I'll probably get stoned for this, but my gut is telling me that the players you find scummiest in Empking, Hiplop and Quilford are my top townreads. I'll have to try and justify that somehow now that I've said it. sigh.
Sure, the L-1 reason for Quilford was horrendous by Hiplop, but I know his scum meta and this doesn't seem to follow suit :/
Scott deserves to be lynched today, IMO, becasue of his tendancy to find NOTHING scummy in the first 7 pages. If that was true there would have been nothing to talk about for 7 pages. he then deflects by saying I'm scummy for trying to get him to share with us the things he's found scummiest. Aside from that nothing merits more than a null read from him at best.
Charter seems a bit anti-town so far, but that could just be playstyle. His massclaim Joke-trap thing could have been a hazard had we less experienced players, and his post-claim Quilford pushing seems artificial. Quilford is most obvtown even more now.
Faraday wrote:hey empy, what do you think of twistedspoon?
and what do you think of this Twistedspoon fellow?
@Hiplop: I noticed you missed our good friend Sloth off of your list. What is your read on him then?
@Neuky: you seem to have quite a mixed opinion on quilford, or so I gather from your last post. What is your opinion on Charter and who might your top scumread be?