasn't rhetorical. I couldn't see any reason a town vig would kill chesskid D1. There was actually a lot of discussion about this, so how could you see it as rhetorical?
zed wrote:Additionally, I feel that her attack on Bunnylover is poorly reasoned. A great deal of it is based on Bunnylover "playing the VI card" and while I agree that is true, I do not feel that the case actually represents an attempt to determine what Bunnylover's motivations have been, but is just an attempt to exaggerate certain characteristics of Bunnylover's that could be interpreted as scummy.
Hang on. You're saying you think BL is playing the VI card... does that mean you think all the times she calls herself stupid is intentional to try to avoid responsibility for her actions?
So basically you are saying you agree with the point I originally made, and yet you are making no attempt to determine BL's motivations. How is that different from what you are accusing me of?
magua wrote:Setael lynch is waaaay more preferable for me than a Raivann lynch.
I'd love to hear what so fully converted you to my lynch. I find this really suspect since no one has given anything but crap arguments.
Shifting attention to me just seems like a distraction from Raivann. Of those who are listing me as scum with weak/contrived reasons {Raivann, dana, Andrius, zedenek, DGB, magua} at least one is scum (I'm looking at Raivann) and one is probably SK (hi, Zed!).