Feysal wrote:Onward to my suspects. I haven't seen a satisfactory explanation from inHim for his suspicions, in fact I've seen no new posts from him at all. However, when I read him in isolation I realized my chronology was off. Now I wonder if the way he changed his read of chesskid was because he noticed the same thing I did. Nevertheless, I'm somewhat disturbed by the curt posting style and absence of arguments in his posts, I'll need to check some scum games of his. For now,
Vote: inHimshallibe
This looks like a town tell to me. Feysal could have chosen one of the already established targets and pushed that, but he's looking elsewhere.
Pine wrote:It seems like I'm moving towards a lynch. Someone has to be the first sacrifice, and if it has to be Town, it may as well be me. From this point on, I am treating it as my job to beat the bushes and flush out as many scum as I can.
This also means that I will largely stop defending myself, and will not be answering questions from my scum/anti-Town reads. My Town flip will vindicate this stance and give added credence to my reads for the Town to go after.
I'll start tomorrow morning with a full re-read and begin shaking trees.
PE: I've already answered most of that, Icey, and in accordance with the above policy, will not be wasting my time any further with you. Fear not, you'll be featured and get your answers.
Pine wrote:I intend to self-vote and push my lynch when I finish. I have nothing to lose, and Town has everything to gain from this tactic.
Hell, if I'm NOT lynched and flipped to confirm the validity of my reads, it's an exercise in futility.
The problem with this logic is that you're lucky if people even bother to notice your reads right after your flip. They'll surely forget about them within a game day. So then all we're left with is a dead townie who didn't do anything to stop their wagon.
To see a similar situation, I tried your exact same tactic in
Ozy and Millie Mafia. It doesn't work.
Amrun wrote:No, he said I had circular logic. I asked him how, and he said, "Well, I guess you don't, but I also thought you voted two people in the same post, which is scummy, but you didn't do that either". So basically I never did any of the things he accused me of - but HE has done them, as I pointed out - but still votes for me just because he wants to look consistent.
That is how I read his posts. I'm asking around because I want to see if others read them the same way.
+1. Amrun is right about Beefster.
Bunnylover wrote:Town does not give up.
FALSE. I'll dig up multiple examples if you need them. This is a LIE.
Beefster wrote:Why so defensive?
It's called reaction testing, my friend. Yes, my initial reasoning wasn't great, but your reaction doesn't seem genuinely townie to me. Even though I have my vote on you, you're panicking over essentially nothing. Mind you there are only 2 votes on you right now. I don't see what the big deal is. You're responding as if you have something to lose.
**SNIP**
Pine is really starting to make me nervous with his self-lynch plan. I have never seen that tactic used by pro-town players.
FoS: Pine
I love when people make shit arguments, someone points out the argument is shit, and the person goes "I WAS JUST REACTION FISHING! DUH".
And by love I mean hate. Cause it's scummy.
And the FOS is so weak its scary.
SGR wrote:LMP, do you usually put so much emphasis on getting out of RVS?
All the time. If you need supporting evidence I'll be happy to dig it up. For starters, here is one I know of off the top of my head.
Secret Invasion Mafia. For one, I find that arguing about getting out of RVS is much more productive than just sitting around in RVS.
SGRaaize wrote:According to Snow_Bunny, claiming is the worst possible thing you can do. So that didn't see much of a good move. Regardless, I'l
Unvote
Can we please lynch this guy? Or Beefster?
Icey wrote:What does everyone think of RBT?
I've had up close and personal experience with RBT-lurker-scum, so I'm watching this with great interest.
Mana_Ku wrote:So you rather started a new 'wagon', because?
If I type slower and in capital letters will it make it easier to understand!? I WAS CATCHING UP TO THE GAME. I VOTED WHERE I WANTED TO WHEN I WANTED TO WITH NO REGARDS TO STARTING A NEW WAGON OR JOINING AN EXISTING WAGON.
Conclusions:
Pine wagon is BAD BAD BAD. Pine is town telling all over the place.
1 of Beefster or SGR should die today.
Town-o-meter
TOWN
Pine
Feysal
implosion
Albert B. Rampage
IceyCupcake
Amrun
CryMeARiver
BabySpice
Zdenek
Dry-fit
chesskid3
Mana_Ku
PeregrineV
Katy
Bunnylover
SnakePlissken
WrathChild
inHimshallibe
gandalf5166
Riceballtail
Beefster
SGRaaize
SCUM
As always reads are clearer at the poles and fuzzy in the middle.