Mini 1145 — Plain Mafia (over)

[Erratus Apathos]

No I'm not. Stalling is anti-town, moving forward in a timely manner is pro-town.

[Peabody]

I'm tired of DeathRowKitty not following through on his promises to post.

I am ready for the hammer to fall. I think inHim's flip has the potential of giving us some good information regarding crazypianist. I have a hunch that there is something beyond the apparent play of crazy: first, defending against the arguments toward inHim based on day 1 (though he had a slight scum read on inHim based on evidence in day 1), and second, turning his 'slightly scummy' read on inHim to a more significant scummy read on him as inHim's impending lynch became more apparent. It just... it looks like bussing. My accusation is only a hunch with no evidence. Let's see how inHim flips.

Let's drop this hammer.

[Valern]

Righto.

VOTE: inhimshallibe

[Quilford]

Peabody removed his vote on inhim, and since I respect his cautiousness I'm not going to hop on the inhim wagon at the moment despite all three of the players who've been in that slot being incredibly useless and anti-town and, as a result, most likely scum. But I'm definitely going to move there if his posting doesn't get a hell of a lot more useful soon.

Valern, you explicitly state that you don't want to hop on the inHim wagon unless his posting gets a hell of a lot more useful soon. He posted once between this post and your hammer, and it was stating that he would post again later. Explain.

[Valern]

Valern, you explicitly state that you don't want to hop on the inHim wagon unless his posting gets a hell of a lot more useful soon.

And it didn't. It's entirely likely that inhim only said that in order to stall the day further (if he had last thoughts to share, I would think he would have made a point of sharing them promptly, which he obviously chose not to do). Problem...?

+ I'm tired of hearing EA moan about how we're dragging the day out, tbqh. >.>

[ICEninja]

Alright well I had a huge post full of content that I was going to make tomorrow but looks like that isn't happening.

Good job.

I've been busy with taxes and all but would have had time to get through everything. I guess we'll see what happens.

[Peabody]

Good night. See you in the morning.

[Erratus Apathos]

[Quilford]

Um, what.

[DeathRowKitty]

In the interest of being as frustrating as possible while still saying something remotely useful, at least one (and probably exactly one) player that's been consistently pointing out I'm not posting is scum.

[Quilford]

And you know this how?

[Quilford]

ALSO GO POST IN THE OPEN GAME YOU ARE NEGLECTING RAH RAH

[Quilford]

Wait, so, Peabody? How do you know Peabody is scum?

[Quilford]

aww fenhl's viewing this forum

inb4 locked

[Fenhl]

Vote Count 2.final

inHimshallibe	5	Erratus Apathos	Quilford	RangeroftheNorth	Peabody	Valern
Quilford	1	crazypianist1116

Spoiler: more info

Not voting: ICEninja, DeathRowKitty, inHimshallibe

A majority has been reached, and inHimshallibe is being lynched.

inHimshallibe, Mafia Goon, is dead.

It is now Night 2. The current deadline is Apr 18 10:33.

[Fenhl]

Erratus Apathos, Compulsive Town Doctor, is dead.

It is now Day 3. The current deadline is Apr 25 10:14.

Vote Count 3.0

No one is currently voting.

Spoiler: more info

Not voting: crazypianist1116, ICEninja, Quilford, RangeroftheNorth, Peabody, Valern, DeathRowKitty
With 7 living players, a majority consists of 4 votes.

[Quilford]

Reviewing EA's posts.

[Quilford]

In the interest of being as frustrating as possible while still saying something remotely useful, at least one (and probably exactly one) player that's been consistently pointing out I'm not posting is scum.

I want you to expand on this post please.

[RangeroftheNorth]

Vote: Crazypianist

Reasons should be obvious, but I'll post them in the morning anyway.

[DeathRowKitty]

In the interest of being as frustrating as possible while still saying something remotely useful, at least one (and probably exactly one) player that's been consistently pointing out I'm not posting is scum.

I want you to expand on this post please.

I posted very little yesterday. Obviously I'm going to get called out for that...but not by everyone.

Scum tend to follow along with trends like that. Scum see a player being harassed for something that's completely logical and they want in on it, so one of them will join the fun. The others will see their buddy bringing it up and don't want to all be seen attacking the same player.

So when I posted that, I didn't (and still don't) have any specific player in mind. It's fairly likely though that exactly one scum player harassed me about my posting.

[ICEninja]

I also think crazy is the most likely scum. I'll do a close review of Ranger, who is probably my only remaining significant town read just to make sure I'm not wrong about him, then post my reads on all the remaining players.

Mod, I'm pretty sure inHim isn't voting on the account that he's dead. He probably doesn't need to be on the "not voting" list.

[RangeroftheNorth]

The main reasons I think crazy is inHim's partner are his defense of inHim here and here, followed by his retraction of that defense after other people pointed it out.

Yesterday, he seemed to be consistently looking for someone besides inHim to lynch, even after he said he was more convinced of inHim's scumminess.

[Peabody]

DRK's post 384 and post 394 look townish. DRK is someone I am going to have to think about a bit more. He made my scumlist yesterday, but today, I'm not so sure anymore.

I'm more concerned about crazypianist, and I gave the gist of my reasoning in post 376:

I am ready for the hammer to fall. I think inHim's flip has the potential of giving us some good information regarding crazypianist. I have a hunch that there is something beyond the apparent play of crazy: first, defending against the arguments toward inHim based on day 1 (though he had a slight scum read on inHim based on evidence in day 1), and second, turning his 'slightly scummy' read on inHim to a more significant scummy read on him as inHim's impending lynch became more apparent. It just... it looks like bussing. My accusation is only a hunch with no evidence. Let's see how inHim flips.

Crazy's defense of inHim before inHim ever replied to the accusations are not sitting right with me. Also, the fact that crazy gave inHim an out when he suggested AMP was probably just a newb here looks really bad. Crazy's defense of inHim looked forced, but as the lynch became more apparent, crazy jumped on the wagon.

I have another (but weaker) reason, but I'm going to wait until a little later in the day to reveal it.

vote crazypianist

[crazypianist1116]

Well I see I'm lynch candidate #1 for today.
All I can say regarding my actions yesterday is that I didn't feel that inhim and the rest of his slot's day 1 actions constituted a lynch. He then proceeded to be useless day 2 and thus I felt he should have been lynched for that.

@RotN: If you thought my pointing fingers at other people was scummy, point out where my reasons were flawed. I'm not going to let other people's scuminness slide under the carpet just because one person is prime for a lynch.

[Quilford]

After rereading the last couple of pages once again, I'm also going to
VOTE: crazypianist1116
for the reasons I presented here.