Hello everyone. First off; my take on the whole "town read" argument. Everything should be questioned, the more useful information we have to work with, the better. Than said, the speculation on the various scenarios put forth by Rhinox and ThAdmiral (#109) is just a list of variables. We all know there are many variables and possibilities. Listing all the ways scum/town might claim town reads on other scum/town is needless unless each possibility is backed up by an
in game
example. There's no point in listing possibilities for which the conditions have not been met.
Speaking of many possibilities:
Mitsuru Kirijo wrote:Also, I don't want to hammer nor am I afraid to hammer. If I was scummy in wanting to hammer but being afraid to hammer, I'd be hammering town, would I not? As such, I would be encouraging this wagon, rather than discouraging it. I don't understand the reasoning behind your vote.
That's a
whole
lot of WIFOM. What did you hope to accomplish by giving such a convoluted response?
EmpTyger wrote:To me, the jump onto kuz feels like simple opportunism.
Kind of like your #55, a blatant attempt to start a wagon... for coming in a bit late?
Fishythefish wrote:EmpTyger wrote:kuz:
th3kuzinator wrote:Why you both are assuming malicious intent behind the question is beyond me.
Well, why *shouldn't* they assume malicious intent? This is a game of mafia, after all.
And why should "it's my playstyle" give you carte blanche to do whatever-you-want?
I don't like this much, particularly in the context of kuz being under attack. The first sentence is just nonsense - of course everyone should assume the
possibility
of malicious intent, but assuming malicious intent to make your case is arguing from your conclusions.
I agree with this. The whole arguing from conclusions thing also applies to Rhinox and ThAdmiral's list of possibilities I mentioned above, i.e. listing some town read scenarios and then using those to make your point.
Between the contrived listing of possibilities, arguing about town reads, and speculating about why kuz left, I don't feel like there's enough at this point to make my vote.
C-Worl wrote:Hey Archaist who
is
are your partner(s)?
Fixed. The town. Who is/are yours?